Komal Sethi,
Shalini Sharma and
Indrajit Roy*
Department of Chemistry, University of Delhi, Delhi-110007, India. E-mail: indrajitroy11@gmail.com
First published on 9th August 2016
In this paper, we report the synthesis, characterisation, and controlled drug delivery applications of drug-encapsulated iron carboxylate nanoscale metal organic frameworks (NMOFs). The nanoscale frameworks, blank and drug-encapsulated, were synthesized in a normal micellar medium, using two different coordination solvents (DMF and DMSO). Structural aspects were studied using TEM and FESEM, from the results of which, we concluded that formed frameworks are reasonably monodisperse and have spherical geometry. The study of their magnetic behaviour using VSM revealed that the saturation magnetization values are markedly different for the NMOFs synthesized in the two coordinating solvents, which is attributed to the different ligand strengths of the coordinating solvents. Nile red or doxorubicin hydrochloride were encapsulated within the formed NMOFs, which showed slow and sustained drug release behavior. The superparamagnetic properties of the NMOFs prepared in DMF as coordinating solvent were exploited for magnetically aided delivery to cells in vitro. Cell viability studies revealed enhanced cytotoxicity for drug-encapsulated nanoparticles when compared to that of the free drug.
Magnetic nanoparticles are widely used by the biomaterials community due to their unique properties, such as superparamagnetism, low coercivity, high magnetic susceptibility, etc.14–18 Their applications include contrast enhancement in MRI, magnetically targeted drug delivery to diseased sites, in vitro detection of disease biomarkers, etc.19–24 Colloidal magnetic nanoparticles, such as iron and cobalt oxides, bimetallic alloys (e.g. Fe–Co, Fe–Ni), ferrites, etc. have been well explored.18,25–27 However, poor drug-loading efficiency, colloidal instability in the biological milieu, and cytotoxicity are some of the drawbacks that have restricted their use in drug delivery.28 NMOFs with incorporated magnetic moieties, or coordination magnetic nanoparticles, are a promising alternative in this realm. Here, the presence of the organic group per s imparts enhanced colloidal stability and ease of surface functionalization. These porous magnetic nanostructures can efficiently carry drug molecules, either by physical encapsulation or by chemical conjugation. Several studies have reported the use of Fe-containing NMOFs as for co-delivery of drugs and imaging agents in cells.11,29
Keeping in view of the magnetic properties and high-drug loading of Fe-containing NMOFs, we investigated whether we can use this system for magnetically-directed drug delivery in cells in vitro. Ferric chloride and 2-aminophthalic acid was used to synthesize this network in a hydrophobic core of a normal micellar medium. The NMOFs were characterized using various techniques for studying their physical and chemical properties. We have also investigated the possible impact of coordinating solvents (DMSO or DMF) on the magnetic behaviour of the NMOFs. We hypothesized that by varying coordinating solvent, the electronic configuration of the central metal ion can be tuned, which leads to the formation of high-spin or low-spin complexes with varying saturation magnetization values. These nanoparticles were used for drug delivery in cells in vitro, without and with the presence of external magnetic guidance.
To determine the magnetic properties of both F-NMOF and S-NMOF, they were probed using vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM), having a Model 3473-70 electromagnet amplifier (CREST Performance CPX 900 power amplifier Instrument). UV-visible absorption and fluorescence emission spectra were measured using Shimadzu UV-1601 spectrophotometer and Cary Eclipse spectrofluorimeter, respectively. Release profile of DOX loaded S-NMOF and F-NMOF was carried out against phosphate buffer saline at 37 °C solution for a period of 15 days.
First, we studied the non-specific as well as drug-induced cytotoxicity of these blank and drug-loaded NMOFs. To the A549 cells in 24-well plates at a confluency of 60–70%, three different dosages of blank or drug-loaded S-NMOF and F-NMOF nanoparticles and free drug were added. The dosages (final concentrations in the wells) were 700, 350 and 175 μg mL−1 for the NMOFs; as well as 5.0, 2.5 and 1.3 μM for DOX. The treated cells were then allowed to incubate for 24 h. After this, 100 μL of MTT reagent in FBS (5 mg mL−1) were added to each well and left in the incubator for 2 h. After this the media was aspirated and 1 mL of DMSO was added in each well to dissolve the blue colored formazan crystals. The optical density was measured at 570 nm spectrophotometrically and the cell viability calculated.
Next, we probed whether externally applied magnetic force can influence the cellular uptake and cytotoxicity of the F-NMOF nanoparticles. For cellular uptake, we analysed the total intracellular iron content (for blank F-NMOFs) and fluorescence intensity (for fluorophore nile red tagged F-NMOFs) by analysing the lysates of treated cells. To A-549 cells in 35 mm plates at a confluency of 70–75%, blank or fluorophore-tagged F-NMOF nanoparticles were added (final concentration = 175 μg mL−1). Magnetic guidance was provided to some of the plates by placing a bar magnet below them, while the remaining plates did not receive magnetic guidance. All the plates were treated for either 5 or 10 min. After treatment followed by thorough washing, the contents were dissolved by adding 10 mM HCl solution per well for 2 hours. HCl acts a lysing and dissolving agent for the cells and its contents, including uptaken nanoparticles, leading to release of Fe3+ ions in the system. The dissolved solutions were transferred to test tubes, and 100 μL of iron detection reagent was added to each tube. This reagent was prepared by mixing 2.5 M of ammonium acetate, 1 M of L-ascorbic acid, 6.5 mM of ferrozine {3-(2-pyridyl)-5,6-bis(phenyl sulfonic acid)-1,2,4-triazine} and 6.5 mM of neocuproine {2,9-dimethyl (1,10-phenanthroline)}. This reagent is sensitive for Fe3+ ions in the mixture and forms a pinkish coloured complex with an absorbance maximum at 560 nm. The value of absorbance obtained directly correlates with the amount of Fe3+, hence these values were used to calculate the amount of Fe3+ using a previously drawn calibration curve involving absorbance and corresponding concentration of Fe3+. Similarly, the total intracellular fluorescence was also detected by analysing the lysates of the treated cells for the emission of the fluorophore nile red in a spectrofluorimeter.
Finally, the effect of magnetic guidance on the drug-induced toxicity of DOX/F-NMOFs (1.25 μM of DOX in 175 μg mL−1 of F-NMOF) was studied in 35 mm plates. Here, the nanoparticle-treatment (without and with external magnetic influence) was carried out for 10 minutes. For comparison, the cells were also treated with the same amount of free drug (1.25 μM) in a similar manner. After washing, the plates were returned to the incubator for 48 hours. After that, the cell viability was measured using the already described MTT assay.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (A1, A2): TEM images (scale bar = 0.5 μm); (B1, B2) FESEM images (scale bar = 1 μm); and (C1, C2) DLS plots. (A1, B1 and C1): S-NMOF and (A2, B2 and C2): F-NMOF. |
The elemental compositions of S-NMOF and F-NMOF obtained from EDS data are provided in Fig. 2A and B, respectively. EDS spectrum for S-NMOF contains an additional peak of sulphur in comparison to F-NMOF, confirming the existence of DMSO (as coordinating solvent) in the formed framework in S-NMOF. The presence of copper in both the systems is a result of contamination from the TEM grid.
The selective area electron diffraction (SAED) micrographs of S-NMOF and F-NMOF are shown in Fig. 3A and B, respectively. The data shows that both S-NMOF and F-NMOF are moderately crystalline. Powder XRD data (Fig. 3C) agreed that both S-NMOF and F-NMOF are moderately crystalline, with structures matching that of the well known MIL-88B pattern of iron-containing NMOFs.
Magnetic behaviour of S-NMOF and F-NMOF was obtained from VSM data (Fig. 4A and B). Both these nanoparticles show paramagnetic behaviour, with negligible coercivity (insets, Fig. 4A and B). It is interesting to note that there is a remarkable difference in the values of saturation magnetization for F-NMOF (59.75 emu g−1) and S-NMOF (0.24 emu g−1). We hypothesize that the reason for such distinction in their magnetization values lies in the strength of the coordinating solvent used. Since, both the coordinating solvents (DMF and DMSO), as well as NH2-BDC, are bulky ligands, they are more likely to form octahedral complex with the metal ion to avoid ligand–ligand repulsion. As DMSO acts as a stronger coordinating ligand in comparison to DMF, the energy gap between t2g and eg levels is more in comparison to that in DMF. Therefore, S-NMOF and F-NMOF are likely to form low spin and high spin complex, respectively. In both cases, the oxidation state of iron is +3 (d5 configuration); thus in S-NMOF it occurs as t52g (1 unpaired electron), whereas in F-NMOF it splits as t32g and e2g (Scheme 1). As the magnetic character relies directly on the number of unpaired electrons, F-NMOF has more magnetization in comparison to S-NMOF. Overall, the high saturation magnetization value of F-NMOF makes it an exciting candidate as porous non-colloidal magnetic nanocarriers for magnetically-aided delivery.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Magnetization curves obtained using VSM for (A) S-NMOF and (B) F-NMOF. Inset shows expanded view of VSM data near zero magnetic field. |
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Effect of coordinating solvents/ligands on the electronic arrangement and spin pairing in d-orbital for iron(III) in (A) S-NMOF and (B) F-NMOF. |
The NMOFs were loaded with the lipophilic fluorophore nile red (NR) for their optical tracking. The optical properties of both free (NR) and nanoencapsulated (NR/S-NMOF and NR/F-NMOF) fluorophores were studied using absorption and emission spectroscopies. The absorption data is given in Fig. S1(A) ESI.† The results show that the absorption maximum (λmax) of the nanoencapsulated fluorophore has blue-shifted in comparison to that of free fluorophore. The fluorescence emission data (at normalized optical density) shows that the emission intensity of the nanoencapsulated fluorophore has decreased and blue-shifted when compared to that of the free fluorophore, shown in Fig. S1(B) ESI.† Overall, the optical properties of the fluorophore are retained, though diminished upon nanoencapsulation. This can be attributed to the open-cage like structure of these NMOFs, where the encapsulated fluorophore is partially exposed to the outside environment. Nevertheless, the fluorescence emission from the fluorophore-encapsulated NMOFs is appreciable and they can be used in optical imaging applications.
Next, we examined the time-dependent release of the drug DOX from DOX/S-NMOF and DOX/F-NMOF in PBS for 15 days. While both the systems showed sustained release patterns (Fig. 5), the drug release in DOX/F-NMOF is higher (maximum release of 88% in 15 days) in comparison to that in DOX/S-NMOF. Such slow and sustained drug release has been observed by Horcajada et al. from chromium and iron-containing NMOFs loaded with the drug ibuprofen.30 The data shows that both these NMOFs can be used in sustained drug release applications, and can avoid faster and burst-release behaviour witnessed with other drug nanocarriers, including some NMOF formulations.11,29
In vitro studies were carried out to observe the cellular uptake efficiency of the NMOFs, via estimation of intracellular iron content. The data is shown in Fig.S2, ESI† and it explains that both NR/S-NMOF and NR/F-NMOF have appreciable non-specific cellular uptake. We then studied the non-specific and drug-induced cytotoxicity of the drug-loaded NMOFs using cell viability assay (Fig. 6). The study was carried out at three different concentrations (of drugs and nanoparticles) in order to have a broad working range. The data shows that while blank nanoparticles are non-cytotoxic at the dosages studied (175 to 700 μg mL−1), the drug-loaded nanoparticles showed dose-dependent toxicity (drug concentration range 1.3 to 5 μM). Free drug is seen to be less toxic with respect to its nanoencapsulated form at the same drug concentration, which can be attributed to the inherent drug resistance showed by several cells and enhanced entry of nanoencapsulated drugs in cells.31 The IC50 value of the encapsulated drug in both cases (DOX/S-NMOF and DOX–F-NMOF) is close to 1.5 μM. whereas for free drug it is much higher.
Finally, we explored whether the cellular uptake and drug-induced toxicity of the F-NMOF (with high saturation magnetization) can be further enhanced with the help of external magnetic force. Estimations of intracellular iron content (Fig. 7A) and fluorescence intensity of nile red (Fig. 7B) show that in both cases the uptake can be enhanced with the use of external magnetic force (with 5 and 10 minutes of treatment). Cell viability data (Fig. 7C) shows that the cytotoxicity of the drug-loaded nanoparticles (DOX/F-NMOF) is enhanced upon magnetically guided delivery, whereas only a negligible effect of magnetic targeting is observable in case of the free drug (DOX). This shows that indeed magnetic guidance can enhance the cellular uptake and drug-induced toxicity of the drug-loaded F-NMOFs.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra18480d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |