Quadrupolar NMR crystallography guided crystal structure prediction (QNMRX-CSP) of zwitterionic organic HCl salts

Abstract

In this work, we benchmark quadrupolar NMR crystallography guided crystal structure prediction (QNMRX-CSP) for determining the crystal structures of two zwitterionic organic HCl salts, L-ornithine HCl (Orn) and L-histidine HCl·H₂O (Hist). These salts present an interesting challenge for QNMRX-CSP, as gas-phase geometry optimizations used to generate starting structures for the organic zwitterionic fragments fail to capture their correct solid-state geometries. To overcome this limitation, geometry optimizations using the COSMO water-solvation model are employed to generate initial structural models. Using this approach, QNMRX-CSP yields structural models of the two zwitterionic organic HCl salts that closely match experimentally determined crystal structures. In addition, the application of QNMRX-CSP to Hist represents a further step toward the de novo structural determination of solvated organic HCl salts, as Hist is the first benchmark system of this type to include a water molecule as a component of its crystal structure. This work is significant for its potential application to the structural determination of active pharmaceutical ingredients, which often feature complex organic components and solvated solid forms.