Open Access Article
Zhongju
Ye
a,
Hua
Liu
a,
Fuyan
Wang
b,
Xin
Wang
a,
Lin
Wei
b and
Lehui
Xiao
*a
aState Key Laboratory of Medicinal Chemical Biology, Tianjin Key Laboratory of Biosensing and Molecular Recognition, College of Chemistry, Nankai University, Tianjin, 300071, China. E-mail: lehuixiao@nankai.edu.cn; Web: https://www.xiaolhlab.cn
bKey Laboratory of Chemical Biology & Traditional Chinese Medicine Research, Key Laboratory of Phytochemical R&D of Hunan Province, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Hunan Normal University, Changsha, 410082, China
First published on 12th November 2018
It has been demonstrated that rod-shaped particles can achieve a high translocation efficiency for gene and drug delivery in biological samples. Previous theoretical calculations also confirmed that rod-shaped particles display higher diffusivity than their spherical counterparts in biological porous media. Understanding the diffusion dynamics of biological and non-biological rod-shaped particles in biological solutions as well as close to the lipid membrane is therefore fundamentally significant for the rational design of efficient cargos. With dark-field optical microscopy, the translational and three-dimensional (3D) orientational diffusion dynamics of individual rod-shaped particles (i.e., E. coli and upconversion microrods, UCMRs) in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) and on the lipid membrane are tracked at the single-particle level. In the buffer solution, faster rotation of E. coli in the z direction was observed even though its dynamics in the x–y plane is comparable with that of UCMRs. Interestingly, on the lipid membrane, distinct from the confined motion of UCMRs, anomalous rocking diffusion was observed, which might facilitate the subsequent survey of stronger association sites on the two-dimensional (2D) surface. These results would afford deep insight into the better understanding of the translocation mechanism by using rod-shaped particles as a delivery cargo in biological samples.
According to previous explorations, the role of the size, morphology and surface chemistry of particles significantly affects the intravenous circulation time, translocation across the cell membrane and intracellular transport routes for drug and gene delivery.3,12–15 Particularly, for rod-like particles, comprehensive theoretical calculations illustrate that the diffusivity is much higher than that of their spherical counterparts in biological matrices.16–18 Transient adhesive interactions with the host matrix play key roles in such anomalous diffusion.19–21 Recent explorations also found that elongated rod-shaped inorganic particles exhibit a noticeable cellular translocation efficiency with size dimensions comparable to those of bacteria through carefully manipulating the surface chemistry.3 However, different from inorganic particles, biological organisms can swim actively and explore the environment, providing an advantage for gene delivery.22–25 This is not possible for non-biological vectors. To further extend the potential biological functionality of these rod-shaped particles, it is noteworthy to comprehend the movability of these two structures (biological and non-biological) in solutions and at the biological interface (e.g. close to the lipid membrane), where the mechanism of motility controls the primary step for the subsequent cellular uptake process.26 However, so far, little knowledge has been gained on the difference in the diffusion dynamics between biological and non-biological particles with similar dimensions particularly close to the 2D interface (e.g., lipid membrane).
On this account, in this work, we explored the translational and rotational dynamics of a bacterium (i.e., E. coli) and rod-shaped inorganic particles (with size dimensions comparable to those of the bacterium, UCMRs) in confined (close to the lipid membrane) and free space with dark-field optical microscopy for the first time. According to the single-particle tracking results, it was found that E. coli swims and rotates much faster than UCMRs in either free or confined space. In PBS buffer, the rotational motion of E. coli in the z direction is noticeably more active than that of UCMRs, resulting in a slow sedimentation rate in the biological matrix. However, on the lipid membrane with non-specific adhesive interactions, the bacterium displays anomalous rocking diffusion with occasional tilting motion in the z direction. The rotation of flagella on the bacterium surface might be one of the essential sources to promote this kind of motion. For rod-shaped particles, invading into the lipid membrane through anchoring one of the ends to the membrane surface and being followed by continuous rotational motion were reported previously.21 In contrast to the bacterium, both of the rotational and translational diffusions of UCMRs were restricted due to the limited thermal energy. These results would afford deep insight into the better understanding of the distinctive translocation efficiency by using these particles as delivery cargos.
:
18
:
2) was mixed with 2.5 mL of 2.08 M sodium citrate under stirring for 30 min to form a white solution. Subsequently, 10 mL of 0.625 M NaF solution was injected into the solution. The solution was stirred for another 1 h before the pH of the mixture was adjusted to about 3.0 by adding a dilute HNO3 solution. Afterwards, the obtained solution was treated at 180 °C for 6 h. After cooling to room temperature, the products were separated by centrifugation and washed with ethanol three times and then dried at 60 °C in a vacuum. The morphological and size characterization of these UCMRs was performed with a Sirion 200 field emission scanning electron microscope.
:
1), for 15 min. Then the solvent was removed by evaporation under vacuum conditions. The lipid film was swollen with PBS buffer and suspended by vortex for 30 min. The SUV solution we used in this experiment was diluted to 0.5 mg mL−1 with PBS. A porous polycarbonate membrane (with a pore size of 100 nm) with a mini-extruder apparatus was used to extrude the solution 21 times. The resulting 100 nm SUV solution was stored at 4 °C prior to use.
The lipid bilayer was prepared inside a custom-built flow channel on a clear cover glass slide by self-assembly at 37 °C. 50 μL of the freshly prepared SUV solution was injected into the channel and incubated for 30 min at 37 °C. After that, the channel was washed with PBS. The integrity of the lipid bilayer was measured using Texas-Red DHPE. Texas-Red DHPE was mixed with POPC during the SUV fabrication process. The homogeneously intercalated dye molecules on the lipid bilayer result in an evenly distributed fluorescence signal within the flow channel which demonstrates that the lipid bilayer is successfully generated.
The large size and strong scattering properties of these two particles can greatly enhance the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of optical imaging. Therefore, good localization accuracy and fast sampling frequency can be achieved. The single-particle tracking experiments were performed on a Nikon Eclipse Ni–U upright optical microscope (Japan). A halogen lamp was focused onto the sample via an oil immersion dark-field condenser (NA 1.43–1.20). Scattered light from the sample was collected using a 40× objective, and the successive images were captured with a sCMOS camera (ORCA-Flash 4.0, Hamamastu, Japan) that was mounted on the front port of the microscope within a single frame. The exposure time was set to 10 ms. The pixel size of the sCMOS camera is 6.5 μm × 6.5 μm.
All images were processed with ImageJ (http://rsbweb.nih.gov/ij/). To precisely track the translational and rotational motion of the rods, we chose an ellipsoidal model and adopted the feature point tracking algorithm for the automated detection and quantitative analysis of particle trajectories recorded with the sCMOS camera. The accurate displacement information in the x–y plane was deduced based on the mass center of the particle. The angle information in the z direction can be obtained from the length fluctuation in the long axis.
The translocation direction of the particles in the biological matrix is largely affected by the strength of the drag force along the opposite direction. Basically, in homogeneous surroundings, the strength of the drag force for anisotropic nanoparticles in different directions is different. The resulting diffusion direction is the balance between the thermal energy-induced collision from nearby molecules and the ensemble-averaged drag forces in different directions. For example, the drag coefficient of solid ellipsoid particles moving along the lengthwise and sidewise directions is fa = 4πηa/ln(2a/b − 1/2) and fb = 8πηa/ln(2a/b + 1/2), respectively, where f is the drag coefficient, a and b are the length along the long and short axes of the ellipsoid particle, respectively, and η is the viscosity of the solution. According to recent experimental and theoretical results, it has been demonstrated that the diffusivity of particles in non-adhesive porous media would increase monotonically with the aspect ratio of the rods with the same hydrodynamic diameter and decrease with the aspect ratio of the rods with the same minor-axis diameter.20 To decipher the details of the discrepancy of the diffusivity of the bacterium and inorganic rods in the PBS solution, we then decomposed the diffusion dynamics of these anisotropic particles into two directions, i.e., along the long axis (a) and short axis (b) as shown in Fig. 1c. Representative decomposed diffusion trajectories along a and b axes for single E. coli and UCMRs are shown in Fig. 1g and j, respectively. Evidently, the diffusion of E. coli along the lengthwise direction is higher than that of UCMRs where a comparable step size was noted. On further analyzing the direction-associated diffusion step length along the lengthwise direction (Fig. 1h and k), interestingly, heterogeneous distributions were noted for E. coli in contrast to UCMRs, indicative of different diffusion modes shielded by the ensemble MSD analysis. This occasional larger step size along the lengthwise direction greatly promotes the diffusivity of E. coli in the medium even though these two particles possess the same aspect ratio around 5–6. Considering the drag force along the lengthwise and sidewise directions, the contribution from this factor is not the key to regulating the diffusion discrepancy. For UCMRs, the diffusivity along a and b directions is generally in agreement with that in the physical mode in consideration of the viscous drag force (around 1.5 fold larger along the b direction).
It has been demonstrated that E. coli is surrounded by flagella by which it can rotate and propel itself forward. In non-adhesive surroundings, the ensemble-averaged translational diffusion commonly occurs in a random fashion which is in good agreement with the observation as noted above. In addition to the translational diffusion, we then analyzed the 3D rotational dynamics of these two particles as illustrated in Fig. 2. Along the vertical direction (polar angle), the mean square angle displacement (MSAD, 〈Δθ(τ)2〉 = 〈|θ(t + τ) − θ(t)|2〉, where θ is the polar angle of the particle, τ is the lag time, and the brackets manifest an average value of the polar angle over all trajectories) of E. coli is around one order of magnitude larger than that of UCMRs. Particularly, the exponent α is close to 1 (〈Δθ(τ)2〉 = 2Drτα, where Dr is the rotational diffusion coefficient), representing stochastic angle rotation in the z direction. The rotational capability of particles in the polar angle also correlates with the sedimentation rate. For inorganic particles (UCMRs), the rotational motion along this direction is greatly confined (with an exponent factor of 0.09), which might be ascribed to the large net downward force on the particle. In contrast to UCMRs, the rotation of flagella on the bacterium surface assists the suspension of the bacterium in the solution, resulting in active rotational motion in the z direction. The distribution of the rotational diffusion coefficient in the polar angle further confirmed this point as shown in Fig. 2c. Obviously, the diffusion coefficient of E. coli is larger and broadly distributed than that of UCMRs, manifesting the more active diffusion capability. In the x–y plane, the motions of these two particles are comparable where only the viscous drag force plays the dominant effect. It is worth noting that the rotational capability in the x–y plane of E. coli is still slightly faster than that of UCMRs (Fig. 2b and d), which might be ascribed to the flagella-assisted active motion. For drug or gene delivery applications, the diffusion capability of the cargo is fundamentally significant, which regulates the circulation time in the biological medium. The active movability of biological particles in translational and rotational modes should therefore play essential roles in promoting delivery applications.
. The estimation determines the probability that a particle has moved a distance of Δr along the x or y direction during time Δt. For an apparent Fickian diffusion, the distribution typically follows a Gaussian decay.32–35Fig. 3e shows the double-logarithmic plots of the correlation function of UCMRs and E. coli with a time duration of 0.1 s. Evidently, the curve decays more slowly than a Gaussian distribution for UCMRs on the lipid membrane. This is contrary to the case of E. coli, where the step size is much broader and exhibits a characteristic Gaussian shape, indicative of apparent Fickian diffusion. The non-Gaussian distribution of the UCMRs might be largely attributed to the gravitational drag force close to the interface. Compared with the UCMRs, the flagellar propulsion of E. coli balanced parts of the subsidence effect, leading to more active motion at the interface.
Since the rotational motion might synergistically affect the translational movement, we further determined the rotational dynamics on the lipid membrane. Representative rotational trajectories in the z direction (the polar angle) and x–y plane (the azimuthal angle) are shown in Fig. 4a and 5a, respectively. In the z direction, the rotational movements of these particles are confined with an average angle distribution close to 80° (Fig. 4b). In contrast to E. coli, the tilting movement of UCMRs is significantly inhibited which might be essentially ascribed to the gravitational force when the particles sediment close to the interface. In the case of E. coli, although the movement in the z direction is one-order of magnitude decelerated in contrast to that in the free solution, occasional jumps in the z direction were observed, which is reflected in the MSAD assay in the z direction (Fig. 4c). The angle distribution in this direction also confirms this argument where a larger tilt angle distribution was found (Fig. 4b). The statistically analyzed rotational diffusion coefficient in the polar angle is shown in Fig. 4d. Evidently, a long tail with faster rotational movements was observed for E. coli.
Interestingly, in the x–y plane, the rotational movement of E. coli is much faster than that of UCMRs (one-order of magnitude larger) with the exponent factor in the MSAD plot close to 1 (Fig. 5). This active motion might be propelled by the rotational movement of the flagella on the bacterium surface. A much broader angle distribution and faster rotational diffusion were found for E. coli in the azimuthal angle (Fig. 5b and d). These observations illustrate that even though the rotational movement of E. coli on the lipid membrane is confined, the motion of the flagella might greatly assist the active motion close to the interface. However, it is still interesting why most of the E. coli exhibit circular rocking diffusion at the interface as shown in Fig. 3b.
To date, many research studies and models have been exploited to explain the dynamics of these delivery cargos.36–43 Most bacteria exhibit random walk in homogeneous environments. Bacterial random walk is often biased when the environment changed.44E. coli is surrounded by flagella by which it can rotate and propel itself forward, such as the well-known run-and-tumble mobility. When running, all the flagella rotate counterclockwise (CCW) and form a bundle. It gives the swimmer a propulsive force which is balanced by the viscous fluid drag force. The bacterium can swim at a steady speed in a straight line until it tumbles. The flagellar bundles disassembled when they encountered some external stimuli, leading to reorientation, and thus they are kept away from unfavourable environmental conditions by changing the swimming direction. When swimming in a non-uniform environment, such as the case close to the lipid membrane, the mobility of the organism may change in a tempo-spatially dependent manner.39 Taking into account these considerations, the anomalous behaviour of E. coli on the lipid membrane can be well delineated as below. Given one of the terminals of the E. coli adhered onto the lipid membrane, the rotational motion of the flagella propels the E. coli to move circularly together with slight sliding motion. Provided the flagellar bundles disassembled, occasional tilting jumps in the z direction might take place in association with diffusion direction transition, resulting in the anomalous rocking diffusion close to the interface.
Gene or drug delivery with functional materials is a realistic prospect for the treatment of cancers and has being investigated and employed clinically for a wider range of diseases in recent years.45,46 However, some grand challenges still exist, such as the poor loading efficiency, limited biocompatibility, and fast sedimentation rate in biological fluids. The development of efficient and convenient vectors for delivery purposes is now widely acknowledged.47 In general, vectors for delivery applications can be classified into non-biological and biological models. As demonstrated in previous studies, non-biological vectors such as UCMRs are attractive for delivery applications because of their safety profile. However, the efficiency of cellular translocation from current non-biological approaches is comparatively poor in contrast to that of biological vectors such as bacteria, thereby limiting clinical efficacy and restricting the range of applicable therapeutic approaches.48 Therefore, a better understanding of translational and rotational dynamics of biological and non-biological vectors in biological matrices should provide great significance on the rational design of efficient delivery cargos.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |