Mingyao
Shen
a,
Cheng
Huang
a,
Yuxin
Xiao
a,
Rongjuan
Huang
a,
Vonika Ka-Man
Au
*b and
Tao
Yu
*a
aFrontiers Science Center for Flexible Electronics (FSCFE), Shaanxi Institute of Flexible Electronics (SIFE) & Shaanxi Institute of Biomedical Materials and Engineering (SIBME), Northwestern Polytechnical University (NPU), 127 West Youyi Road, Xi’an 710072, China. E-mail: iamtyu@nwpu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Science and Environmental Studies, The Education University of Hong Kong, 10 Lo Ping Road, Tai Po, New Territories, Hong Kong, China. E-mail: kmau@eduhk.hk
First published on 9th August 2023
Revealing the differences between crystalline and amorphous states in solid samples can both deepen the understanding of their structure–property relationships and promote the development of versatile materials based on the same compounds. Herein, we report a new triphenylethylene derivative that exhibits different photochromic properties in two aggregated states. The further characterization studies showed that the photochromism was associated with a transition from the crystalline to amorphous state. Moreover, the two aggregated states of samples can be readily interconverted into each other and applied to convertible information storage. This work provides a strategy for controlling photochromism by manipulating the transition of aggregated states, paving a new way for the regulation of photochromism.
In the past several decades, organic photochromic materials have attracted tremendous attention and several photochromic systems have gradually emerged, including azobenzenes,23–25 spiropyrans,26–29 fulgides,30–33 diarylethylenes34–37 and their derivatives. Restricted by the complex synthetic process, poor thermal stability, and weak fatigue resistance to varying degrees, these materials, however, are facing challenges in widespread practical applications. Thus, a new organic photochromic system with fast response is urgently needed. Recently, triphenylethylene derivatives are expected to become a new type of organic photochromic molecules owing to their simple synthesis, facile modifiability, and diverse properties. In 2016, Yu and co-workers38 first reported the photochromism of dichloro-substituted triphenylethylene derivatives, whose color changed from white to red with a concomitant quenching in its blue emission upon UV irradiation (365 nm). The color and fluorescence could return to their original state after stopping the illumination for several seconds. After spin-coating a dichloromethane solution of the compounds onto a SiO2 substrate and removing the solvent by evaporation, the obtained microcrystalline surfaces showed different morphologies and wettability in the presence and absence of UV irradiation. The surface of the microcrystals before UV illumination was rod-shaped; while the surface became scale-like and the wettability reduced drastically upon the irradiation of UV light, exhibiting the combination of photochromic and photoresponsive wettability properties. From then on, Yu's group has successively explored the diverse properties of triarylethylene derivatives, including morphology-dependent photochromism,39 real-time photo-controlled surface,40 oxidation gated photochromism,41 and photochromic-photoluminescent dual-mode response.42 Very recently, Yu and coworkers43 have prepared a new photoresponsive material, a methylmethacrylate-containing triphenylethylene (TrPEF2-MA), that can be directly used for digital light processing (DLP) 3D printing. TrPEF2-MA-printed 3D structures have excellent photochromic properties such as high resolution (50 μm), fast photo-response, and good reversibility. The saturation chromaticity of the 3D structures can also be accurately controlled by adjusting the ratio of TrPEF2 and MA in the component. Moreover, through DLP-3D printing, the materials can realize information encryption and storage characteristics in 3D structures, which has a good application prospect.
The aggregated state of photochromic molecules plays an important role in controlling the optical and photochromic properties. To date, photochromism of triphenylethylene derivatives that have been reported typically occurs in solution states or polymer thin films instead of crystalline states, owing to the difficulty of photocyclization occurring in the rigid crystalline environment. However, it is crucial to develop solid-state photochromic materials for practical applications. The transformation of the aggregated state of solid powder is expected to have an impact on the regulation of photochromic properties.
Herein, a new triphenylethylene derivative, (2-(2,2-bis(4-fluorophenyl)vinyl)phenyl)diphenylphosphine oxide (TrPEoPO), was designed and synthesized. Initially, the crystalline powders obtained from slow recrystallization showed no obvious photochromism. However, the amorphous state of the same compound obtained from rapid vacuum rotary evaporation showed excellent photochromic properties and recyclability. Moreover, the different aggregated states and photochromic properties can be interconverted into each other. Therefore, we successfully realized the gated transformation of photochromism by switching the aggregated state of the solid from the crystalline to the amorphous form, demonstrating a new strategy for the regulation of photochromism.
The basic photophysical properties of TrPEoPO were first studied in the solution state. As shown in Fig. 1b, the UV-vis absorption and photoluminescence (PL) spectra of TrPEoPO were recorded in diluted dichloromethane (DCM, c = 1.0 × 10−5 M) at room temperature. There was an absorption band with a maximum at ca. 315 nm, which could be attributed to the π–π* transition of TrPEoPO according to the previous reports with similar structures.44 In the PL spectra, the TrPEoPO in DCM showed an emission peak at 387 nm, which was consistent with its violet emission upon excitation with UV light (365 nm).
Furthermore, the photochromic properties of TrPEoPO were also investigated in DCM solution (c = 0.10 M). Upon UV light irradiation (365 nm), the colorless and transparent solution turned orange gradually and a new absorption band with a maximum at 460 nm was observed for TrPEoPO (Fig. 1c). Meanwhile, the absorption peak disappeared slowly along the decolorization of the solution from orange to the original colorless state when exposed to visible light or when the UV irradiation (365 nm) was removed for about 30 minutes. According to the previous work,38 the reversible changes in color can be ascribed to the ring-closure and ring-opening of the stilbene moiety of TrPEoPO as illustrated in Fig. 1d. As a result, the degree of conjugation of the molecular structure was changed, thereby realizing the displacement of its absorption spectrum.
In contrast to the photochromism in the solution state, the white solid powders obtained directly by recrystallization from a solution of TrPEoPO in DCM/hexane (1:1 v/v) showed no photochromic phenomenon when viewed with naked eyes. Nevertheless, upon the removal of the solvent by rapid vacuum rotary evaporation, amorphous samples can be obtained. After quickly cooling down to the room temperature, the amorphous samples with glossy surfaces unexpectedly exhibited photochromic properties. Upon UV light irradiation (365 nm) for 10 seconds, the samples could change their appearance from colorless to orange (Fig. 2a).
Time-dependent UV-vis reflectance spectroscopic studies were carried out as shown in Fig. 2b–e. In contrast to the weak rise of the intensity of the absorption band for the crystalline powder, the amorphous form of TrPEoPO exhibited an obvious and significant enhancement in the absorbance at 500 nm. After irradiation for about 150 s, the increase in absorbance stopped. Similar to the aggregated-state-dependent irradiation spectrum described above, although UV light (365 nm) was irradiated for over 3 minutes, there was no obvious absorption peak in the reflectance spectra of TrPEoPO in the crystalline state (Fig. 2d). The intensity of the absorption band (peak at 500 nm) gradually decreased with the removal of the UV light (365 nm) and returned to its initial colorless state in 3600 seconds in the dark as shown in Fig. 2e. Moreover, the photochromic bleaching rates and half-lives of TrPEoPO in solution and amorphous states were calculated by the first-order rate equation as shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†). In addition, the amorphous state of TrPEoPO exhibited excellent recyclability during the photochromic process. As depicted in Fig. 2f, the sample showed no detectable fatigue even after 20 cycles of photochromic and bleaching. The high recyclability indicates its potential applications as rewritable and optical information storage materials.
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was carried out to monitor the weight loss of TrPEoPO under an atmosphere of N2 at different temperatures. As can be seen in Fig. S5 (ESI†), there was only one mass loss process with no residue, which ended at about 390 °C. Meanwhile, the decomposition temperature (Td), defined as the temperature with a 5% loss in weight, of TrPEoPO was 283 °C. The relatively high Td indicated the good thermal stability of the samples, which was attributable to the rigid structure comprised of the triphenylethylene and phosphine oxy groups of TrPEoPO. Second, Fig. 3c shows the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) curves of TrPEoPO. Initially, the crystalline samples were heated from 30 to 220 °C to eliminate the thermal history with a heating rate of 10 °C min−1 under a N2 atmosphere. An endothermic peak due to melting could be obviously observed at 136 °C. Then the amorphous powders were rapidly cooled back to 30 °C for the second cycle of DSC analysis. When the cooled samples were reheated at the same heating rate, a clear shift in the heat capacity was observed. The glass transition temperature (Tg) was determined from the outset of heat flow to be 95 °C. The emergence of the glass transition phenomenon, which is considered as one of the characteristics of amorphous systems, suggested the formation of the amorphous samples after melting and cooling. In addition, the above conclusion can be further verified by the characterization via PXRD. The PXRD patterns of TrPEoPO in the two aggregated states are shown in Fig. 3d. Initially, the crystalline powders exhibited clear diffraction peaks evidencing a high crystallinity, which is consistent with the presence of a high endothermic peak in the first heating cycle in the DSC curve as described above. However, the samples obtained from rapid vacuum rotary evaporation showed only diffuse scattering rather than sharp diffraction peaks, indicating the formation of an amorphous state.
The transition of the aggregated states implies the collapse of the rigid environment and the weakening of the intermolecular interactions, in turn facilitating the occurrence of the ring-closure reaction of TrPEoPO under UV light (365 nm). This is the fundamental reason why the same sample exhibits distinct luminescent and photochromic properties after the transformation from a crystalline aggregated state to an amorphous aggregated state.
As shown in Fig. 4b, the crystalline samples of TrPEoPO were placed on a quartz plate (30 × 30 × 3 mm), in the center of which was a groove with a side length of 20 mm and a thickness of 2 mm. Clearly, the white crystalline powders of TrPEoPO showed no photochromism and remained unchanged under UV light (365 nm), neither with nor without photo masks. After UV irradiation, however, the amorphous solid with a transparent and smooth surface showed the shape of a flower and turned orange quickly under the cover by black mask A, due to the photochromism of TrPEoPO. When the mask was removed and treated with visible light, the orange color disappeared gradually and the initial colorless state was recovered. Additional patterns such as a tower could then be consecutively drawn on and erased from the surface of amorphous powders in the quartz plate, showing excellent reversibility and recyclability. The samples could completely turn orange and fill up the entire groove when no mask was used. Moreover, the reversible transformation of crystalline and amorphous forms can be realized by means of recrystallization and rapid vacuum rotary evaporation. Thus, an interconvertible and rewritable optical information storage material could be accomplished by a simple control of the aggregated state of the solids.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic procedures, experimental details, and supplemental figures. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3tc01093g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |