Andivelu
Ilangovan
*,
Palaniappan
Sakthivel
and
Pandaram
Sakthivel
School of Chemistry, Bharathidasan University, Tiruchirappalli – 620 024, Tamil Nadu, India. E-mail: ilangovanbdu@yahoo.com
First published on 19th September 2016
A simple one-pot procedure for conversion of 2-iodo/2-nitro benzoic acids and dihydropyranone fused benzoic acids into corresponding anilines, using tosyl azide, under transition metal-free conditions is explained. TsN3, is one of the more stable azides, much cheaper and easy to handle. This method is environmentally benign, adoptable for large scale preparation. Different factors such as steric and electronic effect of 2-iodo/2-nitro substituents, and the effect of conformational constraints of the fused dihydropyranone ring on co-planarity of the aromatic ring should contribute to the success of this reaction. Tosyl nitrene was found to be involved in the decarboxylation reaction. As this method is simple, scalable and requires only simple reagents we expect this method to find widespread application in organic synthesis.
Classical methods for the synthesis of anilines involve sequential electrophilic nitration and reduction under harsh conditions,4 and aromatic nucleophilic amination of compounds substituted with specific functional groups.5 Substituted anilines could also be prepared from acyclic precursors.6 Another important strategy is to form the C–N bond through coupling reactions such as Buchwald–Hartwig, Chan–Lam, and Ullmann-type in the presence of a transition metal,7 or under metal-free conditions.8 However, these reactions are mainly suitable for making secondary and tertiary anilines but not for primary anilines.
The next important and particularly useful approach for the preparation of primary anilines from carboxylic acid or its derivatives is through molecular rearrangements such as Curtius,9 Schimidt,10 Hoffman11 and Lossen12 involving an isocyanate intermediate. Although, acyl azides are useful starting materials for obtaining aniline, the drawbacks associated with it make it less attractive. Acyl azides are unstable and difficult to handle, the acid chloride or mixed anhydride13a,b used in its preparation are moisture sensitive, and phase transfer catalysts needs to be used to improve solubility of NaN3 in organic medium.13c Another and most widely used reagent in the Curtius rearrangement is diphenylphosphorazidate (DPPA).14a–c However, this reagent is toxic and moisture sensitive, and separation of desired products from the phosphorus residues is difficult and usually requires high temperature.14d Dess–Martin periodinane–NaN3 could be used to convert aldehydes to acyl azides,15 but the reaction has to be conducted below 0 °C to suppress thermal rearrangement of isocyanate. Acyl azides can also be prepared by diazotization of acylhydrazines,16 however it is not a convenient procedure. Recently, Lebel et al.17 reported a Curtius rearrangement/palladium-catalyzed indolization (Scheme 2, eqn (1)) approach for the direct synthesis of substituted indoles starting from readily available 2-iodobenzoic acid in one pot.
Decarboxylative cross-coupling reactions are highly site selective and have been used as a new tool in C–C as well as C–heteroatom (C–S/O/N/P/halogen) bond forming reactions.18 In case of benzoic acids the ortho-nitro group19 was found to facilitate the decarboxylation. Among these transformations, C–N bond forming reactions remain largely unexplored.20 Particularly, in the case of aromatic carboxylic acids, there are only two reports available (Scheme 2, eqn (2) and (3)).21 These reports reveals that decarboxylative C–N cross coupling of ortho-nitro benzoic acid or its potassium salt with different N-nucleophiles could be carried out in the presence of copper(II)–phenanthroline complex (eqn (2))21a or CuSO4 (eqn (3))21b respectively. Interestingly, literature background reveals that decarboxylative C–N bond formation of ortho-iodo benzoic acid is unknown. Recently, several other C–H functionalisation approaches to access anilines were also reported.22
During a recent study on the synthesis of biologically active heterocycles23 we examined Pd-catalyzed ortho-C–H amidation24 of pyranochromanone acid 6a using p-toluenesulphonyl azide (tosyl azide, TsN3) and K2CO3 in DMF (Scheme 3). We were delighted to find the formation of pyranochromanone aniline t-7a instead of ortho-C–H amidation product 8. Furthermore, the same reaction took place even in the absence of palladium catalyst. Since aryl carboxylic acids are known to undergo decarboxylative functionalisation only in the presence of transition metals,18 we were surprised to observe the formation of aniline even in the absence of a transition metal. This serendipitous result impelled us to look into the scope and limitation of tosyl azide as reagent for the conversion of substituted aromatic acids in to anilines. Herein we present our results.
Delightfully, a mixture of o-iodobenzoic acid (1a) and tosyl azide (2), in DMF, stirred for 3 h at 80 °C, in the presence of K2CO3 (1 eq.) gave o-iodo aniline (3a), albeit in moderate yield (60%, Table 1, entry 1). Then we examined different reaction parameters and the results are summarised in Table 1. Fascinatingly, the yield of the product 3a improved to 90% when the quantity of K2CO3 was increased to 2 equiv. (entry 2). Further, increasing the quantity of K2CO3 or increasing the quantity of tosyl azide did not improve the yield (entries 3 and 4). At r.t. no reaction was observed (entry 5). Change of solvent to DMSO (entry 6) led to lower yield of aniline 3a and no reaction was observed with ACN, MeOH, THF, toluene and DCE as solvent (entry 7). Changing the base to NaHCO3 (entry 8) decreased the yield and with DBU, DABCO and TEA (entry 9) no reaction was observed. Similarly, other azide reagents such as DPPA, nosyl azide (p-nitrobenzene sulphonyl azide) and MSN3 (entries 10–12) led to decreased yield. With TMSN3 (entry 13) no reaction was observed. Based on these results, treatment of acid 1a (1.0 mmol) with tosyl azide (2, 1.2 mmol) and K2CO3 (2.0 mmol) in DMF (4 mL) at 80 °C (entry 2) was identified as the optimum conditions for further study.
Entry | Azide | Base | Solvent | Temp (°C) | Time (h) | Yieldb (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: 2-iodobenzoic acid (1a, 1 mmol), azide (1.2 mmol), base (2 mmol), solvent (4 mL). b Isolate yield. c 1.0 equiv. K2CO3 used. d 3.0 equiv. K2CO3 used. e 2.0 equiv. tosyl azide used. f NR = no reaction. | ||||||
1. | TsN3 | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 3 | 60c |
2. | TsN 3 | K 2 CO 3 | DMF | 80 °C | 2 | 90 |
3. | TsN3 | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 3 | 90d |
4. | TsN3 | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 3 | 90e |
5. | TsN3 | K2CO3 | DMF | r.t. | 12 | NRf |
6. | TsN3 | K2CO3 | DMSO | 80 °C | 12 | 20 |
7. | TsN3 | K2CO3 | ACN, MeOH, THF, toluene, DCE | 80 °C | 24 | NRf |
8. | TsN3 | NaHCO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 12 | Trace |
9. | TsN3 | DBU, DABCO, TEA | DMF | 80 °C | 24 | NRf |
10. | DPPA | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 3 | 70 |
11. | Nosyl azide | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 4 | 65 |
12. | MSN3 | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 12 | 45 |
13. | TMSN3 | K2CO3 | DMF | 80 °C | 12 | NRf |
Having optimized the reaction conditions, we examined the one-pot conversion of different ortho-iodobenzoic acids into the corresponding anilines and the results are portrayed in Scheme 4. Comparison of reactivity of 2-iodobenzoic acids 1b–1e, revealed that there is not much difference in rate of the reaction due to the presence of different electron-donating substituents, such as 5-OMe, 4,5-OMe, 3,5-OMe and 3,4,5-OMe, and the products 3b–3e were obtained in good yields. Interestingly, compounds 1f and 1g containing electron-withdrawing groups 5-Br and 5-NO2 furnished anilines 3f and 3g, respectively, in very good yields, but the rate of the reaction is slow compared to when electron-donating substituents are present. However, in the case of meta- and para-iodo substituted benzoic acid 1h and 1i no reaction was observed. When the reaction was tried with a halogenated benzoic acid, such as 2-bromobenzoic acid (1j), 2-chlorobenzoic acid (1k) and pentafluorobenzoic acid (1l), no conversion took place. This shows that halo substituents other than 2-iodo are ineffective.
Since ortho-nitrobenzoic acids are well known to undergo decarboxylative coupling reactions,20,21 we next explored the scope of this reaction on different ortho-nitrobenzoic acids under the optimized conditions. The results are summarized in Scheme 5. As expected, 2-nitrobenzoic acid (4a) produced aniline 5a in excellent yield. 2-Nitrobenzoic acids 4b–4d, possessing electron-donating substituents such as 5-OMe, 4,5-OMe, 3-OMe on the phenyl ring underwent facile one-pot conversion to corresponding anilines 5b–5d in high yield. In the case of methyl substitution, compared to 5-Me substituted acid 4e, the sterically more hindered 2-Me substituted acid 4f gave the corresponding aniline in excellent yield. This clearly shows that steric effect has significant influence on the rate of the reaction. For the acids 4g and 4h, containing the inductively electron-withdrawing chloro group, with substitution at the strongly influencing para position, 4h gave a complex mixture, where as 4g with substitution at the weakly influencing meta position gave product 5g albeit in low yield (25%). Similarly, the acid 4i with the strong electron-withdrawing 4-NO2 group produced only a complex mixture of products. This reveals that electron-withdrawing substituents do not favor the reaction.
Interestingly, although compound 4j contains the moderately electron-withdrawing 2-COOMe group, the corresponding aniline 5j was obtained in moderate yield (60%). This result, as well as results with acids 4e and 4f, shows that the steric influence is much more important than the electronic effect for this reaction. The reaction failed in the case of acids 4k (3-NO2) and 4l (4-NO2) and this reveals that ortho substitution of nitro groups is essential for the reaction to take place. It is useful to note that the methods reported for decarboxylative C–N bond formation of ortho-nitrobenzoic acids using CuCl221a or CuSO421b provides amides or secondary anilines. However, the primary anilines obtained under the present study are open for the preparation of many derivatives in addition to amide or secondary anilines.
As a part of the study we next examined conversion of pyranochromanone acids and related compounds into the corresponding aniline derivatives under the optimized conditions (Scheme 6). Similar to pyranochromanone acid 6a, substrates 6b and 6c with fused dihydropyanone ring provided the corresponding anilines tc-7b and 7c in high yield. Likewise, the O-prenyl group in acid 6d tolerated the reaction conditions well to provide aniline t-7d in good yield. The starting materials 6a–d, were taken as racemic mixture of cis and trans disatereomers and the corresponding products tc-7a (trans:cis = 55:45) and tc-7b (trans:cis = 87:13) were obtained as racemic mixture of cis and trans disatereomers. The product t-7d was obtained as a racemic mixture of trans diastereomer only. However, acid 6e, without any fused ring system, failed. It is important to note that acids 7a–d are structurally different from 2-iodo/2-nitrobenzoic acids, wherein the ortho substitution is not bulky but the reaction took place. As described by others25 we believe that the fusion of the dihydropyranone ring system would affect co-planarity of the benzene ring particularly during the decarboxylation process. Further, these results infer that for the desired conversion to take place at least one ring should have been fused to the benzoic acid ring.
Further, in order to establish a practical utility of the present method, a gram-scale experiment was carried, under the optimal reaction conditions (Scheme 7). Starting from acids 1a (5.0 g), 4a (5.0 g) and 6a (5.0 g), the desired anilines 3a (3.86 g), 5a (3.72 g) and 7a, (3.84 g) were obtained in 88%, 90% and 85% isolated yields, respectively. This is notable for both the scalability and environmental compatibility of the present method.
Further, we investigated the scope of this reaction with different substituted benzoic acids 9–15, and aliphatic carboxylic acids 16–18 (Fig. 1). However, all these substrates failed to undergo reaction under the optimized conditions.
Fig. 1 Carboxylic acid failed to undergo one-pot conversion to amine using tosyl azide and other possible intermediates. |
Next, we examined mechanistic aspects. To check the possibility of formation of isocynate intermediate, same as Lebel et al. (Scheme 2, eqn (1))17 we tried to trap it by adding diphenyl acetylene (22) during conversion of acid 1a to aniline 3a (Scheme 8). However, no indole 23 was formed, which confirmed the absence of a Curtius rearrangement pathway. Further none of the possible intermediates such as mixed anhydride 19, aryl azide 20 and acyl azide 21 expected through different ways of reaction between carboxylate and TsN3, could be detected in the reaction mixture (Fig. 1).
The foregoing discussion reveals that for the decarboxylative C–N bond formation to take place 2-iodo or 2-nitro substitution or fusion of dihydropyranone ring to benzoic acid is essential and steric effect has a significant influence on the decarboxylation. The electron-withdrawing nature and mainly the steric bulkiness of the 2-iodo or 2-nitro group may help destabilization co-planarity of the benzene as well as stabilization of the negative charge generated during the decarboxylation. Formation of the product 5f in high yield, compared product 5e highlights the importance of steric hindrance for the effective completion of the reaction. Unlike the reports from others21 using CuSO4 and CuCl2, conversion of 2-nitrobenzoic acid was observed by us without using a transition metal catalyst. This suggests that the reaction might take place through a novel pathway.
Thus we considered the involvement of tosyl nitrene.26a,b All the azides studied TsN3, DPPA, nosyl azide, MsN3 (Table 1, entries 2 and 10–12) are known to undergo thermal decomposition to form nitrene26 and provided anilines. However, TMSN3 which can't form nitrene at ≤80 °C, failed to provide aniline (Table 1, entry 13). As with carbenes the fate of nitrenes is also dependent on the solvent26a and in the present study except DMF and DMSO all other solvents failed the reaction. Also during the gram scale experiment we observed the bubble formation due to the liberation of nitrogen and CO2 gas. This confirms the involvement of tosyl nitrene in the reaction. Thus, we have observed for the first time nitrene undergoing ipso attack on the benzene ring. Based on these observations a suitable reaction mechanism is proposed as shown in Scheme 9.
Nitrene I formed by thermal decomposition of TsN3 (path-a), is expected undergo decarboxylative addition to potassium carboxylate II to form tosylamide III which on tautomerisation and hydrolysis should give rise to aniline 3 or 5. It is also likely that carboxylate II may also undergo reaction directly with TsN3 to form benzoyloxytosylamide VI which in turn is expected to form tosylamide III.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental, spectral data and copies of spectra. See DOI: 10.1039/c6qo00343e |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2016 |