D. W. Justin
Leung
,
Katherine R.
Laney
*,
Philip
Kenyon
,
Nicholas H.
Rees
,
Jean-Charles
Buffet
,
Chunping
Chen
* and
Dermot
O'Hare
*
Chemistry Research Laboratory, Department of Chemistry, University of Oxford, 12 Mansfield Road, Oxford, OX1 3TA, UK. E-mail: dermot.ohare@chem.ox.ac.uk; chunping.chen@chem.ox.ac.uk; Tel: +44 (0)1865 27268
First published on 14th March 2024
The effect of calcination conditions (ramp rate, calcination temperature and time) on the formation of Mg2Al layered double oxides (Mg2Al LDOs) as well as their CO2 capture performance, has been systematically investigated. This study explores novel insights into the intricate relationship between these calcination conditions and the resulting surface characteristics, which play a vital role in CO2 capture efficiency. Notably, it is revealed that a rapid ramp rate (100 °C min−1) significantly increases surface area and hydroxyl concentration, leading to a 69% increase in CO2 capture efficiency compared to slower ramp rate. Conversely, short calcination times (1 h) and fast ramp rates (100 °C min−1) are observed to compromise CO2 adsorption due to the presence of dehydrated LDHs. A critical acid:base ratio of 0.37, achieved from a fast ramp rate (100 °C min−1) at 400 °C for 2 h, was found as a key threshold for optimising surface properties, effectively balancing favourable hydroxyl and less favourable strong acid sites, thereby maximizing CO2 capture performance.
Both LDHs and their thermal derivatives (LDOs) have found successful applications in a wide range of areas, including catalysis, anionic adsorbents, flame retardants, gas barrier membrane and biomaterials.5–11 In particular, MgAl–CO3 LDOs have been demonstrated as promising CO2 adsorbents due to their inherent basicity, low adsorption heat, rapid adsorption/desorption kinetics, simple regenerability and good stability.7,8,12,13 Considerable efforts have been made to enhance the CO2 adsorption capacity including the optimisation of adsorption conditions, the control of calcination parameters (temperature and time), the design of LDHs/LDOs synthesis methods, as well as the incorporation of alkaline metal doping or other hybrid materials.12,14–17 However, the influence of the calcination process, including the parameters such as ramp rate, temperature and calcination duration time, on the surface chemistry of the material and its subsequent effects on CO2 capture through both chemisorption and physisorption has not been fully explored yet. Being able to optimise the calcination parameters for the LDHs materials and fundamentally understand their influence on the surface physio-chemical properties holds the key to unlock the full potential of LDHs/LDOs as efficient CO2 sorption materials.
Herein, we report a systematic study to investigate the impact of calcination conditions of Mg2Al LDHs ([Mg0.66Al0.34(OH)2](CO3)0.17(H2O)0.95) on the formation of Mg2Al LDOs. This study includes varying ramp rate (5–100 °C min−1), calcination time (1–6 h) and calcination temperature (100–600 °C). Additionally, we access the CO2 capture performance of the resulting calcined products. The physical property and surface chemistry of each calcined material was characterised extensively using N2 adsorption isotherms, the titration of surface hydroxyl groups, solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) and temperature programmed desorption (TPD).
The LDOs were obtained from the calcination at various conditions. The nomenclature for the obtained calcined LDH samples is as follows: calcination temperature (°C) – calcination time (h) – ramp rate (°C min−1). For example, 400-2 h-5 stands for a sample calcined at 400 °C for 2 h with a ramp rate of 5 °C min−1. For CO2 capture and TPD measurements, LDOs was generated by in situ calcination of LDHs. All other calcinations were carried out in a box furnace and the LDOs used immediately to prevent reconstruction.
Fig. 1 (a) BET surface area and pore volume for 400-2 h-X samples, (b) CO2 adsorption for 400-2 h-X samples at 40 °C and 100 kPa and (c) surface hydroxyl numbers for 400-2 h-X samples. |
CO2 adsorption measurements were carried out in 100% CO2 atmosphere at 40 °C and 100 kPa. In parallel with the observed trend in surface area, the total CO2 adsorption (Fig. 1b) increases from 0.35 to 0.59 mmol g−1 as the ramp rate increases from 5 to 100 °C min−1, displaying a significant 69% increase. Interestingly, this increase occurred despite the samples being calcined at the same temperature (400 °C). For ramp rates below 50 °C min−1, 34% of the CO2 was chemically adsorbed on the LDOs samples and this proportion further rose to 37% when the ramp rate reached 100 °C min−1. This suggests that the surface of the calcined samples might undergo changes with the rapid temperature increase, facilitating CO2 chemical adsorption. Furthermore, we noted that there is still an increase in CO2 uptake capacity when normalised to the surface area (Fig. S3†), implying that the enhanced CO2 capture is not solely attributed to an increase in surface area.
The surface hydroxyl number of the calcined samples was examed using the previously reported method.18 The results as shown in Fig. 1c reveal a significant increase in the surface hydroxyl number, rising from 0.60 to 1.26 mmol g−1 (twice as high) with the ramp rate increasing from 5 to 100 °C min−1. This notable shift in the hydroxyl numbers indicates a responsive change in surface chemistry of the calcined materials to varying ramp rates. The accelerated decomposition at a fast ramp rate, particularly at 100 °C min−1, likely leads to an incomplete dehydroxylation process. This results in a greater presence of surface hydroxyl groups remaining in the calcined samples, even after calcination at 400 °C for 2 h. Notably, this increase in the hydroxyl number remains consistent even when the values are normalised to surface area. This suggests that the observed changes are also not solely due to alternations in the material's surface area but indicative of a more complex and nuanced kinetically-controlled modification on the surface of the calcined materials. This trend in surface hydroxyl number aligns well with that of CO2 uptake capacity (Fig. 1b), indicating the positive interconnected relationship between the surface chemistry and the CO2 adsorption, where the surface hydroxyl number may play a key role in facilitating CO2 adsorption on the calcined samples.
The surface chemistry of the calcined samples was further investigated through probe molecule adsorption and temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) techniques. Ammonia gas (NH3) served as the probe for the surface acid sites, while CO2 probes the Lewis basic sites of the calcined samples. As shown in Fig. 2a, the profiles of the 400-2 h-X samples presents a broad desorption peak of NH3 from 100–400 °C and this distinct desorption pattern provides clear evidence that the material calcined with rapid ramp rate could generate significantly more surface acid sites. The total number of acid sites and the acid site density were summarised in Table 1. We found that both total number and the density of the acid sites increase with increasing the ramp rate. The highest total acid site number can reach 1.34 mmol g−1 when a fast the ramp rate 100 °C min−1 was applied, marking a more than sevenfold increase compared to the sample prepared at 5 °C min−1 (0.17 mmol g−1). To further investigate the different bonding modes to the surface of the calcined samples, the NH3 TPD profiles were deconvoluted into 2 groups based on the analysis reported by Prinetto et al. as shown in Scheme S1.†19 The first group, centred at around 150 °C, corresponds to the hydrogen bonding of NH3 to surface hydroxyl groups or the basic surface oxygens. The other group, at higher temperature around 230 °C, is attributed to the bonding motifs between nitrogen and surface metals. The proportion of the first group increases from 15% to 40% when the ramp rate increases from 5 to 100 °C min−1, a trend is consistent with what we found in surface hydroxyl number in Fig. 1c. A similar phenomenon was observed in the total number of basic sites and the basic site density, as obtained from CO2 TPD Fig. 2b. Both total number and density increase with increasing the ramp rate. The sample treated at 100 °C min−1 displayed triple the number of basic sites compared to that at 5 °C min−1 (3.65 and 1.21 mmol g−1, respectively). As previous reported, there are three types of CO2 bonding modes: bicarbonate, bidentate and monodentate as illustrated in Scheme S2.†20 In our study, the bicarbonate bonding mode from the lower desorption temperature (below 100 °C) was not measured. Therefore, the desorption profiles in Fig. 2b were deconvoluted into bidentate around 155 °C and monodentate modes at a higher temperature around 225 °C. With the slower ramps, the strong basic sites account for ca. 70% of the total measured basicity while at 100 °C min−1, it comprises only 65%. This indicates that even though there is a significant overall increase in number of basic sites, the predominant contribution comes from an increase in weaker bidentate nature. Additionally, we noted that CO2 desorption is completed at lower temperature (350 °C) for the sample subjected to 100 °C min−1 ramp rate. This finding implies that some strongest monodentate basic sites may be absent or less predominant when using a fast ramp rate (100 °C min−1).
Fig. 2 (a) NH3 TPD, (b) CO2 TPD of 400-2 h-X samples and (c) 27Al DPMAS ssNMR of (i) Mg2Al LDH, (ii) 400-2 h-5, (iii) 400-2 h-50 and (iv) 400-2 h-100. |
Total basic sites (mmol g−1) | Basic site density (μmmol m−2) | Total acid sites (mmol g−1) | Acid site density (μmol m−2) | Total acid sites/total basic sites | CO2 uptake (mmol g−1) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
400-2 h-5 | 1.21 | 8.22 | 0.17 | 1.15 | 0.14 | 0.35 |
400-2 h-20 | 1.46 | 8.61 | 0.40 | 2.36 | 0.27 | 0.38 |
400-2 h-50 | 1.89 | 10.58 | 0.84 | 4.70 | 0.44 | 0.47 |
400-2 h-100 | 3.65 | 18.24 | 1.34 | 6.70 | 0.37 | 0.59 |
400-1 h-100 | 2.14 | 17.22 | 1.10 | 8.85 | 0.51 | 0.38 |
400-3 h-100 | 3.56 | 17.57 | 1.11 | 5.48 | 0.31 | 0.41 |
400-6 h-100 | 2.86 | 11.87 | 1.31 | 5.44 | 0.46 | 0.4 |
The 27Al DPMAS ssNMR spectroscopy experiments were carried out to investigate the changes in Al environment corresponding to variations in ramp rates. As shown in Fig. 2c, Mg2Al W LDHs present a single distinct resonance peak at lower field which corresponds to the six-coordinated (octahedral) Al species in the LDHs layers. After calcination, an additional resonance at around 78 ppm was observed in all calcined samples. This is attributed to four-coordinated (tetrahedra) Al sites, indicating the Al atoms have diffused out of the octahedral structure of brucite layer during the calcination.21,22 The proportion of tetrahedral sites (Td%) reaches to the highest value (62%) at a ramp rate of 5 °C min−1, followed by a slight decrease to 58% when ramp rates increase to 50 and 100 °C min−1. This is likely due to the shorter calcination time associated with higher ramp rate, leading to an incomplete migration of Al out from octahedral structure of MgO. The 1H NMR spectroscopy (Fig. S9†) displays the characteristic proton resonances of LDH: the surface Mg2Al–OH at δ = 1.2 ppm and the interlayer water molecules at δ = 4.8 ppm.23 When calcined, several resonances arise between δ = 0–3 ppm, which correspond to the OH resonances in the bulk MgO structure with different neighbouring metals.24 The 13C CPMAS NMR spectroscopy (Fig. S10†) shows a slight change in the CO32− environment from δ = 171 ppm to δ = 167 ppm after post calcination. This is due to the change in environment resulting from the dehydration and dehydroxylation during the calcination process.
The CO2 uptake at 40 °C and 100 kPa using X-2 h-100 samples are presented in Fig. 3c. The maximum CO2 capture value (0.59 mmol g−1) was obtained at a calcination temperature of 400 °C. This trend aligns with previous literature even though using different ramp rates.22,27 However, it is surprising to find that the sample treated at 100 °C displayed a relatively high CO2 uptake, notably exhibiting the highest chemisorption value (0.24 mmol g−1) among all the tested samples. The unexpected results could be attributed to the dissolution of CO2 in the interlayer water molecules of LDHs in 100-2 h-100 sample. A similar enhancement in CO2 capture has been reported in the literature through addition of H2O.8,28
Fig. 4 (a) XRD of 400-X-100 samples, (b) BET surface area and pore volume of 400-X-100 samples, and (c) CO2 adsorption for 400-X-100 samples at 40 °C and 100 kPa. |
CO2 uptake capacity (Fig. 4c) of the subsequent LDOs increases with calcination time up to 2 h, followed by a decrease in capacity at longer calcination times (3 h and 6 h). The sample calcined for 2 h (400-2 h-100) displayed a highest CO2 capture value of 0.59 mmol g−1, making an almost 50% increase compared with the value (ca. 0.4 mmol g−1) observed in samples calcined for 3 or 6 h. However, too short a calcination time and fast ramp rate may result in lower CO2 capture value due to part of the material containing a dehydrated LDHs structure which is less active as a CO2 capture material compared to LDOs.
The impact of calcination time on CO2 capture performance is linked to the surface changes in their acidity and basicity. As shown in Table 1 and Fig. S7,† the sample calcined for 2 h (400-2 h-100) possessed the highest total number of acid sites (1.34 mmol g−1) while 1 h calcination time led to the lowest acidity of 1.10 mmol g−1. The acid site density decreases with increasing calcination time, from 8.85 μmol m−2 for 1 h to 5.44 μmol m−2 for 6 h. Interestingly, 400-2 h-100 also displayed the highest number of basic sites (3.65 mmol g−1) as determined by CO2 TPD. The total number of basicity increases sharply between calcination times of 1 and 2 h, then steadily decreases with prolonged calcination, reflecting the trend observed in their CO2 capture performance. Basic site densities of these samples also follow a similar trend. However, the sample (400-6 h-100) displayed significantly less basicity sites and basicity density. The deconvolution of CO2–TPD profile (Table S1†) indicates that the sample 400-6 h-100 has a lower proportion of monodentate binding mode centred at around 215 °C (63%) compared to the shorter calcination times of 1–3 h (65%). Chizallet et al. suggested that the difference in the basic strength of MgO correlates to their coordination environment: a lower oxygen coordination number leads to an increase in basicity due to a higher concentration of the lone pair density.29 This lower coordination numbers are generated by surface defects which create steps, edges, corners or holes. The decrease in basicity sites and basicity strength of the sample (400-6 h-100) is likely due to the prolonged calcination time, which could lead to increase the surface ordering of the LDOs, allowing more oxygens to migrate into more coordinationally saturated environments.
Considering the overall impact of acid and base sites on the CO2 capture, our previous findings revealed a positive correlation between CO2 capture and acid:base ratio within a limited range of acid:base ratio (<0.2).13 In this study, we have expanded the scope by presenting a wider range of acid:base ratio obtained from all the samples calcined at 400 °C. As shown in Fig. 5, our results indicate that when the acid:base ratio is below 0.37, the CO2 uptake increases with the ratio which is consistent with our earlier observations. However, at higher acid:base ratio (>0.37), the CO2 uptake capability decreases. This decline is attributed to the acidic nature of CO2, an excessive concentration of acidic sites creates a less favourable surface for the CO2 interaction. The optimal ratio of 0.37 strikes a balance between the number of acid and base sites, facilitating sufficient hydroxyl participation in the bicarbonate bonding mode without oversaturating the surface with less favourable interactions between the CO2 molecules and acidic sites. This balance is crucial for achieving enhanced CO2 capture efficiency.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Characterisation technique details, XRDs, BET surface area, TGA, hydroxyl numbers, SEM images, NMR, TPD data. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4dt00270a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |