Nathan J.
Saetveit
,
Stanley J.
Bajic
,
David P.
Baldwin
and
R. S.
Houk
*
Ames Laboratory, US Department of Energy, Department of Chemistry, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa 50011, USA. E-mail: rshouk@iastate.edu; Fax: +1-515-294-5233; Tel: +1-515-294-9462
First published on 28th September 2007
A differential mobility analyzer (DMA) passes laser ablation (LA) particles and agglomerates within a narrow range of electrical mobilities to the inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS). No particle collection or offline particle analysis is required. Fractionation is assessed with the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio. Results presented in this paper support previous findings that ns LA provides many small Zn-rich particles and some much larger Cu-rich particles and that fs LA produces large agglomerates of small particles. The composition of the aerosol produced by fs LA falls between the relatively Zn-rich and Cu-rich extremes of ns LA. Femtosecond LA provides elemental ratio measurements that remain more stable with respect to time, which allows a greater degree of confidence in LA results. Even though some parameters besides pulse length differ between the lasers compared in this study, the suppression of particle size related fractionation with fs LA can be attributed to pulse length.
Many causes of fractionation have been investigated in the different stages of LA-ICP-MS, and various methods have been explored to compensate for, reduce, or eliminate fractionation. Fractionation due to the LA process is affected by many laser parameters, including wavelength,8–12 energy density,12–15 and pulse duration,11,16–21 which can affect the size distribution and composition of the aerosol. Fractionation has also been attributed to transport and ICP effects, which are also affected by particle size.22–29 Smaller particles generally lead to less ICP-induced fractionation. Still, thermal effects of the LA process, such as melting, differential vaporization among elements, and re-ablation of deposited particles, can cause fractionation even if large particles are not transported effectively to the plasma or are filtered from the aerosol before reaching the ICP. Relative to ns lasers, fs lasers have been reported to reduce or eliminate these thermal effects, providing both a more nearly stoichiometric aerosol and smaller particles with a narrower size distribution.5,16
To investigate particles resulting from LA, techniques such as optical particle sizing, particle impaction, and differential mobility analysis have been demonstrated.30,31 Optical particle sizing can determine size distributions of LA aerosols, but it cannot transmit a selected range of particle size for direct, online analysis with ICP-MS. Particle impaction can be used to analyze and measure a wide range of particle and agglomerate sizes and shapes and can be used as a low pass size filter for online analysis. However, to analyze a particle size range defined by both a low and a high cutoff, the technique is limited to offline analysis, which is tedious and time consuming. Only differential mobility analysis offers the flexibility to directly select and examine particles and agglomerates in a specific electric mobility diameter range during online elemental analysis by ICP-MS.
In this work, particles of a range of sizes are produced during LA, and a range of particles and agglomerates centered around a desired electrical mobility diameter (dm) is selected by a DMA and passed directly to the ICP-MS for elemental analysis. As noted elsewhere,31dm is not equivalent to particle volume or mass since the structure of the particle or agglomerate contributes to its electrical mobility. Therefore, particles are inseparable from agglomerates at each dm value of the DMA. Still, the DMA provides valuable insights into the effect of particle size on fractionation because it allows direct, online selection and variation of specific electrical mobility fractions of the total LA aerosol. While not the primary focus of this work, the time stability of elemental ratio measurements during rastering and single spot LA is also briefly investigated.
Because of their different volatilities, Cu and Zn in brass were chosen as the primary elements to examine particle size and laser effects on fractionation. Obtaining the “true” Cu+/Zn+ ratio is not the focus of this work. Since the experimentally determined Cu+/Zn+ ratio may be dependent on factors such as sampling position, ionization efficiency, differential atomization, and mass bias, this work is mainly concerned with changes or trends in the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio with dm. Any observed change in elemental signal ratio with respect to dm is evidence of particle size related fractionation at some dm. Otherwise, the same Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio would be obtained at all dm values.
A fiber chirped pulse amplification (FCPA) fs laser was used for fs LA (FCPA µJewel, IMRA America, Inc., Ann Arbor, MI, USA). This laser provides pulses of approximately 3.7 µJ and 370 fs at a wavelength of 1045 nm and a repetition rate of 100 kHz. The spot size was determined by the focus of the laser; after the experiments it was measured to be approximately 50 µm. The samples were placed in a home-made ablation cell, mounted on an xyz-translation stage, and viewed with a CCD camera.
Both lasers used cylindrical ablation cells with the gas entering the ablation region at the bottom and exiting at the top. For the ns laser, the standard ablation cell from CETAC was used: 25 mm high × 60 mm diameter, total volume 70 cm3, inlet 2 mm id. For the fs laser, a home-made, double-walled cell was used: 45 mm high × 50 mm diameter, total volume 90 cm3, inlet 4 mm id. The same Tygon tubing (4 mm id × ∼1 m long) was used to conduct the aerosol to the ICP in both cases. The same brass sample was ablated with the ns laser using either cell; the signal levels and noise behavior were similar. Thus, the cell geometry does not greatly affect the signal or noise behavior described below.
For the rastering experiments, the samples were moved under the stationary laser beam at approximately 30 µm s–1. Rastering times of 171 and 341 s (100 and 200 ICP-MS scans) were used for the ns and fs experiments, respectively.
For the ns single spot ablation experiments, a spot was continuously ablated at 10 Hz for approximately 120 s (70 ICP-MS scans through the mass range). For the fs single spot experiments, the laser very quickly drilled into the surface deep enough to be out of focus and below the ablation threshold. Therefore, limited signal was obtained for the fs single spot ablation experiments.
For each set of experiments (rastering and single spot ablation with both lasers on the samples, for a total of eight sets of experiments), data were acquired with the DMA for particles with a dm ranging from 50 nm to 1000 nm, in 25-nm increments. For the fs experiments, data acquired at dm = 100 nm and below were not included in the final plots because of low signal level. The sample gas flow was kept constant within each experiment so that changes in measured signals would only be attributable to dm.
Owing to the high voltage applied to the electrodes in the DMA, arcing can be a problem when using Ar as a carrier gas. Under the conditions of these experiments, an abrupt signal change, likely caused by arcing, was sometimes observed at dm > 1000 nm. In two experiments, single spot fs LA on NIST C1100 and rastering ns LA on NIST C1102, arcing may have been responsible for some artifacts at dm < 1000 nm (data not shown in figures). The data trends prior to the possible arcing are consistent with those in the other experiments. Since the trends were consistent between samples and for brevity, only the figures describing the results from one standard are presented for each laser (ns, NIST C1100; fs, NIST C1102). All data, including those not presented in the figures, are included in the summary in Table 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Isotope ratio plots for nanosecond LA of NIST C1100 brass: (a) rastering (1s error bars) and (b) single spot. For clarity, only the upper or lower halves of error bars are shown in (a). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Isotope ratio plots for femtosecond LA of NIST C1102 brass: (a) rastering (1s error bars) and (b) single spot. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Normalized elemental ratio plots for nanosecond LA of NIST C1100 brass: (a) rastering (1s error bars) and (b) single spot. |
The signal plots shown in Fig. 4 show a maximum in signal for both Cu+ and Zn+, centered at dm = 200 nm. The transfer function of the DMA, which is related to the width of the dm transmission window, increases with dm,31,32 which would bias the signal toward large dm. In addition, larger particles contain more analyte atoms. Since the plots show the largest signal count rate for smaller dm values, from 100 nm to 300 nm, more particles and/or agglomerates are produced in this range than at larger dm values. These findings are consistent with previous work.4,14,25
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Signal plots for nanosecond LA of NIST C1100 brass: (a) rastering (1s error bars) and (b) single spot. |
While the DMA cannot directly provide information about the nature of the particles being passed (i.e., whether they are single particles or agglomerates of smaller particles), some such information can be gleaned from the ICP-MS signal itself. There is a dramatic increase in the relative standard deviation of the ICP-MS signal with dm during the rastering experiment (4% for dm ≤ 200 nm to 18% for dm ≥ 600 nm), beginning at dm ∼ 400 nm (Fig. 4). This noise is likely caused by larger, single particles that are less completely vaporized, atomized, and ionized in the plasma, causing localized pockets of excess ions.36 At smaller particle sizes, all the particles and agglomerates are more extensively vaporized, atomized, and ionized, leading to a much more stable and less noisy ICP-MS signal.22 It is still likely, though, that agglomerates of smaller particles exist at all dm values included in this study.37
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Normalized elemental ratio plots for femtosecond LA of NIST C1102 brass: (a) rastering (1s error bars) and (b) single spot. |
The curves in Fig. 6 show that the majority of the ICP-MS signal comes from particles and agglomerates with dm > 200 nm. Previous work14,17 has shown that fs LA of brass produces an aerosol composed of agglomerates of very small particles. The current study supports this previous work: since most of the signal is found at higher dm values, the aerosol is composed of either a distribution of large particles or large agglomerates of small particles. However, the small relative standard deviations observed in the signal and ratio plots imply that there is not a distribution of large particles causing excessive ICP-MS signal fluctuation, but rather a size distribution of agglomerates composed of similar-sized, small particles.14,17
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Signal plots for femtosecond LA of NIST C1102 brass: (a) rastering (1s error bars) and (b) single spot. Note that error bars in (a) are smaller than the symbols. |
As described elsewhere,14,38,39 the particle re-condensation model describes a likely mechanism for production of these small particles. Since Zn is more volatile than Cu and would nucleate later in a saturated vapor, it is reasonable that the smallest condensed particles are relatively Zn-rich compared with the slightly larger condensed particles. Since smaller particles tend to agglomerate more readily than larger particles,17 it is expected that larger agglomerates would tend to be slightly Zn-rich, relative to smaller agglomerates.
Assuming the particle re-condensation model as the dominant particle formation mechanism, this qualitative explanation is consistent with the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratios shown in Fig. 5(a). Different Cu+/Zn+ signal ratios in particles of different sizes formed during fs LA are expected,14 but the overall Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio is still much more uniform throughout the dm range in fs LA than in ns LA.
C1100 | C1102 | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Single spot | Rastering | Single spot | Rastering | ||||||
d m/nm | ns | fsa | ns | fs | ns | fs | nsa | fs | |
a Possible arcing was observed for dm > 600 nm. | |||||||||
Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio | <300 | 3.77 | 6.55 | 2.83 ± 0.13 | 6.54 ± 0.48 | 4.72 | 7.66 | 3.57 ± 0.20 | 8.68 ± 0.36 |
300–575 | 4.07 | 6.41 | 5.15 ± 0.60 | 5.97 ± 0.60 | 5.52 | 7.75 | 6.29 ± 0.60 | 7.87 ± 0.25 | |
≥600 | 5.47 | 5.24 | 7.56 ± 1.4 | 5.80 ± 0.32 | 10.46 | 7.44 | 12.53 ± 1.9 | 7.25 ± 0.22 | |
All | 4.21 | 6.17 | 5.25 ± 0.72 | 5.89 ± 0.42 | 6.38 | 7.58 | 9.24 ± 1.2 | 7.55 ± 0.24 | |
Percentage of total signal | <300 | 41 | 14 | 37 | 5 | 39 | 8 | 18 | 5 |
300–575 | 41 | 64 | 24 | 32 | 37 | 41 | 27 | 38 | |
≥600 | 19 | 22 | 39 | 63 | 24 | 51 | 55 | 58 |
Different trends in the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio and signals with respect to dm are evident between ns and fs LA. Nanosecond LA aerosols in all experiments show a substantial increase in the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio in larger dm regimes, while aerosols in the fs LA experiments show a gradual decrease in the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio in larger dm regimes. In the ns LA experiments, even the least pronounced ratio difference between the lowest and highest dm regimes (single spot, NIST C1100) is larger than that in any of the fs LA experiments. In addition, the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratios for fs LA in all dm regimes fall between the Zn-rich and Cu-rich extremes of ns LA. This is not immediately clear for the case of ns single spot LA on C1100; the rise of the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio is found at higher dm than in other experiments (Fig. 3), which skews the average in the dm ≥ 600 nm regime to a somewhat lower value (maximum Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio, 7.03). Another trend observed is that the percentage of total signal obtained with ns LA was generally higher in lower dm regimes, while the opposite was normally true for fs experiments.
These trends, which are independent of sample and sampling style, along with the previous discussion regarding the differences in relative standard deviations of the ICP-MS signals or ratios, reinforce the predominant view that ns LA produces many small particles (dm < 300 nm) and some large, single, Cu-rich particles, while fs aerosols are predominantly agglomerates of small particles.
Since this work assesses particle size related fractionation through trends in the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratio with dm, obtaining the “true” Cu+/Zn+ value is not required. While an in-depth study of the overall stoichiometry of the LA aerosols would obfuscate the purpose of this paper as a fast, online, qualitative assessment of particle size related fractionation in readily available ns and fs lasers, it is still of some interest to assess the stoichiometry of the LA aerosols. To that end, the ratio of the Cu+/Zn+ signal ratios in the two standards was calculated [Cu+/Zn+(C1102)/Cu+/Zn+(C1100)] for all of the experiments to assess this type of fractionation. In the absence of fractionation, the true ratio, 1.284, would be expected. Table 3 shows a summary of this ratio determined for three dm regimes and for the overall aerosol. There is some deviation from the true value in the various dm regimes for experiments with both lasers, but the largest particles from ns LA demonstrate the highest degree of fractionation. Femtosecond LA gives an overall more stoichiometric aerosol than ns LA for both single spot and rastering LA. This method of looking at the overall stoichiometry of LA aerosols is not intended to be a comprehensive analysis, but rather a rudimentary assessment, of overall fractionation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Time stability of nanosecond LA: (a) rastering and (b) single spot. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Time stability of femtosecond rastering LA. Note that the dm axis is reversed as compared with Fig. 7. |
The two lasers were operated in their “out-of-the-box” state to compare ns and fs LA with readily available laser systems. The two lasers used in this study have obvious differences, including wavelength, repetition rate, and pulse duration, and these parameters could not be matched for the two systems. However, many of the parameters that differ between these two lasers, with the notable exception of pulse duration, would be expected to enhance particle size related fractionation for the fs laser, especially the longer wavelength and faster repetition rate. Since the fs laser suppressed particle size related fractionation, it is reasonable, based on previous research,5,14,16,17,25 to attribute this suppression largely to the much shorter pulse length.
Future studies will include more in-depth examination of the sub-100 nm regime for both rastering and single spot fs LA to gain further insight into the elemental composition of the particles throughout this particle size range. Other results using fast data acquisition are currently in preparation.40
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2008 |