Isabel
Abánades Lázaro
*,
María
Vicent-Morales
,
Guillermo
Mínguez Espallargas
and
Mónica
Giménez-Marqués
*
Instituto de Ciencia Molecular (ICMol), Universitat de València, Catedrático José Beltrán Martínez No 2, 46980 Paterna, Valencia, Spain. E-mail: isabel.abanades@uv.es; monica.gimenez-marques@uv.es
First published on 11th September 2023
Although Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) have received attention as drug delivery systems, their application in the delivery of macromolecules is limited by their pore size and opening. Herein, we present the synthesis of nanostructured MUV-2, a hierarchical mesoporous iron-based MOF that can store high payloads of the macromolecular drug paclitaxel (ca. 23% w/w), increasing its selectivity towards HeLa cancer cells over HEK non-cancerous cells. Moreover, this NanoMUV-2 permits full degradation under simulated physiological conditions while maintaining biocompatibility, and is amenable to specific surface modifications that increase its cell permeation, efficient cytosol delivery and cancer-targeting effect, further intensifying the cancer selectivity of paclitaxel.
Paclitaxel (PTX), with a molecular size of ca. 18 × 15 × 8 Å3, is one of the most effective chemotherapeutics,20 but due to its reduced solubility, its commercial form, Taxol, has associated side effects21 that have led to the urgency of finding alternative formulations.22,23 MOFs have been considered as encapsulating PTX materials, but given the notable molecular size of this drug, the number of reported studies of PTX@MOF formulations remains limited.24–27 For instance, theoretical studies have reported that PTX can only be loaded into Zr-bdc (UiO-66) if defective regions of missing clusters are present.28
To overcome the size limitation, mesoporous MOFs such as Zn-BPDC and Zn-azoBPDC,29 and the Fe-TCPP PCN-600,30 have been studied. However, despite these recent advances in MOF-based PTX formulations, direct evidence of PTX pore loading remains elusive and more importantly, a deficient therapeutic effect prevails as compared with the free-administered drug. Therefore, the development of new PTX@MOF formulations, including a comprehensive study of the composite nature, is desired to improve PTX therapeutic performance.
MUV-2 (MUV stands for materials of the University of Valencia), represented in Fig. 1a, is an stable iron-based mesoporous MOF built from the self-assembly of [Fe3(μ3-O)(COO)6] clusters and tetratopic tetrathiafulvalene tetrabenzoic acid (H4TTFTB) ligands forming a 3,6-connected network with ttp topology and formula (TTFTB)3[(Fe3O)(H2O)2(OH)]2.31 This hierarchical mesoporous MOF, with ca. 80% of calculated free volume, displays 1D hexagonal channels of ca. 3 nm and orthogonal microporous channels of ca. 1 nm.31–33 Despite exhibiting optimal biocompatible composition, MUV-2 has not been reported for drug delivery applications, mainly due to a lack of development in MOF miniaturization. Thus, we postulate that the development of mesoporous NanoMUV-2 shall be suitable for the storage and effective release of macromolecules such as PTX.
Herein, we present a comprehensive study of NanoMUV-2 as a PTX delivery system, thoroughly evaluating its colloidal and physiological stabilities, cellular internalization, surface modification and the effect of these variables on selective PTX delivery to cancer cells.
To assess the suitability of NanoMUV-2 for drug delivery applications, the colloidal stability of the activated material was evaluated by Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) 10X medium. NanoMUV-2 dispersed well in PBS 10X, showing average hydrodynamic diameters of ca. 220 nm (Fig. 1d), similar to the particle size determined by SEM (190 ± 59 nm). The chemical stability of NanoMUV-2 in PBS 10X (pH = 7.4) was investigated by UV-Vis spectroscopic determination of linker release (H4TTFTB). A fast degradation with a burst release of the linker occurs during the first 2 hours (ca. 60%), likely due to the high porosity and pore accessibility of NanoMUV-2, reaching complete degradation after 24 hours, as represented in Fig. 1e. This kinetic profile may be distinct under different PBS concentrations, for instance in cell growth media or the blood current, where MOFs are known to form a protein corona that prevents their degradation.36,37
Given the biocompatibility of its precursors, with the sodium salt of the ligand exhibiting a 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) after 72 hours of 0.64 ± 0.06 and 0.54 ± 0.05 mg mL−1 for cervix cancer HeLa and non-cancerous HEK cell lines respectively (see section S3.8 in the ESI†), we assessed the effect of NanoMUV-2 using the MTS assay (Fig. 1f). NanoMUV-2 exhibited optimal biocompatibility for both HeLa and HEK cell lines, with an IC50 of 1.92 ± 0.31 and 2.02 ± 0.32 mg mL−1 respectively, after 72 hours of incubation. In this regard, the IC50 of the maximum delivered ligand (corresponding to ca. 1.54 and 1.63 mg mL−1 of ligand, based on the molecular formula) is higher than the one of the free ligand salt in both cases, suggesting poor internalization and/or incomplete cytosol delivery.
Flow-assisted cell sorting (FACS) was used to monitor the cellular internalization of Cal@NanoMUV-2 by HeLa cervix cancer and HEK non-cancerous cells (see section S5.1 in the ESI†). Between a 3- and 4-fold increase in calcein internalization was confirmed by FACS after 2 hours of incubation with free calcein and Cal@NanoMUV-2, which was consistent through different concentrations (Fig. 2d) and further confirmed by confocal microscopy (see section S5.2 in the ESI†). Comparison of normalized cytoplasmic fluorescence determined through FACS upon incubation with Cal@NanoMUV-2 at 37 °C and 4 °C indicates that the MOF is mainly internalized through active transport such as endocytosis. Interestingly, the normalized cytoplasmic fluorescence upon incubation with Cal@NanoMUV-2 was slightly higher for HeLa than for HEK cells, ranging from 1.1- to 1.5-fold increase. Lysotracker was used to stain lysosomes and determine if Cal@NanoMUV-2 can undergo efficient calcein cytosol delivery.40 Manders' colocalisation coefficients indicate high colocalisation of calcein and lysosomes for both HeLa and HEK cells, which is in agreement with the reduced effect on cell viability when compared to the free linker salt.
The exceptionally large pores of MUV-2 make it an interesting candidate for the delivery of macromolecular therapeutic agents such as PTX. Essentially, we loaded PTX into NanoMUV-2 by a simple impregnation method revealing ca. 22% w/w loading after extensive washing as determined by UV-Vis (see section S6 in the ESI†). PXRD confirmed the structural integrity of the resultant PTX@NanoMUV-2 composite material (Fig. 3a). As control studies, we evaluated the well-studied MIL-100(Fe)5 and UiO-66(Zr)3 MOFs for PTX delivery (see section S7 in the ESI†), confirming negligible PTX inclusion as expected for the molecular size limitation.28 This was further confirmed by FT-IR and TGA,41 where PTX features were observed only for MUV-2 and not for the other MOFs, with TGA revealing similar loadings (ca. 23% w/w) to UV-Vis determination (Fig. 3b).
Moreover, N2 sorption analysis unequivocally confirmed the successful loading of PTX into NanoMUV-2 pores (see section S6 in the ESI†), as deduced from the pore size distribution analysis where the small mesopore contribution is reduced after loading together with a complete disappearance of pores ranging from 15.5 to 20.3 Å corresponding with the PTX molecular size (18.2 × 15.2 × 7.9 Å3 (Fig. 3c).20
After confirmation of significant PTX pore loading, we evaluated the cytotoxic effect of PTX@NanoMUV-2 and free PTX in cervix cancer HeLa cells and non-cancerous HEK cells (Fig. 3d). PTX@NanoMUV-2 was less cytotoxic than free PTX towards both cell lines, in agreement with partial lysosome colocalisation, but its anticancer selectivity was slightly increased (see section S8 in the ESI†), possibly due to the enhanced internalization of cancer cells. At low concentrations (0.02 mg mL−1 of MOF, corresponding to a maximum delivery of PTX of ca. 4.4 μg mL−1 as represented in Fig. 3d), PTX@NanoMUV-2 reduced HeLa cells’ proliferation to 60 ± 9% cell viability, but had no negative effect on HEK cells (119 ± 6% cell viability), whereas for a concentration of 4 μg mL−1 of free Taxol, HeLa cells’ viability is reduced to 19 ± 6% and HEK cells to 42 ± 5%. Calculating the anticancer selectivity based on the IC50 values of PTX delivery reveals an increase in selectivity from ca. 1.26 for free PTX to ca. 1.76 for PTX@NanoMUV-2.
NanoMUV-2 retains its crystalline structure after both surface coatings (see section S9 in the ESI†). Importantly, FT-IR and TGA revealed the successful attachment of both surface coatings, whereas different characterisation techniques such as Energy-Dispersive X-Ray (EDX), Proton Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (1H NMR), and TGA41 confirmed similar weight per cent for both coatings, 11.8 ± 0.8% w/w of Oct on NanoMUV-2-Oct and 8.9 ± 0.1% w/w of FA on NanoMUV-2-FA. N2 sorption studies suggested inner and outer surface coating, which is expected due to the large, accessible pores of MUV-2. The great colloidal stability of uncoated NanoMUV-2 in PBS 10X, was maintained for NanoMUV-2-Oct and further enhanced upon FA coating. Partial pore blockage by the surface coatings slows the degradation kinetics in PBS 10X due to the formation of a phosphate corona (Fig. S66 and S80, ESI†) that prevents further degradation,3 leading to a maximum of ca. 40% linker release for the hydrophobic-coated NanoMUV-2-Oct after 8 hours and to a maximum of ca. 70% linker release in the case of the hydrophilic NanoMUV-2-FA, as represented in Fig. 4a.
NanoMUV-2-Oct and NanoMUV-2-FA displayed a decrease in cell proliferation compared to the precursor NanoMUV-2 (Fig. 4b), which aligns with the cytotoxicity of the free ligand salt (see section S10 in the ESI†) and hence suggests higher cell internalization and/or more efficient cellular uptake routes towards cytosol delivery. The associated cytotoxicity was in general more pronounced for HeLa cervix cancer cells, and, nevertheless, none of the MOFs had a negative effect on cell proliferation up to 0.3 mg mL−1, whereas, at this concentration of PTX@NanoMUV-2, there is negligible cell viability for both cell lines.
Flow-assisted cell cytometry confirmed efficient calcein delivery into cells by the surface-modified drug delivery systems (see section S12.1 in the ESI†). Both surface coatings enhanced internalization by HeLa cells, with no statistical significance between the coated MOFs among high concentrations (Fig. 5a). However, the internalization of Cal@NanoMUV-2FA was more significant at low concentrations (0.005 and 0.05 mg mL−1 of MOF), with a ca. 13-fold increase compared to Cal@NanoMUV-2, whereas a ca. 3-fold increase was observed for Cal@NanoMUV-2-Oct, considering in both cases the calcein loading of the systems. For higher concentrations, the enhancement compared to Cal@NanoMUV-2 ranged from ca. 1.5 to 2-fold increase for both surface-coated MOFs.
The hydrophobic Cal@NanoMUV-2-Oct was less selective for HeLa cells than the hydrophilic Cal@NanoMUV-2-FA, observing for the later a reduced uptake for non-targeted HEK cells, more pronounced at higher concentrations (Fig. 5a). This explains the differences in the selective cytotoxicity of the surface-modified samples, with more cancer-selective internalization for Cal@NanoMUV-2-FA leading to more selective cytotoxicity. As cell internalization is enhanced for both HeLa and HEK cells in the case of Cal@NanoMUV-2-Oct, the cytotoxicity of NanoMUV-2-Oct towards both cell lines is more similar.
Confocal microscopy of HeLa Cells upon incubation with 0.2 mg mL−1 dispersions of MOFs for 2 hours agreed with the results obtained through FACS, showing an enhancement in the internalization of calcein (Fig. 5b). Moreover, more diffuse patterns of calcein were observed (Fig. 5c), suggesting efficient cytosol delivery and less endosome/lysosome trapping. This was confirmed by colocalisation studies using Lysotracker (Fig. 5d). HeLa cells showed a decrease in colocalized calcein, with diffusion patterns across the cytosol, whereas, in the case of HEK cells, the co-localization was similar, as represented by the differences in Manders' coefficients (Fig. 5e) (see section S12.2 in the ESI†).
Surface modifications were performed on PTX@NanoMUV-2 following similar procedures and optimal surface coating was confirmed by a number of techniques including 1H NMR, FT-IR, EDX and TGA among others, leading to PTX@NanoMUV-2-Oct and PTX@NanoMUV-2-FA with minimum PTX leaching (see section S13 in the ESI†). The effect of the coated PTX@MOF systems on cell proliferation was in agreement with the increase in internalization efficiency and cytosol delivery evaluated on the coated Cal@NanoMUV-2 analogues for HeLa cells (see section S14 in the ESI†).
Comparing the effect on cell proliferation of the three PTX-loaded MOFs as a function of the maximum concentration of PTX that could be delivered (Fig. 6a) reveals an increase in the cytotoxicity towards HeLa cells for both coated MOFs, possibly given that both systems can scape lysosome formation, leading to efficient cytosol delivery. As a result, the proposed NanoMUV-2 formulations reach similar PTX therapeutic effects in HeLa cells as compared to free PTX.
The cytotoxicity towards HEK cells was slightly reduced, possibly due to the reduced lysosomal scape for HEK cells. Thus, the anticancer selectivity of the drug-loaded materials based on the determined IC50 values (Fig. 6b) was increased from ca. 1.3 for free PTX and ca. 1.7 for PTX@NanoMUV-2, to ca. 8 for the surface-coated materials, suggesting that efficient cytosol delivery plays a more important role than selective internalisation.
The superior pore size and opening of MUV-2 allows significant pore loading of big biomolecules such as PTX (ca. 22% w/w), one of the most widely applied chemotherapeutics. Moreover, NanoMUV-2 has been proven to be versatile for surface modifications, which further enhance its colloidal stability, chemical stability towards degradation and drug release kinetics as well as cell permeation, efficient cytosol delivery and cancer targeting effects. Ultimately, we have shown that surface functionalization greatly enhanced PTX selectivity, opening the door for PTX resistance studies.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3tb01819a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |