Yaru
Song‡
a,
Guangyuan
Feng‡
a,
Lingli
Wu
*b,
Enbing
Zhang
a,
Chenfang
Sun
a,
Dejuan
Fa
a,
Qiu
Liang
a,
Shengbin
Lei
*a,
Xi
Yu
*a and
Wenping
Hu
a
aTianjin Key Laboratory of Molecular Optoelectronic Science, Department of Chemistry, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, P. R. China. E-mail: shengbin.lei@tju.edu.cn; xi.yu@tju.edu.cn
bMedical College, Northwest Minzu University, Lanzhou 730000, P. R. China. E-mail: wulingli19831106@163.com
First published on 29th October 2021
In this work, through rational monomer design we integrated the conformational change mechanism into a two-dimensional covalent polymer and implemented 3 different low-power memory behaviors on the same device by tuning the compliance current (ICC), including nonvolatile write-once-read-many-times (WORM) memory behaviour, nonvolatile FLASH memory behaviour and volatile dynamic random access memory (DRAM) behaviour. Furthermore, 2DP-based memory devices exhibit excellent flexibility and thermal stability, which is a desirable property for applications in wearable electronics and a high temperature environment. Finally, the conformation-induced conductance switching under an electric field was confirmed by UV-vis spectra. The differences in memory behaviour were attributed to the inherent differences in the degree of regioregularity and ease of the conformational relaxation of the field-induced rearrangement of carbazole groups.
Memory devices can show non-volatile (WORM and FLASH) and volatile (DRAM and SRAM) memory effects depending on whether electrical power is required to maintain a given state (ON state);31 both have great importance in applications such as for information storage or neuromorphic computing and beyond von-Neumann computer architectures.32 The memory behaviors of the device can be tuned by controlling the electrode type, doping, molecular structure and active layer and electrode thickness.33–39 Although there have been many reports, most of the multiple behaviors were achieved by controlling materials or electrodes during the preparation process. After the preparation is completed, it is not possible to change the memory behaviors anymore. Thus, there are still huge challenges in controllably and reversibly tuning the memory behavior of a given device.
Based on the above considerations, we propose a strategy to controllably adjust the resistive switching behavior of the same device by controlling the degree of conformational change of the active layer material. For this purpose we designed and synthesized the 2,5-bis(3-(9H-carbazol-9-yl)propoxy)terephthalaldehyde (TPAK) monomer (Fig. 1a), in which two carbazole groups are attached via a flexible spacer (O–C–C–C unit) to the phenyl backbone of terephthalaldehyde. Then the two-dimensional covalent polymer was synthesized by the Schiff base reaction between TPAK and 1,3,5-tris(4-aminophenyl)-benzene (TAPB). Under the effect of an electric field, the carbazole part will undergo conformational changes. When different compliance currents (ICC) are applied, the degree of conformational changes can be precisely adjusted, leading to different memory behaviors, including nonvolatile write-once-read-many-times (WORM) memory behaviour, nonvolatile FLASH memory behaviour and volatile dynamic random access memory (DRAM) behaviour. Moreover, the devices exhibit high thermal stability and excellent flexibility.
The 2DP films obtained at the centimeter scale were transferred onto a Si/SiO2 substrate for morphology characterization through optical microscopy and atomic force microscopy (AFM). Using optical microscopy, the color of the film is uniform, which indicates that the film thickness is highly uniform (Fig. 1c). As shown in Fig. 1d, the average thickness and total surface roughness of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film are about 30.5 ± 0.6 nm and 1.5 ± 0.2 nm, respectively. The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image (Fig. 1e) shows that the films have good freestanding ability due to their covalently connected network structure. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and selected area electron diffraction (SAED) images (Fig. 1f and inset) show that the 2DPTPAK+TAPB thin films are amorphous, which is also consistent with the XRD data (Fig. S12a, ESI†). This may suggest that the carbazole group is initially in a disordered state in the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film.
Due to its covalently bonded structure, the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film has good thermal stability in addition to the good freestanding ability. TGA data show that the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film is stable up to 360 °C, and the weight loss at 35–364 °C (8.8%) can be attributed to the loss of adsorbate and unreacted monomers (Fig. S9A, ESI†). The rapid weight loss at 364–441 °C can be attributed to carbonization. AFM characterization of the samples before and after heating at 300 and 400 °C for 2 hours in a vacuum showed no significant change in morphology (Fig. S9B(b)–C(c), ESI†) except for a slight decrease in thickness and surface roughness. In addition, the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film also exhibits excellent solvent resistance. After soaking in different organic solvents for 5 minutes, no significant changes in morphology, thickness and surface roughness were detected (Fig. S10a–f and 11A(a)–F(f), ESI†). The excellent thermal stability and organic solvent resistance make the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film ideal for the fabrication of electronic devices that can operate in harsh environments.
The attenuated total reflectance FT-IR (ATR FTIR), Raman spectra and XPS spectra were used to further characterize the chemical structure of the 2DP films and confirmed the successful formation of the –CN bonds. Fig. 2a shows not only imine vibrations (1598 cm−1) but also the remaining carbonyl vibrations (1687 cm−1), indicating the formation of imine bonds and incomplete imine condensation.14,15 The Raman spectra (Fig. S12b, ESI†) also provide evidence of imine formation in the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film. The band appearing at 1587 cm−1 indicates the imine stretching mode.14,15 And as shown in Fig. 2b, the N 1s spectrum of 2DPTPAK+TAPB can be separated into three components, the lower binding energy component centered at 398.9 eV can be attributed to the imine bonds, the one at 399.9 eV correspond to the unreacted –NH2 of TAPB and the one at 400.4 eV is from the carbazole-N, which clearly confirms the formation of imine bonds and the incomplete reaction of the precursors, which is consistent with the FT-IR results. The UV-vis absorption spectra of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film, and TAPB and TPAK monomers are shown in Fig. 2c and Fig. S13 (ESI†). The onset of the absorption peak of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film is determined to be 500 nm, from which the optical bandgap (Eeg) was calculated to be approximately 2.48 eV. In combination with cyclic voltammetry (CV) (Fig. 2d and e), the energy levels of the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film were determined to be −5.51 eV and −3.03 eV, respectively. This favours the injection of holes instead of electrons. As seen in the energy diagram (Fig. 2f), the barrier of hole injection (0.71 eV) is much smaller than the barrier of electron injection (2.07 eV). Thus, the switching of the device was observed in the positive bias, with the transport of holes as the conducting mechanism.
The memory device with a sandwich structure of Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO was fabricated and the performance was investigated under ambient conditions. An inert Au electrode was used as the top electrode instead of the active Ag and Al electrodes, which rules out the possibility for the electrochemical metallization mechanism. As shown in Fig. 3a, when the ICC is set at 10−4 A, the device switches from the OFF state to ON state at about 1.26 V during the I–V measurement from 0 V → 3.0 V → 0 V (sweep 1). However, after turning off the power, the memory device can only remain at the ON state for several tens of seconds after which it automatically relaxes to a high resistance state. And then, it can continue to be switched to the ON state again by applying the appropriate voltage (sweep 2). For the DRAM effect, the ON state could be retained for a short period after the removal of the applied voltage.31 Therefore, the behaviour of the Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO device shows characteristics of dynamic random access memory (DRAM). To explore the switching uniformity of the prepared device, I–V curves of about 70 devices were measured. The device-to-device distributions of HRS resistance and LRS resistance range from 8.8 × 104 to 8.3 × 105 Ω and 9.2 × 102 to 3.8 × 103 Ω (read at 0.1 V), respectively (Fig. 3d). Thus, the calculated ON/OFF ratio is about 102. In order to evaluate the retention time of the ON state of the Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO device, the I–t curve was measured at 0.1 V read voltage at room temperature (the inset of Fig. 3g). The retention time of the device was concentrated in the range of 20–40 s, which further indicates that when the ICC is set at 10−4 A, the device exhibits the switching characteristics of DRAM (Fig. 3g).
Fig. 3b shows that when the ICC is set at 10−3 A, the device switches from the OFF state to ON state at about 1.36 V during the I–V measurement from 0 V → 3.0 V → 0 V (sweep 1). By an inverse sweep from 0 V → −3.0 V → 0 V (sweep 2, ICC = 10−1 A), a switch from high-conductivity (ON) state to a low-conductivity (OFF) state was observed. Bias is not required to sustain the high-conductivity state. However, only a suitable negative bias can switch the high-conductivity state to the low-conductivity state. This feature is consistent with flash memory behaviors. To explore the switching uniformity of the prepared device, I–V curves of about 50 devices were measured. The device-to-device distributions of HRS resistance and LRS resistance range from 2.0 × 105 to 5.5 × 105 Ω and 1.7 × 102 to 4.8 × 102 Ω (read at 0.1 V), respectively (Fig. 3e). And the ON/OFF ratio is about 103. As shown in Fig. 3i, the retention characteristic of the Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO devices was measured at 0.1 V read voltage at room temperature. The resistances of both states show no obvious change for about 3.5 × 103 s indicating that our devices have a relatively good stability. We explored the device stability during multiple write and erase operations. As shown in Fig. S14 (ESI†), we have performed about 100 write and erase operations, and the device can still work normally, and the HRS resistance and LRS resistance are evenly distributed.
As shown in Fig. 3c, when the ICC is set at 10−1 A, the device switches from the low-conductivity (OFF) state to the high-conductivity (ON) state at about 1.52 V during the I–V measurement from 0 V → 3.0 V → 0 V (sweep 1). The device cannot be switched back to its OFF state by subsequent application of a negative bias (sweep 2, ICC = 10−1 A) or a positive bias (sweep 3). The device remains in the ON state even after the power has been turned off. Thus, the Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO device exhibits write-once-read-many-times (WORM) memory behaviour, as it is both non-rewritable and nonvolatile after it has been switched ON. In addition, the device has an ON/OFF ratio of up to 103 when read at 0.1 V. To explore the switching uniformity of the prepared device, I–V curves of about 50 devices were measured. The device-to-device distributions of HRS resistance and LRS resistance range from 2.1 × 104 to 7.5 × 104 Ω and 3.2 × 101 to 7.7 × 101 Ω (read at 0.1 V), respectively (Fig. 3f). To evaluate the persistence of the ON/OFF states of the Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO devices, the retention characteristic was measured at 0.1 V read voltage at room temperature, as shown in Fig. 3i. The resistances of both states show no obvious change for about 3.0 × 103 s, indicating that our devices have a relatively good stability.
So far, most of the memory devices based on the mechanism of conformational changes have only worked at room temperature, showing limited heat resistance, because the functional layers in memristors based on traditional organic molecules and polymers are mostly stabilized through intermolecular interactions. In our devices, we speculate that the high thermal stability of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film makes it an ideal material for fabricating devices with high thermal stability. To further evaluate the thermal stability of the device, we heated an RS device made with a 25.5 ± 0.5 nm thick 2DPTPAK+TAPB film for 2 hours at different temperatures in an argon-protected cube oven. The switching characteristics and success rate after heating are shown in Fig. 4a–c. Devices based on 2DPTPAK+TAPB at different limiting currents exhibit reliable non-volatile and volatile storage properties even after annealing at 300 °C. The HRS and LRS resistance of the device did not change significantly with increasing annealing temperature. After annealing at 300 °C, the success rate was only slightly reduced to 70%, indicating that the 2DPTPAK+TAPB based device still showed high reliability after heating at 300 °C. Only after annealing at 400 °C, the success rate suddenly drops to 10%, and most devices cannot operate. The high thermal stability is attributed to the strong covalent bonds in the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film. This will have potential applications in electronic devices under harsh conditions such as in the aerospace, geothermal, oil and gas industries, as well as in implanted devices. Furthermore, we were able to fabricate RS devices with ultra-thin 2DPTPAK+TAPB films down to 2.7 ± 0.5 nm, in which different switching behaviors such as the volatile dynamic random access (DRAM) memory feature, nonvolatile FLASH memory feature and the nonvolatile write-once-read-many-times (WORM) memory feature can still be realized by adjusting the ICC to 10−4 A, 10−3 A and 10−1 A, respectively. And the devices have an on/off ratio of about 4 at a 0.1 V read voltage (Fig. 4d–f). This ultra-thin device will facilitate the integrated application in flexible and wearable devices.
Flexible devices have generated a lot of research interest due to their potential applications in wearable electronics, smart skin and minimally invasive biomedical devices. From previous data we demonstrated the high flexibility and uniformity of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB films, which will be ideal for flexible equipment applications. Here, we show a flexible device with a vertical Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO structure on a flexible (ITO) substrate (Fig. 4g–i). The thickness of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film was 26.5 ± 0.5 nm. The flexible memory devices can also realize the adjustment of switching behavior by setting the current compliance to 10−4 A, 10−3 A and 10−1 A, respectively and maintaining the memory characteristics after 500 bending cycles. Finally, the devices failed to operate until 1000 bending cycles. The flexible device exhibits excellent mechanical durability, and therefore, the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film with good flexibility and high thermal stability is very attractive for the application of a flexible device under harsh conditions.
The carbazole groups are electron donor and hole transporters40,41 and tend to form a partial or complete face-to-face conformation with adjacent carbazole groups, resulting in extended electron delocalization. The stacked carbazole groups provide a charge-carrier hopping pathway in the direction of the electric field.40 We speculate that the switching effect in the Au/2DPTPAK+TAPB/ITO device may be due to the change in the conformation of the carbazole groups through the rotation of these groups, resulting in more regular π–π stacking regions. At low applied voltages, the carbazole pendant groups attached to the backbone through the flexible C–O bonds in TPAK are initially in random orientation, as shown by the simulated structure in the left image of Fig. 5c. Upon application of a voltage, the injected holes oxidize the carbazole group near the interface to form a positively charged species. As a potent electron donor, a nearby neutral carbazole group may interact with a positively charged carbazole group for charge transfer or excess acceptor interaction with a nearby carbazole group to form a partial or complete face-to-face conformation, as shown in the right image of Fig. 5c. And then it will delocalize the positive charge to the adjacent ordered carbazole group. This process can then be propagated through the polymer film. When the applied voltage exceeds a threshold, a significant portion of the carbazole groups undergo this conformational change, resulting in enhanced charge transport through neighboring, aligned carbazole groups, producing a high conductivity state (ON state).42 The UV-visible spectra of the 2DPTPAK+TAPB film in the “OFF” state and “ON” state give evidence for the conformational change. As shown in Fig. 5a, a liquid Ga–In droplet instead of an Au electrode was used to construct a vertical structured Ga–In/2DP/ITO device; when a 3.0 V voltage scan was applied with ICC set at 10−4 A, 10−3 A and 10−1 A, respectively, slight but significant red shifts were seen (Fig. 5b). This was attributed to the increased interaction between the carbazole groups in the face-to-face conformation.43 In order to further rule out the possibility that the red-shift phenomenon solely comes from the contact between the film and the Ga–In liquid electrode, we tested the UV spectrum of the film in contact with the Ga–In liquid electrode but without applying voltage (Fig. S15, ESI†), and no red-shift was found, which further illustrates that the red-shift phenomenon comes from the conformational change of the carbazole groups after the voltage was applied. Moreover, the conformation change of 2DPTPAK+TAPB in different states is also supported by the results of fluorescence. As shown in Fig. S16 (ESI†), the main emission peaks of 2DPTPAK+TAPB in ON and OFF states both appear at around 370 and 525 nm. The excimeric species of the over-lapped (face-to-face conformation) carbazole groups show emissions at about 370 and 420 nm owing to the higher-energy excimer and sandwich-like excimer, respectively.12,21 After applying voltage to the film, the ON state of 2DPTPAK+TAPB shows a stronger emission and a slight red shift to 376 nm compared with the OFF state (372 nm), which is due to the increased interaction among the carbazole groups in a face-to-face conformation. A similar phenomenon is also observed in the emission at approximately 420 nm. The STM characterization also gives some more direct evidence for the conformational change. As shown in Fig. S17a and b (ESI†), at a bias voltage of −0.3 V, the carbazole groups can be observed in the STM image (the positions of the carbazole groups were marked by the red circles), but when increasing the bias voltage to −0.6 V, the carbazole groups were never observable anymore, which was attributed to the conformational change of the carbazole group.
Fig. 5 (a) The schematic of the Ga–In/2DP/ITO device. (b) The UV-vis spectra of the device in different “ON” states and “OFF” state. (c) The proposed conformation change memory mechanism. |
To further explore the conduction mechanism of resistance switching, a typical I–V curve of the device is plotted using a double logarithmic scale, as shown in Fig. S19–S21 (ESI†). The OFF state I–V characteristic of the device at 3 different compliance currents can be well fitted with the combination of the Schottky emission model and the space charge limited current model with field dependent mobility.44–46 In the low voltage range from 0 to 0.5 V, the lnI–lnV characteristic shows a linear relationship corresponding to the space charge limited current model (Fig. S19–S21b, ESI†), while in the high voltage region of HRS (0.5 V to Vset), the lnI–lnV curve shows a nonlinear relationship. Further analysis shows a linear relationship between lnI and V1/2, indicating that the Schottky emission is the main conduction mechanism of the HRS in the high voltage region (Fig. S19–S21c, ESI†). The I–V characteristic of the ON state shows a linear plot with a slope of 1 (Fig. S19–S21d, ESI†), indicating ohmic behaviour. Furthermore, the suitability of the fitted model was confirmed by the temperature dependence of the device current. The ON state current of the device shows the temperature dependence (Fig. S22b, d and f, ESI†). And the negative temperature coefficient indicates the corresponding non-metallic conductive channel, which is consistent with most reported literature on the mechanism of conformational changes.
We believe that the mechanism for the tunable memory behaviours by adjusting the applied ICC is due to the effect on the degree of conformational changes. Since our carbazole-containing 2D polymer device is based on conformational changes mechanism, once conductive paths are formed under the applied electric field, the charge transfer will be promoted under biases. The degree of conformational change that occurs also increases with the increase of applied bias. With the maximum compliance current the degree of conformational change is very high, and the formed conductive channel is robust, so after the device is switched to the “ON” state, it cannot be returned to the “OFF” state by applying a reverse bias or the same bias voltage. However, under a small compliance current, the degree of conformational change is not high, and the organic framework of 2DP provides sufficient conformational freedom, thus the device can return to the “OFF” state through conformational relaxation. Finally, the degree of conformational change that occurs at a moderate compliance current is between the first two, so it can be returned to the “OFF” state by applying a reverse bias. These explanations are supported by the UV-visible spectra. As shown in Fig. 5b and Fig. S18, Table S1 (ESI†), the UV-vis spectrum of the three different ON states of the device shows different degrees of red shifts. Among them, the degree of the red shift in the WORM state is the largest (19 nm), followed by the FLASH state (9 nm), and the degree of the red shift in the DRAM state is the smallest (5 nm), corresponding to different degrees of conformational changes. In short, the free space provided by the rigid 2D polymer backbone is a key for the success of the tunable memory behavior of our conformational change 2DP memristor.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1tc04248c |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |