The effects of droplet stabilization by surfactants and nanoparticles on leakage, cross-talk, droplet stability, and cell adhesion

Abstract

Partially fluorinated nanoparticles (FNPs) have been proposed as a promising alternative for stabilising aqueous droplets in fluorinated oils. The exceptional energetic stability of FNPs at the droplet interface holds the potential for minimising leakage, enhancing stability, and promoting improved cell adhesion. However, their lower diffusion coefficient compared to surfactants presents challenges in achieving rapid droplet stabilisation, which is important in microfluidics applications. While several studies have focused on some of these aspects, a comprehensive study and direct comparison with conventional fluorosurfactants is still missing. In this manuscript, we undertake an examination and comparison of four crucial facets of both FNP- and surfactant-stabilised droplets: leakage of compounds, emulsion stability, droplet formation dynamics and cell adhesion. Contrary to what has previously been claimed, our findings demonstrate that FNPs only reduce leakage and cross-talk in very specific cases (e.g., resorufin), failing to provide enhanced compartmentalisation for highly hydrophobic dyes (e.g., rhodamine dyes). On the other hand, FNP-stabilised droplets indeed exhibit greater long-term stability compared to their surfactant-stabilised counterparts. Regarding the size of droplets generated via a diversity of microfluidic methods, no significant differences were observed between FNP-stabilised and surfactant-stabilised droplets. Finally, the previously reported improvements in cell adhesion and spreading on FNP-stabilised interfaces is limited to flat oil/water (o/w) interfaces and could not be observed within droplets. These comprehensive analyses shed light on the nuanced performance of FNPs and commercial fluorosurfactants as stabilising agents for aqueous droplets in fluorinated oils, contributing valuable insights for choosing the correct formulation for specific droplet-based microfluidics applications.