Elucidation of factors shaping reactivity of 5'-deoxyadenosyl – a prominent organic radical in biology

Abstract

This study investigates the factors modulating the reactivity of 5'-deoxyadenosyl (5'dAdo^•) radical, a potent hydrogen atom abstractor that forms in the active sites of radical SAM enzymes and that otherwise undergoes a rapid self-decay in aqueous solution. Here, we compare hydrogen atom abstraction (HAA) reactions between native substrates of radical SAM enzymes and 5'dAdo^• in aqueous solution and in two enzymatic microenvironments. With that we reveal that HAA efficiency of 5'dAdo^• is due to (i) the formation of 5'dAdo^• in a pre-ordered complex with a substrate, which attenuates the unfavorable effect of substrate:5'dAdo^• complex formation, and (ii) the prevention of the conformational changes associated with self-decay by a tight active-site cavity. The enzymatic cavity, however, does not have a strong effect on the HAA activity of 5'dAdo^•. Thus, we performed an analysis of in-water HAA performed by 5'dAdo^• based on a three-component thermodynamic model incorporating the diagonal effect of the free energy of reaction, and the off-diagonal effect of asynchronicity and frustration. To this aim, we took advantage of the straightforward relationship between the off-diagonal thermodynamic effects and the electronic-structure descriptor – the redistribution of charge between the reactants during the reaction. It allows to access HAA-competent redox and acidobasic properties of 5'dAdo^• that are otherwise unavailable due to its instability upon one-electron reduction and protonation. The results show that all reactions feature a favourable thermodynamic driving force and tunneling, the latter of which lowers systematically barriers by ~2 kcal mol^-1. In addition, most of the reactions experience a favourable off-diagonal thermodynamic contribution. In HAA reactions, 5'dAdo• acts as a weak oxidant as well as a base, also 5'dAdo^•-promoted HAA reactions proceed with a quite low degree of asynchronicity of proton and electron transfer. Finally, the study elucidates the crucial and dual role of asynchronicity. It directly lowers the barrier as a part of the off-diagonal thermodynamic contribution, but also indirectly increases the non-thermodynamic part of the barrier by presumably controlling the adiabatic coupling between proton and electron transfer. The latter signals that the reaction proceeds as a hydrogen atom transfer rather than a proton-coupled electron transfer.