Ajay Vikram
Singh
*a,
Yunus
Alapan
a,
Timotheus
Jahnke
b,
Peter
Laux
c,
Andreas
Luch
c,
Amirreza
Aghakhani
a,
Soheila
Kharratian
d,
Mehmet Cengiz
Onbasli
e,
Joachim
Bill
b and
Metin
Sitti
a
aPhysical Intelligence Department, Max Planck Institute for Intelligent Systems, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany. E-mail: avsingh@is.mpg.de
bInstitute for Materials Science, University of Stuttgart, Heisenbergstr. 3, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany
cDepartment of Chemical and Product Safety, German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), Max-Dohrn-Strasse 8-10, 10589, Berlin, Germany
dKoç University, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Sarıyer, 34450 Istanbul, Turkey
eKoç University, Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Sarıyer, 34450 Istanbul, Turkey
First published on 17th October 2018
A surfactant-less, seed mediated, biological synthesis of two dimensional (2-D) nanoribbons in the presence of breast cancer cells (MCF7) is demonstrated. The diameter and yield of nanoribbons are tunable via seeds and gold precursor concentration. Such crystalline nanoribbons serve to enhance the Raman signals over MCF7 cells. The side and slopes of the triangular nanoplatelets fused as nanoribbons exhibit plasmon excitement in quadrupole resonance modes in the infrared region. Consequently, when irradiated with an infrared laser they show an excellent photothermal effect and rapid rise in temperature. The experimental results verified by finite-difference time-domain (FTDT) calculations reveal the presence of wedge-plasmon polaritons propagating along the edges of the nanoribbons. These simulations confirm that long aspect ratio nanoribbon's edges and vertices act as an active optical waveguide, allowing for heat propagation along the long axis, killing cancer cells in the process at lower power doses.
The fabrication of anisotropic gold nanoparticles can be accomplished by a seed-mediated nucleation technique using a wet chemical method.3 However, this reaction requires toxic chemical reductants and stabilizers in solution, which limits its biomedical applications.4 Here, we present a biological route of anisotropic gold nanoparticle synthesis that is biocompatible and seeded on a bioorganic surface coating, known as a “biomolecular corona”.5 The shape of particles can be controlled during growth on the surface of cells using polypeptides that bind specifically to inorganic surfaces as functional molecules6 or by involving membrane vesicles as templates for in situ engineering.7 However, a high-yield fabrication of high aspect ratio nanostructures, such as nanowires and nanoribbons, has not yet been demonstrated.8
Using the biological synthesis method, a small fraction of NPs with anisotropy has been produced by E. coli-secreted proteins containing specific polypeptide sequences, which induce the growth of flat triangular particles.9–11 Similarly, intra- and extracellular anisotropic NP growth in different cell lines are reported10via a slow reduction process by varying culture conditions (serum vs. no-serum culture).6 However, the aqueous phase biological synthesis of nanoribbons under ambient conditions remains still unsolved. Such a benign route of synthesis, on one hand, makes nanoribbons highly biocompatible and on the other hand, their high aspect ratio would help for rapid propagation of photothermal plasmonic wave for biomedical applications. Herein, we present an in situ method of obtaining two-dimensional (2D) nanoribbons with a length of several micrometers grown on the surface of cancer cells. Our method also enables temporal control over the synthesis process by variation and tuning of the seed size, allowing for the versatile growth of different micro/nanostructures.
We have recently reported a biomineralization process, which turns ionic gold into spherical nanoparticles and anisotropic microplate structures, depending on the serum concentration of a cell culture medium.6 We were able to demonstrate that defense proteins related to cellular stress in cancer cells are able to reduce ionic gold and subsequently bind to specific crystal surfaces. This led to the anisotropic growth of gold NPs. Within 24 h of addition of the gold precursor solution, a sudden pH change of the cell culture medium occurred, the serum and cell membrane proteins in serum culture denatured, and the reduction of gold Au3+ to spherical nanoparticles as Au0 was triggered. The instantaneous pH drop led to an unfolding of the 3D protein structures, which enabled access to hydroxyl and thiol groups. Particularly, functional groups in tyrosine and tryptophan acted as electron donors and stabilizers for gold seeds and NPs, assisting in the reduction of Au3+ to metallic AuNPs12 as:
To test this hypothesis, we incubated mouse myoblast C2C12 and breast cancer cell line MCF7 cell monolayers with 1.5 mM AuCl4 salt solution under serum-free conditions.6 Eight hours after addition of the gold salt solution, we added 10 μL mL−1 of 20 nm spherical gold NPs, as seeds pre-synthesized by mammalian cells. Following a reaction time of 24 h, we found worm-like structures on the culture surface as well as on the cell monolayer (Fig. 1A–F). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis demonstrated that the worm-like structures are triangular thin platelets fused tip-to-end, producing nanoribbon-like patterns in the process. Also, as qualitatively visible from the SEM images in Fig. 1A–C compared to Fig. 1D–F, MCF7 cells fabricate more nanoribbons than C2C12. Higher production might be related to the more versatile extracellular secretion of MCF7 cells compared to that of mouse myoblasts.13 We hypothesize that the nanoribbon synthesis under serum-free conditions is initiated by diffusion of gold ions from the bulk to the cell membrane via surface diffusion.
Over the cell membrane, reductions and irreversible incorporation of growth species (gold ions) into anisotropic thin microplatelet crystal structures take place via nucleation growth.6 When seed NPs are added, the anisotropic triangular platelet-like structures are fused together as long nanoribbons. From a thermodynamic perspective, a crystal lattice matching of the overlapping parts of the triangles occurs to minimize the interface energy. This is displayed in Fig. 2A schematic, showing the tip of one triangle overlapping another triangle along its side. Hereby the (111) lattice planes of both triangles match, resulting in the distinctive form of the nanoribbons.14 Further desorption and diffusion of the soldered chain of triangular particles take place from the surface to the culture medium, as shown via SEM images in Fig. 1A–F. The nanoribbon features are shown to mainly originate from protruding cellular filaments (e.g., filo/lammelipodia). We observed nanoribbons with a width of 50–200 nm (Fig. S2, ESI†) and a length of up to 60 μm protruding from the cell edges (Fig. S1A and B, ESI†). Among the different steps of the anisotropic growth, irreversible incorporation of growth species into the crystal structure, generally acted as the growth limiting step. In the presence of gold seeds and gold binding peptides (GBP) secreted under similar conditions, we expect preferential adsorption of GBP on the {100} rather than {111} crystal planes, which allows an ordered anisotropic growth to produce nanorods (NRs) and nanowires. However, we observed nanoribbons with high aspect ratios, which require a liquid crystalline phase with biomolecules from MCF7 cells as soft templates in bulk.15 In addition, the secreted GBP must have several times more hydrophobicity with better interfacial adsorption to promote nanoribbon growth in the presence of NP seeds.16
Compared to the recent work showing multiply-twinned platelet and hexagon synthesis using cancer cells, herein, fused thin nanoplate synthesis with a twinned layer in the range of 150–200 nm could have a vital influence for biomedicine applications, since the thickness of the nanoplates affects the plasmon resonance.17 Contrary to thin platelets, end-to-end arranged multiply-twinned nanoribbon structures exhibit very diverse plasmon transmission through the corners and propagation along the edges.18 These unique features could contribute to the enhanced photothermal destruction of tumors via utilization of these nanoribbons as long-range plasmonic waveguides. Further experiments were carried out using only the cancerous MCF7 cells to demonstrate cancer cell killing. We next investigated the influence of seed and gold ion concentration on nanoribbon size and shape control. Increasing the gold ion concentration from 1.5 mM to 2 mM, while keeping the seed concentration the same, resulted in a change of nanoparticle shapes from nanoribbons to triangular and hexagonal microplates (Fig. S3A and B, ESI†). In contrast, varying the concentration of seed NPs from 10 μL mL−1 to 25 μL mL−1 with 1.5 mM gold ions, an increase in the yield of nanoribbons was observed (Fig. S3C and D, ESI†). High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HR-TEM) analysis demonstrated that these nanoribbons are formed by thin, single crystalline flake-like units joined together at regular intervals (Fig. 2B–E). Seed particles, added to accelerate the reaction, did not only help in seed-mediated nucleation and growth but also played a crucial role in fusing triangles into nanoribbons.
As shown in TEM images in Fig. 2B, quasi-L shaped nanoribbons show multiple spherical seed nanoparticles near the bend of L-shaped ribbons, indicating that these units are independently formed via seed-mediated reduction. The band-like patterns shown in a single crystal triangle arise due to the difference in the electron density caused by bending or deformation of the nanoribbon possibly as a consequence of the radiation effect of the electron beam as reported in thin metal foils (Fig. 2D–E).8 TEM analysis of the edge of the sheets (Fig. 2E) shows the rough nature of the edges of the gold prisms, indicating a biological corona formed at the edges. Particle attachment seems to occur in different stages in the scheme (Fig. 2A): the seed particles attach to the triangles, preferably at the edges of the sheets, in order to reduce the surface energy. Then the seed particles match the underlying crystal structure of the gold triangles. These gold NPs seem to be in a liquid gold state and align to the single crystalline prism.19,20 Upon coming into contact with another triangle, the aligned seed particles act as a glue between them and an oriented attachment occurs between both. Repetition of this process leads to long shapes, composed of triangles, which are overlapping tip-to-side, in order to match their crystal lattice structure on the (111) facet. This correlates well with the HR-TEM image in Fig. 2E, showing a nearly perfect single crystal structure. The interplanar lattice distances could be measured as 0.247 nm. The electron diffraction pattern exhibits a crystal texture in the (111) direction, which is caused by the large (111) facet facing upward and being perpendicular to the beam axis.
The growth of nanoribbons by an intermediate liquid gold is in agreement with our recent report;20 however, further work is warranted. We measured surface-plasmon resonances of individual thin triangular gold platelets and their transformed nanoribbon structures using 3D finite difference time domain (FDTD) simulations at high spatial resolution. The simulation results demonstrate the presence of wedge-plasmon polaritons propagating along the nanoplatelets and nanoribbons (Fig. 2F–H). Extracting the surface features from the TEM and SEM images and directly applying the FDTD simulation clearly demonstrate that the edges of nanoribbons act as plasmonic waveguides for rapid transmission of optical signals.
Energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis confirms the presence of gold and carbon/nitrogen/oxygen arising from the proteinaceous/biomolecular organic phase (Fig. S3E, F and S4A–E, ESI†). X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis of the nanoribbons has further confirmed the presence of metallic gold with a small fraction of Au(I) gold (Table 1) still present. The binding energies of Au 4f doublets with a peak at 84.4 eV and 87.8 eV correspond to Au 4f7/2 and Au 4f5/2, respectively. They are caused by the metallic nature of nanoribbons.
Name | Position | FWHM | Height CPS | Area |
---|---|---|---|---|
4f5/2 | 87.8 | 1.46 | 645.75 | 1043.72 |
4f5/2 | 90.8 | 1.46 | 291.25 | 470.74 |
4f7/2 | 84.5 | 1.46 | 1192.97 | 1928.21 |
An additional peak was observed at 90.8 eV representing the Au(I) state, which is related to partially reduced ionic gold within the nanoribbon network. We further noted amide-, carbonyl- and alkyl-associated carbon peaks, which arise due to electron emissions from the diverse organic material associated with these nanoribbons (Fig. 3A–C). The XPS N 1s spectra were assigned to amine/amide (400.5 eV) from the nanoribbon surface indicating the role of secreted proteins in the synthesis process.21
Rapid analysis of the biochemical composition of a single living cell using non-invasive, highly sensitive, and label-free techniques has important implications in cell-based micro- and nanotechnologies for biomedical applications. Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) provides a non-destructive solution for such single cell analysis methods at an unprecedented resolution.22 Raman spectra recorded at 632 nm incident wavelength from control cells without gold ion treatment were noisy, and individual Raman peaks were not discernible (compare Fig. 3D–F and G–I). However, gold ion-treated cells showed a series of bands that corresponded to diverse biopolymers also found in the cells (Fig. 3G–I). We observed the nucleic acid peaks at 1067 nm (PO2 in DNA) and 831 nm (PO2 in RNA), Protein Amide(III) at 1220 nm and amino acids phenylalanine at 1000 nm, tyrosine at 854.1 nm, and tryptophan at 754 nm. The lipid peaks between 1448–1460 nm display shoulders which might arise from the direct interaction with the nanoribbon surface, as lipids are known to stabilize and modify the NP surface corona.23 Sugar ring associated C–O–C Raman peaks were identified spreading between 800–1500 nm.24 The characteristic peaks of fixed cells around 1005 nm were found diminished due to enhanced signals associated with nanoribbons.22 Mono-substituted aromatic compounds exhibit strong ring vibration at 1000 nm (e.g., Phe, Trp) and 850 nm (e.g., Tyr), with a slight shift arising due to different substitution symmetry as observed in our analyses.25 The presence of these amino acids further corroborates our hypothesis of protein-mediated reduction/capping and seed-nucleation growth of nanoribbons reported herein.26
Metallic materials are of great interest for near-infrared (NIR) hyperthermia applications since they show great promise as efficient tools for tumor ablation.27 Gold nanoparticles, nanorods, and nanowires have been reported as potential materials; yet clinicians are in quest of superior hyperthermia agents, which are easy to synthesize, incorporate and give efficacious results.4,27 Promising results have been obtained from previous reports of hybrid nanowires of gold NPs decorated with silica; however, they require PEGylation for higher uptake and relatively higher laser power to destroy cancer cells.28 Comparatively, cell-based, seed-mediated growth of nanoribbons described in this report has several advantages. First, since biological cells synthesize the nanoribbons, they are highly biocompatible and no functionalization is required for cellular uptake. Second, lower laser power and radiation dose are needed for tumor ablation due to a sharp rise in temperature upon laser irradiation (Fig. S6, ESI†). Finally, strong NIR absorption is observed due to plasmon excitement via the edges for trigonal platelets in the 100–200 nm thickness range18 (UV-vis spectra in Fig. S7, ESI†). The side and slopes of the triangular nanoplatelet-ribbons exhibit plasmon excitement in quadrupole resonance modes involving complex field distribution on the surfaces in the infrared region. Therefore these nanoribbons could be powerful NIR hyperthermia agents, complementing photothermal tumor ablation, rivaling the state-of-the-art cancer hyperthermia agents reported recently.
To test the photothermal efficacy, the nanoribbons obtained in aqueous solution were purified overnight inside a dialysis bag with a 340 kDa molecular weight cut-off. Subsequently, nanoribbons were irradiated with a 780 nm NIR laser at a power density of ∼0.6 W cm−2 inside Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM), water and phosphate buffered saline (PBS) as controls. Compared to the control group, where we found no obvious increase in temperature, nanoribbons exhibited a significant increase in temperature when exposed to the NIR laser. Compared to the temperature change obtained with commercial nanorods used in photothermal therapy and spherical nanoparticles synthesized with breast cancer cells reported in our previous protocol, nanoribbons demonstrated a superior photothermal effect upon irradiation with the NIR laser.6,29 Maximum temperatures recorded after NIR laser irradiation correlates with these findings: gold nanoribbon (65.5 °C) > gold nanorods (50.2 °C) > spherical NPs (39.1 °C) (Fig. 4A–C). We believe that tip-to-side soldered thin nanoplatelets in nanoribbons act as photothermal transducers or antennas to absorb the light.30 The large anisotropy in shape significantly enhances the conversion of external light to thermal heat. Furthermore, they even convert the energy more efficiently than anisotropic gold nanorods/spherical NPs.29,30
Additionally, we evaluated the photothermal ablation capacity of the nanoribbons to investigate in vitro hyperthermia of breast cancer cells MCF7. For this, we incubated MCF7 cells with gold ions to synthesize gold nanoribbons, as described in the previous section, and spherical NPs in situ, as reported recently.6 Subsequently, cells were exposed to a 780 nm laser of ∼0.6 W cm−2 for 5 min at three different spots. In a parallel control experiment, we incubated MCF7 cells with PEGylated gold nanorods before NIR irradiation. After NIR irradiation, we stained the cells with trypan blue and Calcein as shown Fig. 4D–G and H–K, respectively. The breast cancer cells with nanoribbons showed the largest number of dead cells (lowest cell viability) compared to controls (untreated cells), spherical gold NPs, and gold nanorods after NIR ablation (Fig. S8, ESI†). These in vitro hyperthermia experiments demonstrate that gold nanoribbons could be highly efficacious for in vivo tumor ablation as compared to other NIR sensitive anisotropic gold nanostructures reported so far.
In conclusion, we have reported the first example of the seed-mediated in vitro biological synthesis of nanoribbons on the surface of cancer cells. The one-pot, in situ methods reported herein show batch production of the nanoribbons with high reproducibility. The nanoribbons could be used as powerful SERS imaging and NIR hyperthermia agents, complementing photothermal tumor ablation and rivaling the state-of-the-art cancer hyperthermia agents reported recently. The present in vitro findings suggest new opportunities for novel gold-based cancer nanomedicine. Nonetheless, further work is necessary for a better understanding of the in vivo efficacy of cancer killing of these nanoribbons within a tumor micro-environment. The effect of aspect ratio on photothermal conversion is also a matter of further investigation in lieu of novel emerging biomedical applications for hyperthermia, particularly in bacterial biofilm treatment.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8tb02239a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |