Substituent effects and the role of negative hyperconjugation in siloxycarbene rearrangements

Abstract

Substituent effects and the role of negative hyperconjugation in 1,2-silyl migration and decarbonylation of methoxy(substituted-siloxy)carbenes have been investigated using quantum chemical calculations and natural bond orbital analysis. It has been found that σ-electron-withdrawing substituents generally lower the barriers for 1,2-silyl migration and decarbonylation, consistent with symmetry-forbidden concerted rearrangements involving intramolecular front-side nucleophilic attack by the carbene lone pair at silicon and by the methoxy oxygen at silicon, respectively. However, while good linear Hammett correlations are obtained for 1,2-silyl migration, those obtained for decarbonylation are poor. In addition, there appears to be a relationship between the extent of pertinent hyperconjugative interactions in the siloxycarbene conformers and the ease of intramolecular reactivity. As a matter of fact, the finding that 1,2-silyl migration is more favorable than decarbonylation seems to be primarily related to stronger negative hyperconjugation between the carbene lone pair and the O–Si antibonding orbital, compared to that between the methoxy oxygen n(σ) lone pair and the O–Si antibonding orbital. Moreover, the activation enthalpies for 1,2-silyl migration decrease linearly with stronger negative hyperconjugation, although no such correlation could be established for decarbonylation.