Sayuri
Okunaka‡
*,
Toshio
Nakamura
,
Takeshi
Ikeda
,
Kohei
Tsuruda
and
Hiromasa
Tokudome
*
Research Institute, TOTO LTD., 2-8-1 Honson, Chigasaki, Kanagawa, 253-8577, Japan. E-mail: hiromasa.tokudome@jp.toto.com
First published on 24th November 2023
Solar-light-driven production of hydrogen (H2) from water using semiconductor photocatalysts is one of the breakthrough technologies of the sustainable and economical solar energy conversion process. However, the conventional oxidation product in water splitting reactions is mainly oxygen gas with low economic benefit. In this paper, photocatalytic simultaneous production of hypochlorous acid (HClO) as a high-value oxidant along with H2 in saline water under simulated solar light was successfully achieved for the first time using SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst systems. Loading of a co-catalyst was found to be essential to proceed the photocatalytic H2/HClO production reaction, in particular the RhCrOx(0.1 wt%)-loaded SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst (RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al) showed the highest activity. In the RhCrOx, the Rh species acts as a co-catalyst to promote proton reduction, and CrOx suppresses the decomposition of the produced HClO. The HClO production rates on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst increased with increasing the Cl− substrate concentration, whereas HClO was produced even in the diluted NaCl aqueous solution of ca. 0.001 M. Moreover, RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst films, in which the photocatalyst particles are fixed onto a glass substrate, were prepared by simple screen printing followed by a drying and calcination process. The RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst film produced H2/HClO from saline water under simulated solar light. The evolution rate of H2/HClO on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst film was found to be almost the same as that on the corresponding suspended particles thanks to the porous structure enabling an efficient mass transfer.
One of the essential strategies lies in the replacement of O2 evolution with oxidative production of high-value-added chemicals, such as hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) or HClO, which is an important chemical substance with a wide range of industrial applications.20–29 In particular, HClO is a well known inorganic oxidant with excellent microbial and oxidizing properties. It is widely used as a disinfectant, deodorizer, and bleaching agent in various industries.30,31 At present, fifty million tons of HClO and its derivatives are produced by electrochemical processes in the world.21
Thus, HClO production via oxidation of Cl− in water by photogenerated holes in photocatalysts can become a valuable and sustainable reaction, along with H2 generation by photogenerated electrons. In this reaction, HClO is produced via oxidation of Cl− by the photogenerated holes; Cl− is first oxidized to Cl2 (eqn (1)) and then the produced Cl2 disproportionates in the aqueous environment to form HClO (eqn (2)). In addition, the reduction reaction of H+ into H2 is carried out by the photogenerated electrons (eqn (3)).
Oxidation reaction:
2Cl− → Cl2 + 2e−, E = +1.48 V vs. RHE | (1) |
Cl2 + H2O ↔ H+ + HClO + Cl− | (2) |
Reduction reaction:
2H+ + 2e− = H2, E = 0.0 V vs. RHE | (3) |
Recently, photoelectrochemical HClO production from aqueous NaCl solution has also been demonstrated with a photoelectrochemical system using a BiVO4/WO3 multilayer photoanode under simulated solar light irradiation.24,26,27 Also, some suspension systems including photocatalyst particles such as Pt- or Pt, MnOx-loaded WO3, and Au-loaded AgCl have demonstrated HClO generation in an aqueous solution of NaCl under simulated solar light.25,28,29 However, it was difficult to produce H2 with these photocatalysts because of the difficulty in the reduction of protons (H+) by the photogenerated electrons owing to their deep conduction band edge (>0 V vs. RHE) or the possibility of the self-reduction of Ag+ for AgCl. Therefore, there is still a demand for photocatalysts and their systems that can produce HClO and H2 simultaneously from an aqueous solution containing Cl− under solar light.
To achieve the simultaneous HClO/H2 production on a photocatalyst, choosing photocatalyst materials which have both the band potentials to reduce H+ (<0 V vs. RHE) and oxidize Cl− (>1.48 V vs. RHE) is needed. For example, SrTiO3 is a well-known photocatalyst to split water efficiently and shows a high H2 evolution ability under UV irradiation, and also has the sufficient band potential for producing HClO via oxidation of Cl− theoretically.10,32,33 Therefore, the properties of SrTiO3 photocatalysts motivated us to employ them in the construction of the photocatalytic HClO/H2 production system under solar light. In this study, we used the SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst as a prototype and examined its HClO/H2 production abilities from an aqueous NaCl solution under simulated solar light. We investigated the effect of co-catalyst loading onto the SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst on the HClO production under solar-light irradiation in detail. Moreover, we fabricated a SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst panel by simple screen-printing followed by calcinations, to achieve simultaneous HClO/H2 production under solar light.
Co-catalyst loaded SrTiO3:Al particles, which we denoted as MOx/SrTiO3:Al (M = Rh, Pt, Ru, Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, RhCr, PtCr, RuCr) were prepared by impregnation of an aqueous solution of the metal precursors onto the SrTiO3:Al, followed by calcination at 350 °C for 1 h in air. SrTiO3:Al particles with 0.1 wt% of RhCrOx, which we denoted as RhCrOx (0.1 wt%)/SrTiO3:Al, was the optimum catalyst for HClO/H2 production activity, as mentioned later.
In the case of the photocatalytic HClO and/or H2 production on the SrTiO3:Al films loaded with/without co-catalyst, the reactions were carried out in a Pyrex-made reaction vessel, in which the film was horizontally fixed in 10 mL of aqueous NaCl solution, connected to a closed gas-circulating system.
The amounts of HClO produced were analyzed by using the N,N-diethyl-p-phenylenediamine (DPD) method. The detection limit of the HClO measurement was almost 0.01 μmol. The amounts of H2 produced were analyzed and quantified by using an on-line gas chromatograph (GL Science; GC-3200, TCD, Ar carrier, MS-5A column).
No. | Co-catalyst | Amount of produced HClO (μmol) |
---|---|---|
a Catalyst, 0.01 g; reactant solution, 5 mL of 1 M aqueous NaCl solution; light source, simulated solar light (AM 1.5G); irradiation time, 5 h. | ||
1 | None | n.d. |
2 | Rh | 0.06 |
3 | Pt | 0.02 |
4 | Ru | 0.03 |
5 | Cr | n.d. |
6 | Mn | n.d. |
7 | Co | n.d. |
8 | Ni | n.d. |
9 | Cu | n.d. |
10 | RhCr | 4.25 |
11 | PtCr | 0.09 |
12 | RuCr | 0.10 |
The bare SrTiO3:Al exhibited almost no HClO production activity in an aqueous NaCl solution under solar light irradiation. In the case of loading a single metal oxide co-catalyst, RhOx, PtOx, and RuOx were found to slightly promote HClO production. These precious metal oxides have been reported to be active components as a co-catalyst for photocatalytic H2 evolution from water.34,38 In contrast, the tested transition metal oxides (CrOx, MnOx, CoOx, NiOx, and CuOx), mainly recognized as water oxidation co-catalysts,34,38 did not show HClO evolution activity. In all cases when cutting UV light off using an L-42 filter, HClO was almost not produced over all the samples (not shown). Also, it is generally known that HClO gradually decomposes under UV light irradiation.39 These results confirm that the photocatalytic HClO generation on SrTiO3:Al in an aqueous NaCl solution under solar light irradiation preferentially proceeds against the UV decomposition of HClO by loading appropriate co-catalysts that can especially promote H+ reduction to produce H2.
Next, photocatalytic HClO evolution activity of SrTiO3:Al powders co-loaded with the precious metal oxides and CrOx by simultaneous impregnation was tested. Notably, the existence of loaded co-catalysts (RhCrOx, PtCrOx, and RuCrOx) was confirmed by XPS (Fig. S4†), while the peaks of loaded co-catalysts were undetectable by X-ray diffraction (Fig. S5†). In addition, SEM analysis of the co-catalysts loaded SrTiO3:Al revealed the formation of nanoparticulate RhCrOx, PtCrOx, and RuCrOx (ca. 10–50 nm) over the surface of the SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst (Fig. S6†). As shown in Table 1, all the photocatalytic activity was markedly improved by co-loading with Cr. Specifically, RhCrOx-loaded SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst was found to show the best activity.
To investigate the role of the RhCrOx co-catalyst on the HClO production reaction in aqueous NaCl solution under solar-light irradiation, we conducted a series of control experiments using the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst, along with loading RhOx or CrOx alone. Prior to the investigation, the presence of the co-catalyst loaded on the SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst was confirmed by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). In the XPS spectra of the MOx/SrTiO3:Al, peaks attributed to the MOx (Rh 3d and Cr 2s) and the SrTiO3:Al (Sr 3p, Ti 2p, and Al 2p) appeared (Fig. S7†). However, peaks originating from the loaded MOx were undetectable by X-ray diffraction (Fig. S2†), because their amounts were too little. Fig. 1 shows the amounts of HClO and/or H2 production on the RhOx, CrOx, and RhCrOx loaded SrTiO3:Al photocatalysts in aqueous NaCl solution under solar-light irradiation. Loading of RhCrOx was the most effective to produce HClO, along with H2. The sample loaded with RhOx only, a typical reduction catalyst, also produced H2 and HClO, while the amount of HClO generated was significantly decreased compared to the case of using the RhCrOx-loaded one. In contrast, almost no product was formed in the case of using CrOx, known as an oxidation catalyst.34,38 Judging from the above-mentioned results, it is likely that the loading of a reduction co-catalyst for a counterpart H2 evolution is necessary to proceed the oxidative HClO production reaction. Indeed, in the photocatalytic reaction, O2 gas evolved preferentially compared to HClO in the oxidation reaction, and the molar ratio of O2 to H2 was near 1:2 exhibiting close to stoichiometric water splitting (data not shown). For example, the selectivity for HClO production on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst was 1.8%. It indicates that HClO is an oxidative by-product in the present conditions because the SrTiO3:Al photocatalysts were originally designed for overall water splitting. Improving the selectivity will be examined in future work by further optimization of the co-catalyst modification.
Next, in order to investigate the reason for the lower HClO production activity on RhOx/SrTiO3:Al, the following HClO decomposition reaction tests were conducted.40 It is generally known the decomposition reaction of HClO proceeds on the metal oxide surface,40 following the equation (eqn (4)):
2ClO− → 2Cl− + O2 | (4) |
Initial screening of the co-catalysts revealed that the loading of RhCrOx was found to boost the photocatalytic HClO production in aqueous NaCl solution. We subsequently conducted a more detailed investigation of the catalyst composition. The HClO/H2 production on the SrTiO3:Al photocatalysts loaded with different amounts of RhCrOx was examined under simulated solar light irradiation. The photocatalytic activity of the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst in the HClO/H2 production reaction depended on the loading amount of RhCrOx as shown in Fig. 2(a), increasing the loading amount up to 0.1 wt% resulted in an increase in the activity, whereas beyond 0.25 wt% the activity decreased. The promotion of HClO/H2 generation by loading RhCrOx can be caused by an efficient charge separation between SrTiO3:Al and the co-catalyst and the inactivity with HClO of the surface CrOx species as mentioned above. However, the excessively loaded RhCrOx co-catalyst may cover the surface active sites of the photocatalysts and hinder its contact with the reaction substrates (water and Cl−), and/or shield the incident light that should be absorbed by the photocatalyst, resulting in the decreased activity. Alternatively, the amounts of HClO produced on the SrTiO3:Al photocatalysts loaded with RhCrOx were also dependent on the Cr loading amount, 0.1 wt% of Cr loaded sample exhibited the highest activity in the photocatalytic HClO production (Fig. 2(b)).
We also examined the effect of the NaCl concentration in the solution on the HClO/H2 production reaction over the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst under the simulated solar-light irradiation (Fig. 2(c)). The activity of HClO generation increased with increasing NaCl concentration up to 2 M, whereas a concentration of NaCl more than 2 M did not affect the activity. The result indicates that the concentration of the reactant Cl− is important to proceed the reaction smoothly. It is noted that the HClO was produced even when the NaCl concentration was <0.5 M, suggesting the possibility of the practical application using seawater (Cl− concentration: ca. 0.5 M), or tap water (Cl− concentration: ca. <0.01 M).
Additionally, we conducted a recycle test using the present RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al particles. The RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al particles were separated from the reaction solution, washed with aqueous solution, and dried at 80 °C. The photooxidative HClO production reaction in aqueous NaCl solution was conducted using the obtained RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al particles. These processes were repeated 2 times. From the characterizations of the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst before/after the reaction shown in Fig. S9,† no obvious changes were observed in the original particles and co-catalyst characteristics. In addition, the photocatalytic HClO production ability of the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al particles was almost not changed over at least 3 cycles (Fig. S10†), indicating the stability of the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst towards these photooxidative conditions.
Fig. 3 (a) A photograph of RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film prepared via the screen-printing method. (b) Cross-section and (c) magnified cross-section views of SEM images of the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film. |
Firstly, we checked the HClO and H2 production ability in an aqueous NaCl solution on the obtained RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film under UV light irradiation. Under UV-light irradiation, gas bubbles were obviously observed, as shown in Fig. S12(a),† and the color of the reaction solution changed to pink when the DPD reagent was added, indicating generation of HClO (b). The produced amount of HClO was 7.5 μmol cm−2 under UV-light irradiation for 1 hour. H2 and HClO production activity on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film was also evaluated under simulated solar light. Fig. 4 shows the time course of gas evolution on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film. At the early stages of photoirradiation, both H2 and HClO were generated simultaneously with steady rates from the aqueous NaCl solution. However, the rate of HClO generation slightly decreased as the irradiation time increased. This is because the generated HClO is subsequently decomposed on the surface of the co-catalyst, as mentioned above. The H2 and HClO production activity on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film was almost the same as that on the corresponding suspended particles (Fig. S13†). The result indicates that the porous structure in the present RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film enables an efficient mass transfer of the reaction substances, and thereby contributes to maintaining the original activity of the photocatalyst particles for H2 and HClO production.
Fig. 4 The time course of (a) HClO and (b) H2 evolution on the RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al film (active area: 6.25 cm2) in an aqueous NaCl solution (1 M) under simulated solar light (AM 1.5G). |
Toward the practical use of solar H2/HClO production, RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst panel systems, wherein the photocatalyst particles are fixed onto a glass substrate, were also developed. A porous RhCrOx/SrTiO3:Al photocatalyst film with a thickness of 10 μm was prepared via simple screen printing followed by a drying and calcination process. The obtained film produced H2 and HClO from saline water under simulated solar light irradiation, almost maintaining the same activity as on corresponding suspended particles.
For practical applications of solar H2 and/or HClO production using saline water, it is essential to develop photocatalyst particles/films capable of producing them efficiently under solar-light irradiation. Such developments will be vital to upgrade photocatalytic materials to improve various factors such as photoabsorption or selectivity of HClO production. We believe that this work will contribute to the development of sustainable and economical solar energy conversion systems that can obtain both clean energy and high-value-added chemicals.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3se01163a |
‡ Present address: Department of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Science and Engineering, Tokyo City University, 1-28-1 Tamazutsumi, Setagaya-ku, Tokyo, 158-8557, Japan. E-mail: E-mail: okunakas@tcu.co.jp |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |