Hideyuki F.
Arata†
*ab and
Hiroyuki
Fujita
a
aInstitute of Industrial Science (IIS), The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, 153-8505, Japan. E-mail: arata@sanken.osaka-u.ac.jp
bJapan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS), Tokyo, Japan
First published on 6th May 2009
To establish general-purpose methods and tools for biological experiments on a short time scale is an essential requirement for future research in molecular biology because most of the functions of living organisms at the molecular level take place on a time scale from 1-second to millisecond. Thermal control with on-chip micro-thermodevices is one of the strongest and most useful ways to realize biological experiments at molecular level on these time scales. Novel biological phenomena revealed by the experiments using micro-thermodevices on a 1-second and millisecond time scale will be shown for the proof. Finally, the advantages and impact of this methodology in molecular biology will be discussed.
![]() Hideyuki Arata | Hideyuki Arata was born in Okinawa, Japan, in 1980. He received his BS, MS, and PhD degrees in electrical engineering from the University of Tokyo in 2002, 2004, and 2008, respectively. He is currently a postdoctoral researcher at the Curie Institute, Paris. He has been a research fellow of the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) since 2006. He has received numerous prizes, such as the JSME Young Engineers Award 2005 (as the youngest awardee). His research interests are in the interdisciplinary field of molecular biology and nano-micro technology, such as Single Molecule Biophysics, Lab on a chip, and bioMEMS. |
![]() Hiroyuki Fujita | Hiroyuki Fujita received his BS, MS and PhD degrees in electrical engineering from the University of Tokyo in 1975, 1977, and 1980, respectively. Since 2000, he has been Director of the Center for International Research on MicroMechatronics. He has been a Lecturer (1980–1981), an Associate Professor (1981–1993), and a Professor (since 1993) with the Institute of Industrial Science at the University of Tokyo. He is currently engaged in the investigation of microelectromechanical systems fabricated by IC-based processes and applications to optics, and bio/nanotechnology. He is also interested in autonomous distributed microsystems made by MEMS technology. |
Insight, innovation, integrationMost of the functions of living organisms at molecular level take place on a time scale from 1-second to millisecond, thus this is one of the most important time scales in studying biomolecular functions. Top-down technology enabled on-chip thermocontrol devices of a few hundreds to a few tens of micrometres in size showing the advantages of miniaturization such as fast response, compactness, and mass productivity. As a result, easy access to real-time controlling and probing of biologically important phenomena such as enzymatic activity, mechanical motion of motor proteins, and denaturation dynamics of fluorescent proteins, which happen on a second to millisecond time scale, became possible. The impact and potential of this methodology in molecular biology will also be discussed. |
Measuring response due to external stimulation by changing the environment rapidly has been one of the most common and widely applicable ways to measure the dynamics on a short time scale. To change the chemical environment3 or temperature4–6 by laser pulses has been a powerful strategy. However, an observed material often requires biological mutation or chemical treatments beforehand and the laser heating may damage fragile materials not only by the effect of temperature rising but also by exposure to excess light. They also need expensive setups which require high skill to operate. These heating techniques are difficult to couple with thermosensors for simultaneous temperature monitoring.
Especially when measuring at single molecule level, these techniques also involve problems to do with collecting large quantities of data for statistical analysis, because in those experiments the experimental setup must be manually operated from one run to another. This has been a major limiting factor for performing a series of experiments in this field. Therefore, high speed experimental tools must be capable of obtaining large quantities of data. It is preferable that these tools are widely applicable to many kinds of biomaterials and allow experiments with small amounts of samples. The tools must be compact, cheap, and mass producible to allow a series of experiments in typical biological laboratories. For these requirements, temperature transition by a miniaturized thermocontrol device consisting of a microheater and a micro-thermosensor is one of the strongest and most widely applicable strategies. Since thermal mass (heat capacity which is an extrinsic property) is proportional to the third power of the size, the response speed of the thermocontrol device is increased drastically by miniaturization.
So-called top-down technologies, mainly by the semiconductor microfabrication process, have enabled us to manufacture and fabricate structures of a submicrometre scale.8 The smallest functional unit in a commercial electronic device has reached the 10 nm scale.9 MEMS (Micro Electro Mechanical Systems)10 and μTAS (micro total analysis systems)11–15 technologies offer the advantages of batch fabrication of numbers of devices as well as an ability to integrate multiple functional units in a small area, which is important for developing smart and sophisticated devices. MEMS technologies have been applied successfully to sensors,16 actuators,17 microreactors,18 radio-frequency devices,19 and optical devices.20–24 μTAS enables rapid, highly sensitive and parallel biological/chemical analysis with small amounts of samples thanks to the merits of miniaturization. In handling small amounts of samples in a microscale, it realizes short diffusion distances, high interface-to-volume ratio, and small thermal mass.25 Material costs and the amount of waste can also be reduced. Miniaturized devices also allow samples to be analyzed in typical biological laboratories. Various biological experiments have been realized by microchip technology26 frequently by combination with micro-nano manipulation techniques.27 Taking those advantages, top-down technologies have been applied to thermal devices such as high-speed PCR,6,28–32 both in flow-through-type29,30 and in thermal-cycling-type,6,31,32 or high-speed microcalorimetry.33–36 Microfabricated fluidic channels, heaters, temperature sensors, and fluorescence detectors were integrated to analyze nanolitre-size DNA samples.37 Therefore, top-down technologies can meet the demands in molecular biology mentioned above, including fast response, high sensitivity, and obtaining larger quantities of data by establishing systems and tools for biological experiments on a short time scale.
The purpose of this report is to review, discuss and state the importance of the strategy of high speed temperature transition by miniaturized thermocontrol devices which enable real-time biomolecular experiments on a short time scale for microscopic observation. Finally, the impact of this strategy and future prospects will be discussed. For more detailed information, especially on the device fabrication and the experimental conditions, we encourage readers to refer to the original papers.38–45
Fig. 1 shows a micro-thermodevice fabricated by patterning nickel (hereinafter, Ni) on a glass plate.38Ni was chosen as the material for both the heater and the thermosensor to simplify the fabrication process. The diameter of the circular microheater was 400 μm, and the width of the heater wire was 20 μm. The Ni-patterned glass plate was wire bonded to pitch conversion board to enhance the pitch between the electrodes. The heater raises the temperature by joule heating and the thermoresistive-sensor detects the temperature from its resistivity. The input of the microheater was controlled and the output of the thermosensor was calculated into temperature using commercial software. Temperature uniformity and the response speed of the heater were measured by using Rhodamine B as a temperature detector.39 This was also estimated by conducting numerical simulation by a finite element method using commercial software (FEMLab) the results of which showed excellent agreement with experimental results. Consequently, the temperature accuracy within the circular heater was measured to be 3 °C and the response speeds were 71.5 and 56.9 K s−1 for temperature rise and fall, respectively. This response time is comparable with that of a PCR chip, whose volume of reaction chamber is in the same order; about 80 °C s−1 for heating and 60 °C s−1 for cooling.32
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Ni-patterned glass plate, which is placed on a pitch conversion board to enhance the pitch between the electrodes and connected to lead wires (left). Microscopic view of the integrated microheater and micro-thermosensor (right). H. F. Arata et al., Appl. Phys. Lett., 2006, 88, 083902, American Institute of Physics. Reproduced by permission. |
This micro-thermodevice of 1-s response time was applied to several biological experiments. Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP)49 of a single DNA molecule was achieved in a polyacrylamidegel -based microcontainer coupled with the micro-thermodevice.40 Hence, total time for reaction including detection was less than 1 hour. This system could also be applied to study single molecule PCR.41 This micro-thermodevice was successfully adopted to switch the gel –sol transition of thermally responsive supramolecular nanomeshes50,51 which enabled on/off switching of the rotary motion of F1.42 This result suggests that intelligent soft materials such as supramolecular hydrogels give promise of the integration of biomolecules and hard materials for developing novel semi-synthetic nano-biodevices. In the following sections, our major results using this micro-thermodevice will be shown.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Schematic of the observation system of a single F1 molecule. F1 is attached to the glass plate and microbeads are attached to the rotary axis of F1 (top). Microscope view of two microbeads being rotated by a single F1 molecule. The angular velocity is 1.5 rps (bottom). |
Angular velocity control of F1 rotation was observed by altering the temperature in 1 s. Angular velocity changed from 1.2 to 4.4 rps and came back to 1.7 rps when the temperature was altered from room temperature to 50 °C and back to room temperature (Fig. 3). When the temperature was increased gradually, the velocity of F1 increased gradually, but stopped at a temperature less than 50 °C since the enzyme cannot survive for long at high temperatures. To measure the velocity at higher temperatures, the temperature should be altered rapidly, as shown in Fig. 3(a), because the enzyme can tolerate higher temperatures for a short period, even at temperatures higher than that which would denature it in a steady state. Acceleration of angular velocity while raising the temperature can be associated with two factors. One is decrease of the viscous drag of water. The other is torque increase in the F1 molecule. The torque increase depending on the temperature can be calculated by subtracting the effect of the viscous drag of water, which can be numerically estimated. Consequently, it was proved that a rotating F1 has a tendency to show higher torque at higher temperatures with the estimated increasing rate of 4% per 10 °C as shown in Fig. 3(b). This result shows that the performances, both torque and velocity, of molecular machines can be controlled by this methodology. This may be a useful method when future organic–inorganic hybrid nanosystems are established.55,56
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (a) Time course of the rotation of F1 while switching the temperature. Angular velocity changed from 1.2 rps to 4.4 rps and back to 1.7 rps. (b) Standardized angular velocity dependent on temperature. Lines represent the data when the temperature was increased gradually. Star-shaped dots represent the data obtained by rapid temperature alternation. H. F. Arata et al., Appl. Phys. Lett., 2006, 88, 083902, American Institute of Physics. Reproduced by permission. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) SEM image of a silicon-patterned cylindrical mold. (b) SEM image of patterned PDMS sheets with volume of 55 fL. |
The combined system of a micro-thermodevice and microcontainers enabled measurement of the enzymatic activity of β-galactosidase (hereinafter β-gal) at high temperatures by altering the temperature rapidly. β-gal is widely used as a reporter in molecular biology.61β-gal is the enzyme that catalyzes hydrolysis of fluorescein di-β-D-galactopyranoside (FDG). A fluorogenic substrate of β-gal, FDG in a buffer solution is hydrolyzed to fluorescein. Fluorescent intensity represents the amount of product produced by β-gal. Therefore, we can measure the activity of β-gal from the time course of the fluorescent intensity. In the steady state, the activity of β-galversus temperature shows a peak at around 45–50 °C. It decreases with temperature after the peak and there is complete cessation above 60 °C (Fig. 5(a)). β-gal was captured in microcontainers mounted on the micro-thermodevice to manage rapid alternation of exposed temperature. In this experiment, the volume of a microcontainer was 60 fL; at a β-gal concentration of 37 nM, each container contained around 1300 enzymes . Applying 60 °C heat pulses of 4 s, we successfully increased the activity of the enzyme (Fig. 5(b)). This indicates that the enzymes remained active and increased their activity over a short period, even at temperatures that cause damage after prolonged exposure. This method gives new kinetic information and allows us to measure the temperature stability of biomolecules. It also makes it possible to perform highly sensitive biochemical experiments which can be applied to highly sensitive biosensors .
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Activity of β-galvs. the temperature measured by bulk experiment. It shows higher activity at a temperature higher than room temperature and shows a peak at 45–50 °C, a decrease with temperature after the peak and complete cessation of activity over 60 °C. (b) Activity controlled by temperature pulses with a duty ratio of 1/3 (four pulses in 48 s). The increase rate of the fluorescent intensity changed from 0.28 to 0.56. The lines follow the intensity of four individual microcontainers. H. F. Arata et al., Anal. Chem., 2005, 77, 4810, American Chemical Society. Reproduced by permission. |
To realize those experiments, a thin-film microheater was fabricated by patterning Ni on a glass plate with sputtering and photolithography45 (Fig. 6). The microheater heats up its internal and external area by joule heating. The heater wire is 200 nm thick and 2 μm wide. The size of the microheater is 20 μm × 20 μm. Such dimensions realize 1 millisecond temperature control. A microfabricated PDMS sheet was mounted onto a glass substrate with thin film microheaters to form microcontainers as described in section 3.2. In this experiment, the cylindrical containers were 4 μm in diameter, 2.2 μm in height, and 28 femtolitres in volume. Samples were captured in microcontainers mounted on the micro-thermodevice to manage rapid alternation of exposed temperature as described in section 3.2. The microcontainers located in the internal area of the microheater were used during the experiments because the temperature of the internal area was proved to be sufficiently uniform by conducting numerical simulation by a finite element method using commercial software (FEMLab).45
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) A Ni microheater fabricated on a glass plate. The bright part is patterned Ni and the dark part is naked glass. (b) A micro-patterned PDMS sheet. Cylindrical holes are patterned on one side of a PDMS sheet. The bottom right is an expanded picture taken by a scanning electron microscope (SEM). (c) A micro-patterned PDMS sheet was mounted on a microheater fabricated glass plate to form microcontainers. Buffers with proteins in microcontainers were heated up by a collocated microheater. H. F. Arata et al., Lab Chip, 2008, 8, 1436, Royal Society of Chemistry. Reproduced by permission. |
When the temperature was raised to slightly under 100 °C in 1 ms, the fluorescence intensities of the protein-containing microcontainers were quenched owing to the denaturation of GFPs. The quenching curves of GFPs have a rapid fall at the beginning and a slow decrease afterwards, as shown in Fig. 7(a). This suggests that they have two time constants. The quenching curves of red fluorescent proteins were measured by the same method. Fig. 7(b) shows the quenching curves of red fluorescent proteins. Denaturation was completed in 5 to 10 ms for red fluorescent proteins. The large difference in response time between GFPs and red fluorescent proteins may be due to the strong thermal stability of GFPs65,67 compared to that of typical proteins. Fitting with bi-exponential decay by the least squares method iteration proved that rAcGFP denatured with time constants of 5 ms and 75 ms, while rGFPuv denatured with time constants of 10 ms and 130 ms. The bi-exponential decay may be caused by the reverse process of two-states renaturation observed by Ueno et al.3 in which a GFP molecule recovered its fluorescence in around 30 s after being denatured by acid. The difference of the parameters of the fitted curve between rAcGFP and rGFP may be explained by the difference in the position of mutated amino acids.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Time courses of fluorescence intensity of fluorescent proteins in microcontainers. The fluorescent intensity of each microcontainer is plotted in line. The average intensity of all the containers is plotted in triangles. The fluorescent intensity started quenching when the microheater was switched on at an elapsed time of 0 s. (a) Group of curves in the graph are from five individual microcontainers containing the same concentration of rAcGFP.68 The quenching showed bi-exponential decay. (b) The group of curves in the graph is from five individual microcontainers containing the same concentration of rDsRed.69 Insets show the same data over a longer time range. The quenching was completed within 5–10 ms. H. F. Arata et al., Lab Chip, 2008, 8, 1436, Royal Society of Chemistry. Reproduced by permission. |
They also have potential applications in industrial research. For example, it might be possible to use a heat sensitive catalytic enzyme at high temperatures by altering temperatures rapidly. It might also be possible to produce heat sensitive products by avoiding prolonged heating which may induce unfavorable sub-reactions. Those applications of microdevices might promote protein engineering such as the development of industrial biocatalysts .70 Additionally, the micro-thermodevice is applicable to a variety of biomaterials because the device allows us to perform experiments without any mutations or biochemical treatment of the material itself. We observed the thermal quenching dynamics of double stranded DNA with fluorescent intercalator SYBR Green, which completed in 10 ms, by a micro-thermodevice of 1 ms response time.71 It can also be used as a means of differential calorimetry because the proposed micro-thermodevices can monitor the temperature rise at a definite energy input in real-time on a short time scale as performed by 3D-MEMS devices which are cumbersome to manufacture and use.33–36 This enables highly sensitive measurements of specific heat capacity, which is an intrinsic material property, change during various biological functions at the molecular level, such as denaturation of nucleic acids, phase transition of lipids or protein denaturation, whose detecting method has hitherto been limited mostly to fluorescent illumination. As another potential application, this micro-thermodevice can be used to study the thermosynthesis concept, biological free energy gain from thermal cycling, whose resulting overall origin of life model may suggest new explanations for the emergence of the genetic code and the ribosome.72,73
Theoretically, further miniaturization of thermodevices may achieve response times faster than milliseconds. For example, microsecond to millisecond protein dynamics, which are necessary for catalysis and are an intrinsic property of enzymes as shown by NMR (Nuclear Magnetic Resonance) relaxation dispersion experiments for cyclophilin A,74,75 can be examined by those devices. However, when the size of the heater gets close to the size of one biomolecule, for example, in the order of a few nanometres to a few tens of nanometres for a typical protein, a single biomolecule must be isolated and put on to a heater. To overcome this alignment problem, improving the spatial resolution of chemical treatment for selective patterning of proteins, such as Ni-NTA surface chemical treatment,52 will be required. The other way is to manipulate a sample molecule mechanically with the precision of a few nanometres by techniques of nano-isolation and -manipulation of biomolecules using MEMS devices; for example, studies to isolate a single DNA molecule using a 2 μm-wide microchannel76 or trapping a single DNA molecule using microtweezers.77 A micro-thermodevice of this type is highly applicable to microfluidic systems because a thermodevice patterned on a 2D substrate can control the temperatures of any part of 3D structures such as flow channels and reactors mounted on it. Another considerable limitation for this methodology is the fact that a microheater itself is invisible by optical microscope under scale of diffraction limit, 200 nm for a typical optical microscope. Those nanodevices must be designed to facilitate alignment between an invisible heater and protein. Experiments using nanoscale thermodevices are expected to be realized by integration with these MEMS/NEMS (Nano Electro Mechanical Systems)-based manipulation technologies. This may lead to the high-throughput screening of experiments which have so far been performed manually. Hence, these devices are likely to accelerate experimental work and promote understanding of basic phenomena in life science.
Footnote |
† Current affiliation: Curie Institute, Paris, 75005, France. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2009 |