Yuta
Shiroma‡
a,
Hiroto
Mogi‡
a,
Takeaki
Mashiko
b,
Shuhei
Yasuda§
c,
Shunta
Nishioka
a,
Toshiyuki
Yokoi
c,
Shintaro
Ida
d,
Koji
Kimoto
b and
Kazuhiko
Maeda
*ae
aDepartment of Chemistry, School of Science, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 2-12-1-NE-2 Ookayama, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, 152-8550, Japan. E-mail: maedak@chem.titech.ac.jp
bElectronic Functional Materials Group, Polymer Materials Unit, National Institute for Materials Science, 1-1 Namiki, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, 305-0044, Japan
cNanospace Catalysis Unit, Institute of Innovative Research, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 4259 Nagatsuta-cho, Midori-ku, Yokohama, 226-8503, Japan
dInstitute of Industrial Nanomaterials (IINa), Kumamoto University, 2-39-1 Kurokami, Chuo-ku, Kumamoto, 860-8555, Japan
eLiving Systems Materialogy (LiSM) Research Group, International Research Frontiers Initiative (IRFI), Tokyo Institute of Technology, 4259 Nagatsuta-cho, Midori-ku, Yokohama, Kanagawa 226-8502, Japan
First published on 11th April 2023
Modification of the interlayer nanospaces of lamellar solids is an effective means of enhancing the physical properties and chemical functions of such materials. The present work demonstrates the interlayer modification of the layered perovskite oxynitride K2LaTa2O6N, a photocatalyst having a ∼600 nm absorption edge and exhibiting visible-light-driven H2 evolution activity. This material was subjected to various interlayer modifications, including H+/K+ exchange, ethylamine (EA) intercalation and exfoliation with tetra(n-butyl)ammonium hydroxide (with subsequent restacking) while maintaining its capacity for visible light absorption. H2 evolution activity from aqueous methanol with the aid of an optimal amount of a Pt cocatalyst was improved by a factor of approximately 60 following EA intercalation to increase the interlayer spacing of the host material. However, subsequent exfoliation-restacking to yield flocculated nanosheets led to a decrease in activity as compared with the EA-intercalated specimen. The present results indicate that the intercalation of EA provided interlayer nanospaces suitable for Pt cocatalyst loading and so promoted the photocatalytic H2 evolution reaction, while the restacked nanosheets did not provide space for Pt loading.
Mixed anion compounds have recently received considerable attention as potential functional materials, and the interlayer modification of lamellar mixed anion compounds is of interest.17–19 As an example, the exfoliation of nitrogen-doped layered CsCa2Ta3O10 (CsCa2Ta3O9.7N0.2) as a means of synthesizing a heterogenous photocatalyst has been reported.20 In some cases, phase-pure undoped layered oxynitrides are preferable to their nitrogen-doped analogues because the former exhibit superior visible light absorption and limited formation of anion vacancies due to aliovalent O2−/N3− exchange.21 However, the interlayer modification of undoped layered oxynitrides has rarely been reported. This lack of studies can be attributed to the poor stability of undoped layered oxynitrides in the aqueous media22 used for interlayer modification. The chemical instability of these materials is a serious challenge, as this instability leads to the loss of nitrogen. This effect eventually lowers the visible light absorption capacity of the compound.
Recently, we found some exceptional cases of chemically stable layered oxynitrides, which include K2LaTa2O6N23 and K2Ca2Ta3O9N.24 Ida et al. reported that a three-layer specimen of the oxynitride perovskite Na2Ca2Ta3O9N could be exfoliated to produce nanoscale sheets. These sheets exhibited photocatalytic water splitting activity and were also able to transition to a free-standing film.25 The present work demonstrates the interlayer modification and single layer exfoliation of the Ruddlesden–Popper oxynitride K2LaTa2O6N with the aim of obtaining high photocatalytic activity. K2LaTa2O6N, which has a structure comprising two-layer perovskite blocks, undergoes H+/K+ exchange in water while maintaining a suitable degree of visible light absorption.23,26 This material also shows much higher photocatalytic activity than the three-layer analogue because of a longer photogenerated free electron lifetime.24
Therefore, the application of K2LaTa2O6N to photocatalytic reactions after suitable modification is of interest. The interlayer nanospaces in layered metal oxide photocatalysts are typically employed as reaction sites.7,12,13,27–29 However, this technique has rarely been applied to undoped layered oxynitrides. This study confirms that the interlayer modification of the layered oxynitride, K2LaTa2O6N, with a Pt cocatalyst improves photocatalytic activity during visible-light-driven H2 evolution.
Restacked material was obtained by adding a 2.0 M aqueous KCl solution dropwise to the nanosheet suspension. The flocculated solid formed by this addition was then collected by centrifugation and dried in an oven overnight at 333 K. The resulting restacked nanosheets are referred to herein as R–K2LaTa2O6N. The entire materials preparation procedure is depicted in Scheme 1.
The apparent quantum yield (AQY) values for the H2 evolution reaction over the various specimens were obtained using a similar setup but with monochromatic visible light (λ = 420 nm). The AQY was calculated as
AQY (%) = (2 × R/I) × 100 |
Sample | Specific surface area/m2 g−1 | Bulk atomic ratioa | Surface N/Ta ratiob | |
---|---|---|---|---|
K/Ta | La/Ta | |||
a Measured by EDS. b Calculated based on the corresponding XPS peak areas. The N 1s XPS peak used for the calculation is attributed to lattice N species. | ||||
K2LaTa2O6N | 5.0 | 1.01 ± 0.04 | 0.60 ± 0.04 | 0.37 |
HxK2−xLaTa2O6N | 7.4 | 0.08 ± 0.01 | 0.52 ± 0.02 | 0.19 |
EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N | 16.0 | 0.10 ± 0.00 | 0.50 ± 0.01 | 0.10 |
R–K2LaTa2O6N | 18.4 | 0.45 ± 0.00 | 0.51 ± 0.01 | 0.10 |
Ideal K2LaTa2O6N | — | 1 | 0.5 | — |
SEM images of the K2LaTa2O6N with and without EA intercalation are provided in Fig. 2. Plate-shaped particles reflecting the layered structure of the material can be seen in both specimens, again confirming the successful topochemical reaction. However, the specific surface area, as determined by nitrogen-adsorption at 77 K, was increased from 5.0 m2 g−1 in the case of the original K2LaTa2O6N to 16.0 m2 g−1 for the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N. The TG data indicated that EA was incorporated in the sample to a level of 8.6 wt% (Fig. S2†).
Exfoliation of the lamellar K2LaTa2O6N to form single-layer sheets was also found to be possible. As shown in Fig. 3a, the reaction of EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N with TBAOH resulted in a yellowish colloidal suspension and this suspension was found to be stable for at least 1 month. Fig. 3b presents a typical AFM image of the colloidal suspension, in which sheet-like objects having lateral dimensions in the range of 0.1–0.5 μm appear. The height profile obtained from this sample indicates that the thickness of the sheets was approximately 1.3 nm and so was very similar to that of the two-layer perovskite blocks in K2LaTa2O6N as determined from crystallographic data.23 In addition, the lateral dimensions of the sheets were consistent with those observed in K2LaTa2O6N by SEM (Fig. 2). These results confirm that TBA+-exfoliated LaTa2O6N2− sheets were successfully prepared, although the material may have contained some residual EA.
Fig. 3 (a) Digital photographs of the TBA+-exfoliated LaTa2O6N2− nanosheet colloidal suspension and (b) a typical AFM image and the height profile of a nanosheet. |
The addition of KCl to the TBA+-exfoliated LaTa2O6N2− nanosheet colloidal suspension led to an immediate flocculation of the colloids. The XRD pattern of the flocculated solid (that is, the R–K2LaTa2O6N) exhibited weak 00l peaks although the intensity of the in-plane reflection peak remained relatively close to that of the parent K2LaTa2O6N (Fig. 1). These data indicate that the flocculated solid did not retain the long-range order of the layered structure present in the parent material but did keep the original in-plane crystallinity. The same behaviour has been observed in studies with other inorganic layered solids subjected to exfoliation and restacking.4,28 The peak position of the 001 plane in R–K2LaTa2O6N was higher than that of the original K2LaTa2O6N, indicating a narrower interlayer. This could be due to the insufficient intercalation of K, which is supported by the EDS results (Table 1). SEM observations also confirmed the formation of a disordered structure in the restacked material (Fig. 2). The specific surface area of the R–K2LaTa2O6N was determined to be 18.4 m2 g−1.
As shown in Fig. 4, EA intercalation did not significantly alter the position of the absorption edge of the host K2LaTa2O6N, which was located at 580 nm. However, the intensity of the Kubelka–Munk function was decreased following EA intercalation. This result suggests some loss of nitrogen from the K2LaTa2O6N, although a quantitative evaluation of the nitrogen content was difficult because the specimen incorporated EA, which also contained nitrogen. The visible light absorption capability was further reduced in the case of the R–K2LaTa2O6N. Our group previously demonstrated that layered K2LaTa2O6N shows high (photo)chemical stability in aqueous media. Specifically, the proton-exchange reaction of K2LaTa2O6N in aqueous HCl was found to produce a slight initial reduction in the nitrogen content of the material but no ongoing loss of nitrogen.23 However, the K2LaTa2O6N could have been damaged by the present multi-step treatment involving proton-exchange, EA intercalation, exfoliation with TBAOH and KCl restacking, resulting in a loss of nitrogen content that lowered the visible light absorption of the material. This possibility is supported by the observation that the bulk N/Ta atomic ratio in the R–K2LaTa2O6N (N/Ta = 0.38 ± 0.02) was lower than that in the layered K2LaTa2O6N (N/Ta = 0.50 ± 0.05).
The surface electronic states of the K2LaTa2O6N and its derivatives were investigated by XPS. As shown in Fig. 5, the K and La peak positions were not changed significantly after proton-exchange, EA intercalation or subsequent restacking, although the K signal was significantly reduced in the case of the HxK2−xLaTa2O6N and the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N. In contrast, some changes were evident in the Ta 4f and N 1s spectra. The Ta 4f XPS spectrum of the K2LaTa2O6N contained broad peaks, indicating that Ta species having different oxidation numbers were present in this material (see Fig. S3† for details), as discussed in a previous paper by our group.26 Following proton-exchange, the Ta 4f peak became sharper and showed features typical of Ta5+. A loss of the lattice nitrogen content from the surface was also observed after the proton-exchange (Table 1). It is therefore considered that the nitrogen species bound to the tantalum was removed by the proton-exchange, thereby placing the tantalum in a more oxide-like (more ionic) environment. The intercalation of EA into the HxK2−xLaTa2O6N resulted in a shift of the Ta 4f peak to a lower binding energy while maintaining the Ta5+ features. These effects can be ascribed to electronic interactions between the intercalated EA and Ta species in the interlayers. The R–K2LaTa2O6N kept the lower binding energy of the Ta 4f peak even though the majority of the intercalated EA molecules had been removed, as shown in Fig. 1. This result implies that some residual EA molecules remained in the interlayer spaces. Further evidence for this was supplied by the asymmetric peak associated with the 001 reflection of the R–K2LaTa2O6N (Fig. 1). The position of the N 1s peak was also changed, and the change in the binding energy can be explained in the same manner as for the Ta 4f by considering the electron density around Ta atom. It should be noted that the surface N/Ta atomic ratio obtained from the XPS data (N/Ta = 0.10, see Table 1) was much lower than the bulk ratio (N/Ta = 2.83 ± 0.25), again suggesting that EA molecules were intercalated in the bulk HxK2−xLaTa2O6N (see also Fig. S4 and additional discussion in ESI†).
The H2 evolution activity of the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N was found to depend on the Pt loading. As shown in Fig. S5,† the H2 evolution rate was increased with increases in the Pt concentration up to 3 wt%, beyond which the rate decreased. An initial induction period was observed in all cases and was associated with the consumption of photogenerated electrons via reduction of the Pt precursor rather than by water reduction.38 The total amount of H2 produced from the 3 wt% Pt/EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N was approximately 180 μmol, which exceeded the photocatalyst amount (ca. 91 μmol), indicating the catalytic production of H2. The AQY of the 3 wt% Pt/EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N was 2.0% at 420 nm. Although there is a room for improvement of the photocatalytic activity (e.g., by optimizing metal cocatalysts39 and operating conditions40), this value is comparable to (or slightly higher than) the AQY of Pt/ZrO2/TaON (1.7%), one of the most active oxynitride photocatalysts for H2 evolution.41 Without Pt deposition, the amount of H2 evolved was very small (approximately 0.6 μmol over a 10 h reaction), demonstrating that the deposited Pt provided H2 evolution sites. This enabled to calculate a turnover number for H2 evolution with respect to Pt to be 23. It should also be noted that increasing the Pt loading from 1 to 3 wt% in trials with the R–K2LaTa2O6N did not increase the H2 evolution rate (Fig. S6†).
The XRD pattern obtained from the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N following the reaction showed that the 001 peak position was moved to a higher angle (Fig. 7). This result indicates that the interlayer nanospaces of the HxK2−xLaTa2O6N, which had been expanded by EA intercalation, were narrowed. This effect was likely due to the removal of the intercalated EA during the reaction. Further evidence for the loss of EA was obtained from the results of 13C CP/MAS NMR and TG analyses (Fig. S1 and S2†). Nevertheless, the peak position was still at a lower angle compared with those in the HxK2−xLaTa2O6N and R–K2LaTa2O6N patterns, suggesting that the interlayer spacing in the reacted EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N remained wider than in the latter two materials (also see Fig. S7 and additional discussion in ESI†). Importantly, no significant changes were identified in the UV-visible DRS data acquired from the sample following the reaction. From this lack of change, it is evident that the capacity of the HxK2−xLaTa2O6N for visible light absorption was unaffected (Fig. S7b†).
Fig. 7 XRD patterns obtained from the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N before and after the photocatalytic reaction. Data for various reference samples are also shown for comparison. |
One possible explanation for the different activities of the present specimens is that the most active material (the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N) had expanded interlayer spacing (Fig. 7). This expansion may have promoted redox reactions, as has been reported based on prior work with layered metal oxide photocatalysts.12,13,27–29 In contrast, no XRD peak shifts were observed when the same experiment was conducted using the R–K2LaTa2O6N (Fig. S8†). That is, Pt could not be deposited in the interlayer spaces of the R–K2LaTa2O6N.
Fig. 8 presents high-resolution SEM images confirming that the post-reaction R–K2LaTa2O6N contained a number of Pt deposits having sizes of 2.1 nm on its surfaces (Fig. S9†). These Pt deposits were not seen in images of the reacted EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N. XPS analyses established that the reacted EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N and the R–K2LaTa2O6N both generated Pt signals (Fig. S10†) but the surface Pt/Ta atomic ratio was smaller in the former (Pt/Ta = 0.024) than in the latter (Pt/Ta = 0.046). The Pt 4f peaks for the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N sample appeared at higher binding energies than those generated by the R–K2LaTa2O6N. This outcome indicates that the Pt species in the former were more cationic than those in the latter and implies that the former Pt species interacted strongly with the LaTa2O6N2− layers.13 As shown in Fig. S11,† the Pt/R–K2LaTa2O6N catalysed the H2–O2 consumption reaction while the Pt/EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N did not.
Fig. 8 High-resolution SEM images of the reacted R–K2LaTa2O6N and EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6. Pt deposits can be clearly seen as brighter spots in the Pt/R–K2LaTa2O6N. |
From these results, it is apparent that intercalation of Pt species in the interlayers of the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N occurred during the photocatalytic reaction. Additional observations were performed using HAADF/STEM combined with EDS in an attempt to directly observe the intercalated Pt in the material. While clear stripe patterns originating from electron-rich LaTa2O6N2− perovskite layers were obtained (Fig. S12†), it was not possible to identify any Pt species because of beam-related damage to the sample during the observations and an overlap of the Pt and Ta signals. Nevertheless, it appears that no significant aggregation of Pt species occurred in the Pt/EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N. These data help to explain the higher activity of the Pt/EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N during H2 evolution as compared with the Pt/R–K2LaTa2O6N.
Interestingly, the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N required a higher Pt loading to achieve peak H2 evolution performance compared with the R–K2LaTa2O6N (Fig. S5 and S6†). This was the case even though the two materials had almost the same specific surface areas as determined by nitrogen adsorption experiments. As noted above, a Pt loading of 1 wt% resulted in the majority of the Pt species being introduced into the interlayer nanospaces of the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N (Fig. 8 and S11†). However, increasing the Pt loading to 3 wt% caused Pt nanoparticles to deposit on the external surfaces of the specimen (Fig. S13†) and, at 5 wt% Pt, the Pt formed larger secondary particles. The need for more Pt in the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N photocatalyst relative to the R–K2LaTa2O6N provides further evidence that the interlayer nanospaces could be utilized as sites for Pt intercalation and H2 evolution. This was not possible in the R–K2LaTa2O6N, meaning that the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N exhibited higher photocatalytic activity during H2 evolution.
The sequential photodeposition of Pt onto the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N starting from the interlayers and moving to the external surfaces was thus demonstrated. Evidently, the interlayer nanospaces of the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N had a strong affinity for H2PtCl6. It has been reported that 1,2-C6H10(NH3)22+ will react with [PtCl6]2− to form [PtC6H10(NH2)2Cl4], most likely as a consequence of a Lewis acid–base interaction.43 A similar Lewis acid–base interaction would be expected to occur between CH3CH2NH3+ (i.e., intercalated EA in the EA/HxK2−xLaTa2O6N) and [PtCl6]2−, thereby resulting in the sequential photodeposition of Pt.
Recently, dye-sensitized niobate nanosheets and nanoscrolls have been reported to function as good H2 evolution photocatalysts capable of functioning under visible light but the low stability of the dye component needs to be addressed.14,44,45 In contrast to such dye-sensitized oxide systems, oxynitride nanosheets that are already capable of absorbing visible light do not require an additional photosensitizer dye. Thus, the results of this work demonstrate the significant potential of two-dimensional LaTa2O6N2− sheets with regard to the construction of visible-light-driven water splitting systems.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ta01387a |
‡ Equal contribution. |
§ Present address: Department of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Engineering, University of Toyama, 3190 Gofuku, Toyama 930-8555, Japan. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |