S.
Selvakumar
*,
Subbaraj
Karunakaran
and
V. Siva
Rama Krishna
Chemical & Mechanical Testing Labs, QC (Process & Labs), Solid Motors Propellant Complex, SDSC-SHAR, Sriharikota – 524 124, India. E-mail: selvakumar.s@shar.gov.in; kumarreka@hotmail.com; Fax: +91-8623-223013; Fax: +91-8623-225154
First published on 26th September 2022
The high toxicity of isocyanate species in the workplace demands the development of sensitive techniques for the detection of isocyanates to protect workers from adverse health effects. To detect airborne isocyanate molecules in a workplace, several analytical techniques such as colorimetry, amperometry, capillary zone electrophoresis, high-performance liquid chromatography and fluorescence are reported in the literature. Among them, fluorescent probes due to their high sensitivity and selectivity grabbed special attention for the determination of the isocyanate group. This review primarily focused on fluorescent derivatizing agents (with amine and hydroxyl groups) available for the determination of isocyanates in the literature and also discussed about fluorescent polymers in non-derivatization mode for isocyanate estimation, which is less explored.
Environmental significanceIsocyanates are a group of highly reactive, low molecular weight organic compounds, which are widely used in the automobile industry, and the manufacture of flexible and rigid foams, and coatings such as paints and varnishes. Although industrially important, organic isocyanates are significantly toxic and exposure to these chemicals causes respiratory-related diseases such as asthma, pulmonary emphysema and bronchitis. For example, the Bhopal gas tragedy, where over 500 thousand people were exposed and eight thousand or more people died within a short time of exposure and thousands of victims were partially injured, having severe health side effects due to the leakage of methyl isocyanate from the pesticide industry at Bhopal, India in 1984. Due to the severe physiological adverse effect of inhalation of isocyanates, regulatory organizations such as the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Occupational Safety and Health Administration and American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists have set occupational exposure limits for these compounds at 5 ppb (Time-Weighted Average TWA) for a full work shift and 20 ppb (TWA) for a short-range exposure limit. However, the estimation of isocyanate concentration in the working atmosphere is critical to protect workers from adverse health effects due to isocyanate's high reactivity, volatile nature and instability. To detect airborne isocyanate vapours in a workplace, several analytical techniques such as colorimetry, amperometry, capillary zone electrophoresis, high-performance liquid chromatography and fluorescence have been reported in the literature. Among them, fluorescent probes due to their high sensitivity and selectivity grabbed special attention for the determination of the isocyanate group. This review is an attempt to give a complete insight into fluorescent reagents for isocyanate detection with a chromatographic separation mode. |
Isocyanates | M. wt | VP (mmHg) | Volatility | Form | PEL TWAd (ppb) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a VP – vapour pressure. b VP – at 20 °C. c VP – at 25 °C. d PEL – permissible exposure limit and TWA – 8 h work shift (OSHA). | |||||
MI | 57.05 | 348b | Very high | Highly volatile liquid | 2 |
HDI | 168.2 | 0.05c | High | Liquid | 5 |
TDI | 174.2 | 0.01c | High | Liquid (mixture of 2,4 and 2,6-isomers) | 5 |
IPDI | 222.3 | 0.0003b | Moderate | Liquid | 5 |
MDI | 250.25 | 0.000005c | Very low | Low melting point solid | 5 |
Even though industrially important, organic isocyanates are significantly toxic and exposure to these chemicals may irritate the skin, mucous membranes, eyes, and respiratory tract.14–16 For example, the Bhopal gas tragedy, where over 500 thousand people were exposed and eight thousand or more people died within a short time of exposure and thousands of victims were partially injured, having severe health side effects due to the leakage of MI from the pesticide industry at Bhopal, India in 1984.17–19 The main adverse health effect associated with isocyanate exposure is respiratory-related diseases such as asthma, pulmonary emphysema and bronchitis.20–33 Due to the severe physiological adverse effect of inhalation of isocyanates, regulatory organizations such as the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) have set occupational exposure limits (OELs) for these compounds at 5 ppb (Time-Weighted Average TWA) for a full work shift and 20 ppb (TWA) for a short-range exposure limit.34–36 However, the estimation of isocyanate concentration in the working atmosphere is critical due to its high reactivity, volatile nature and instability. Hence, various research activities have been carried out to develop rapid and sensitive analytical techniques for the detection of airborne organic isocyanates.
The most commonly used methods to detect and determine airborne isocyanates are the derivatization of isocyanates with an amine or hydroxyl agent at the time of sample collection and the analysis of the resulting derivatives by using various analytical techniques such as colorimetry, gas chromatography (GC), high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE), proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry (PTR-MS) and fluorescence.37–39 Due to the high reactivity of isocyanates towards nucleophiles, the derivatization technique is found to be the best route for the detection and determination of isocyanates. The purpose of derivatization is to stabilize isocyanates and enhance their detection ability.40 Marcali et al. reported a colorimetric technique to determine derivatized isocyanates, which involves hydrolysis of isocyanates to amines, followed by derivatization such as diazotization.41,42 Though this technique is less expensive, it suffers from low sensitivity and is not suitable for aliphatic isocyanates as diazotization is specific only to aromatic isocyanates.43 Schanche et al. developed a detection technique by GC for TDI but the detection for a broader range of isocyanates could not be further explored.44 HPLC with amperometry and UV detection is a widely used technique for the quantification of derivatized isocyanates. However, the use of a non-selective UV detector and unstable amperometry detector result in low sensitivity and therefore is not a reliable approach.45
Rudzinski et al.46 used the CZE technique to determine HDI and its oligomers. Although this technique has five-fold sensitivity for HDI compared to that of HPLC, the repeatability of results was not achievable when there is a small variation in pH. Also, the capillary was found to be degraded within a short period of its usage with some of the derivatizing agents.46 Even though PTR-MS has good sensitivity towards the determination of isocyanates, the instrumental setup is highly expensive.47 Though the UV-Vis spectrophotometry technique is simple and available at any common laboratory, this technique exhibits low sensitivity for the determination of isocyanates.48 Though various derivatizing agents are available in the literature for the detection of airborne isocyanates, HPLC with the fluorescent detection technique is found to be more accurate and convenient for operation due to its high sensitivity and selectivity. Fluorescent probes based on small organic molecules, polymers and nanomaterials have become important tools in the field of cell imaging, tumour diagnosis, drug delivery and sensors because of their extreme sensitivity and excellent specificity.49–51 The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) were also using fluorescence derivatizing agents for the detection of isocyanates due to their high stability and high sensitivity. Specifically, tryptamine-NIOSH 5522, 1-(2-pyridyl)-piperazine (2PP) – OSHA 42/47, and 1-(9-anthracenylmethyl) piperazine (MAP)-NIOSH are widely used as per the NIOSH manual of analytical methods.52–55Table 2 summarizes the widely used fluorescent agents for the determination of isocyanates reported in the literature. The scheme of derivatization with fluorescent reagents is shown in Fig. 2. This review is an attempt to give a complete insight into fluorescent reagents for isocyanate detection with a chromatographic separation mode.
Derivatization reagent | Detection mode | Detection limit | Isocyanates studied | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
NMA | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis | 0.25 μg m−3 (10 ppt) per 20 L air sample/≈ 0.5 ng (3 ppt) per 10 μL sample injection volume | HDI, IPDI, Desmodur N | 57 |
MNMA | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis | 0.001–0.015 mg m−3/0.14–0.44 ppb per 1 L air sample and 50 μL sample injection volume | TDI, MDI, HDI, IPDI, Mondur P, PI, Mondur TD-80, Multrathane M, Mondur HX, Desmodur N75 | 58 |
MAMA | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis | 1 × 10−4 mg m−3 per 15 L air sample and 100 μL sample injection volume | 2,4 and 2,6 TDI, HDI, MDI | 59 |
TRYP | LC-fluorescence, LC-ECD | 0.0005 ppm per 120 L air sample | MI, TDI, HDI, PMPPI, Mondur MR, Mondur CB-75 | 62 |
2PP | UV-Vis, fluorimeter | 64–67 mmol L−1 | 2,4 and 2,6 TDI, HDI, MDI | 65 |
MAP | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis, LC-ECD | 31–124 μmol L−1 | 2,4-TDI, HDI, MDI, PI, BI | 67 |
PAC | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis | 21–83 nmol mL−1 | 2,4-TDI, HDI, MDI, PI, BI | 69 |
NBDPZ | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis, LC-MS–MS | 5–9 nmol L−1 | 2,4 and 2,6 TDI, HDI, MDI, MI, PI, ethyl, propyl, pentyl, hexyl and benzyl isocyanates | 70 |
MMNTP | LC-fluorescence, LC-UV-Vis | 6.7–7.7 pmol per 30 L air sample and 20 μL sample injection volume | 2,4 and 2,6-TDI, HDI, MDI, PI | 72 |
BHAC | Fluorimeter | 96 nM for CEI | TDI, IPDI, HDI, MDI, PI, CEI | 73 |
BVN | Fluorimeter | 56 nM | EI | 74 |
Following the same path, C. Sango et al.59 developed an improved HPLC method with 9-(N-methylaminomethyl)-anthracene (MAMA) as a fluorescent and UV detection reagent for the detection and estimation of isocyanates. The MAMA-based urea derivative exhibits fluorescence as well as strong UV-absorption with high molar absorptivity at 254 nm. The sensitivity of this method was found to be ten to twenty-fold better than that of previously reported NNNP.55 By using MAMA, four different isocyanates 2,4-TDI, 2,6-TDI, HDI, and MDI were separated by both fluorescent and UV detectors with a detection limit of 1 × 10−4 mg m−3 in a 15 liter air sample.59 The total reactive isocyanate group (TRIG) is the total concentration of the isocyanate group, regardless of the molecule (monomer or oligomer or prepolymer) to which the isocyanate group is attached. TRIG was also evaluated by using MAMA for a series of 11 model isocyanate compounds including aliphatic, aromatic, mono-, and polyisocyanates. Derivatized products of these isocyanates were estimated by using reversed-phase HPLC with different detection modes i.e., fluorescence with λex-245 nm and λem-414 nm and UV absorbance at 245 and 370 nm. All these detection modes showed statistically significant differences for isocyanates when examined by the analysis of the variance and response factor. Here, the response factor is taken as the ratio between the integrated peak area and corresponding concentration. Fluorescence detection exhibits a higher response factor than UV detection at 245 nm and 370 nm.60
Rando et al. continued the work further to determine the airborne total reactive isocyanate group (TRIG), which is essential to protect the working atmosphere by proper quantification of isocyanate leaching during polyurethane formation.61 It was demonstrated that the MAMA reagent was successfully able to quantify TRIG using reverse-phase HPLC with fluorescence and UV detection modes in the products of polyurethane and oligomer precursors such as Lupranate M20S (40% MDI monomer & 60% MDI oligomer), CMDI (58–68% MDI monomer & remaining MDI oligomer), poly[methylene (polyphenyl isocyanate)] (PMPPI-oligomeric form of MDI), Desmodur N100 (HDI homopolymer, HDI-BT & 1.6% HDI), Imron paint activator192S (33% HDI oligomer) and Rexthane (TDI monomer and prepolymer). TRIG estimation was successfully achieved by using MAMA in all six different oligomers or prepolymer precursors using a UV response ratio of λ-245/370 nm and quantitative recoveries have been observed in comparison with a reference titrimetric procedure. However, one of the disadvantages of this technique is the presence of phosgene, which causes significant positive interference in the determination of TRIG using the MAMA reagent since phosgene also reacts readily with MAMA.61
Wu et al.62 investigated tryptamine 3-(2-aminoethyl) indole (TRYP) as the derivatizing agent for isocyanate determination with fluorescence (λex = 275 nm and λem = 320 nm) and amperometry detectors. Both fluorescence and amperometric oxidation of tryptamine are induced by the conjugated π-system of the indolyl moiety, which is located two carbon atoms away from the derivatising site of the amino group. Hence, the p-orbital (or orbitals) of isocyanates after derivatisation would not overlap with the indolyl π-system and hence the electronic structure of the π-system is not perturbed and hence the quantum efficiency of TRYP remains unchanged. The tryptamine derivatizing agent was specifically used to determine methyl isocyanate (MI) and the derivatized product (TRYP-MI) was characterized by 1H-NMR, which indicates the presence of a signature doublet peak of –CH3 at 2.8–3.3 ppm. Amperometry measurements of TRYP-MI in comparison with the existing 1-(2-methoxyphenyl) piperazine (MPP-MI) yield almost comparable results.63 However, LC based fluorescence detection of TRYP-MI was 30 times more sensitive than that of MPP-MI and found to detect less than 1 ng of TRYP-MI. Further, a stability study indicates no apparent loss of TRYP observed even after 35 days under the experimental conditions.62 As a continuation of previous work, Wu et al.64 studied TRYP derivatization with TDI, MDI, HDI and PMPPI and characterized it by using IR spectra which exhibit an IR band at around 1610 cm−1, which represents characteristic carbonyl stretching of the urea functional group. All the derivatized products formed were quantified using fluorescence and amperometry techniques efficiently. Further Wu et al.65 also studied the competitive derivatization rate of TRYP with other amine-based derivatizing agents like N-methyltryptamine (NMTP), PP, MPP and NNNP. The results indicate that a much smaller amount of TRYP or MPP is required than that of NNNP to efficiently derivatize an equivalent amount of isocyanate, which is beneficial in the HPLC system if TRYP/MPP were to be used.
Salthammer et al.66 developed a versatile fluorescent reagent 1-(2-pyridyl)-piperazine (2PP) for the determination of isocyanates. Urea derivatives of 2PP exhibit a high molar absorption coefficient and fluorescence quantum yield of 0.14–0.21 at 20 °C and display a small variation of the solvatochromic effect on absorption and fluorescence spectra. The effects of heat and light on the spectroscopic properties of these products were also studied. It is observed that these derivatives are stable in methanolic solution for more than 200 hours under dark conditions but found to be highly sensitive to temperature. Specifically, MDI-2PP and HDI-2PP exhibit a decreased quantum yield of about 10% for the temperature rise from 20 °C to 30 °C. It was shown that the absorption of 2,6-TDI-2PP is slightly blue-shifted in non-polar n-hexane and fluorescence spectra show a slight bathochromic shift because of the increased solvent polarity. This effect is stronger for only 2PP (356 nm-n-hexane; 382 nm-acetonitrile) but less pronounced for the urea derivative 2,6-TDI-2PP (355 nm-n-hexane; 369 nm-acetonitrile). Also, 2PP urea derivatives were compared with derivatives with similar structured 2-pyridinamine for variation in solvent polarity. The addition of a small amount of ethanol to 2-pyridinamine in isooctane results in notable variation in the shape and intensity of spectra due to hydrogen bond formation, and such an effect is not observed in 2PP due to the steric hindrance originating from the piperazine ring.66
A novel fluorescent derivatizing agent, 1-(9-anthracenylmethyl) piperazine (MAP) was synthesized by Streicher et al.67 to detect and estimate non-monomeric isocyanates. The effectiveness of MAP towards isocyanate derivatization was studied and compared with that of existing three different fluorescent agents MPP, MAMA and TRYP. The relative reactivity of phenyl isocyanate with MAP and MPP is almost comparable since the reactive piperazine group remains the same. It was observed that MAP reacts 4 times and 3.3 times faster than TRYP and MAMA, respectively. It was also reported that the fluorescence intensity of the derivatives of mono-isocyanates (BI and PI) of MAP and MAMA was higher than that of the derivatives of di-isocyanates (HDI, TDI, and MDI). This may be due to the intramolecular quenching in the diisocyanate ureas of MAP and MAMA. However, such an inference was not observed in the case of TRYP urea. The urea derivatives of MPP and MAP with five different isocyanates are subsequently analysed by HPLC with UV and EC detection. The average UV response of MAP urea was 4.8 times greater than that of MPP urea, but the EC response was slightly less than that of MPP urea. The replacement of the secondary amine group present in MAMA with piperazine results in MAP, which is highly reactive and more sensitive than MAMA towards isocyanates.67
Wang et al.68 described a new strategy for fluorometric determination of methyl isocyanate (MI) in air, which involves the degradation of MI to corresponding methylamine. Methylamine thus obtained reacts with acetylacetone and formaldehyde at a pH of 5.6 (sodium acetate buffer solution) to form a fluorescent compound, N-methyl-2,6-dimethyl-3,5-diacetyl-1,4-dihydropyridine. A fluorescence study was carried out at λex-404 nm and λem-474 nm. The effect of pH over the formation of a fluorescent compound was studied by varying pH from 2 to 10. It is observed that the fluorescence intensity was found to be maximum at λem-474 nm at pH 5–6 and low at pH 2–4. Also, a heating time of ∼16 min was found to be optimum to get maximum fluorescence intensity. However, heating beyond 16 min causes degradation of the compound, while a low heating time results in low fluorescence intensity as the time is not sufficient for the reaction to yield the fluorescence compound. The presence of foreign ions (Na+, K+, Mg2+, Ca2+, Cu2+, Ni2+, F−, Cl−, Br− and NO3−) was studied and found that foreign ions significantly cause positive interference in the determination of MI.68 Though this technique is highly sensitive, it is not further explored for the study of different isocyanates, since the formation of fluorescent compounds highly depends on pH, temperature, and foreign ions.
Roh et al.69 synthesized 9-anthracenylmethyl 1-piperazinecarboxylate (PAC) and developed a technique for the quantification of non-monomeric isocyanates with a single analyte peak in HPLC, which can overcome various limitations of traditional methods. In this technique, isocyanate species were derivatized with 9-anthracenylmethyl 1-piperazinecarboxylate (PAC) and subjected to a cleavage reaction with sodium thiomethoxide. The cleavage product 9-anthracenylmethyl methyl sulfide (AMMS) was estimated by HPLC as a single analyte peak. Using this strategy, all non-monomeric isocyanates are converted to a single analyte and the problem of variable response factors using different species is thus prevented. Hence by using this technique, the authors successfully separated a single AMMS analyte peak in HPLC and proposed a technique for the quantification of the total isocyanate group in polymeric isocyanates also. PAC was efficiently used to derivatize BI, PI, HDI, TDI, and MDI followed by a cleavage reaction and a single analyte peak as well as urea derivatives of PAC were separated by HPLC using a fluorescence/UV detector. This technique can also be applicable for the estimation of the surface bound free isocyanate group in the polyurethane. The relative kinetics of the reaction of phenyl isocyanate with PAC and MAP were studied and it was found that PAC is less reactive than MAP with a relative rate factor of 12.6 for MAP/PAC. The PAC usage was limited because the cleavage product of AMMS is not exactly specific for isocyanate-PAC derivatives,69 since AMMS can also be originated from the degradation of PAC or reaction product of PAC with solvent impurities.
Vogel et al.70,71 described a versatile method for the determination of mono- and di-isocyanates in air samples with UV-visible and fluorescence detection with a new reagent 4-nitro-7-piperazino-2,1,3-benzoxadiazole (NBDPZ). The urea derivatives of NBDPZ were separated by employing reverse phase HPLC and exhibited the red-shifted absorption maximum in UV and fluorescence detectors (UV/Vis – λmax-480 nm; fluorescence-λex-470 nm and λem-535 nm). NBDPZ displays increased selectivity compared with MAMA and MPP. The rate of reaction of NBDPZ with 2,6-TDI was found to be ≈ 3 times faster than that of MAMA-2,6-TDI. Also, the determination of isocyanates in the gas phase using impinge sampling methods with NBDPZ was performed and it was found that the aromatic isocyanate recoveries were in the range of 79–95%. On the other hand, aliphatic propyl isocyanate recovery was significantly lower because of the low reactivity towards NBDPZ compared to aromatic isocyanates. The LOD of MDI using NBDPZ in fluorescence detection mode was found to be 5–9 nmol L−1 for the individual isocyanate derivatives.70 Further, NBDPZ coated octadecyl modified silica (ODS)-filled glass tubes were used for the estimation of isocyanates and found that the 2,4-TDI recovery was in the range of 86–99%.70 To investigate the practical application of the NBDPZ test tube method for the determination of isocyanates, leaching resulting from polyurethane foams (PUF) based on MDI was studied. The non-heated PUF results in no MDI emission, whereas the thermally treated samples revealed a significant release of residual monomeric MDI. Despite numerous advantages and the applicability of NBDPZ for isocyanate detection, the stability of NBDPZ in the solution is very low. NBDPZ in solution under refrigerated conditions over two weeks exhibits a decreased peak area from 100% to 80% of its initial value. Further, the peak area is found to be decreased down to 41% at room temperature in the dark and 27% at RT under daylight. However, storage of the solid in the refrigerator yielded no degradation of NBDPZ for six months.70
Werlich et al.72 developed a technique with a newly synthesized derivatizing reagent 4-methoxy-6-(4-methoxy-1-naphthyl)-1,3,5-triazine-2-(1-piperazine) (MMNTP) for isocyanate determination. MMNTP was successfully used to derivatize five different isocyanates (PI, HDI, 2,4-TDI, 2,6-TDI, and MDI) and all five isocyanates separated by the HPLC method using UV (λmax-325 nm) and fluorescence detection mode (λex-325 nm and λem-405 nm). The MMNTP reacts faster with aromatic isocyanates, but aliphatic isocyanates require a minimum of 2 h incubation. Also, Werlich et al. demonstrated that the MMNTP reagent is found to have good spectroscopic properties with low detection levels in the range of pmol for both UV and fluorescence detection.72 The MMNTP reagent was used for an air sampling system for the real sample DESMODUR T80. The technique involves a glass tube filled with MMNTP coated chromosorb as a backup and a sampling layer with a pump flow of 1 L min−1. Using this technique, the analyte peaks are efficiently separated in the sampling layer along with additional peaks, which originate from the impurities of diisocyanates of the technical mixture.72
PTR-MS | Proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry |
HPLC | High-performance liquid chromatography |
MDI | Methylene bis(phenyl isocyanate) |
TDI | Toluene diisocyanate |
HDI | Hexamethylene diisocyanate |
NDI | Naphthalene diisocyanate |
HMDI | Methylene bis-cyclohexyl isocyanate |
IPDI | Isophorone diisocyanate |
HTPB | Lydroxyl terminated polybutadiene |
MI | Methyl isocyanate |
NIOSH | National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health |
OSHA | Occupational Safety and Health Administration |
ACGIH | American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists |
OELs | Occupational exposure limits |
TWA | Time-weighted average |
TRIG | Total reactive isocyanate group |
CZE | Capillary zone electrophoresis |
NNNP | N-(4-Nitrobenzyl)-N-propylamine |
2PP | 1-(2-Pyridyl) piperazine |
NMA | 1-Naphthalenemethylamine |
HDI-BT | Hexamethylene diisocyanate-biuret trimer |
MNMA | N-Methyl-1-naphthalenemethylamine |
MAMA | 9-(N-Methy1aminomethyl)-anthracene |
TRYP | 3-(2-Aminoethyl) indole |
PMPPI | Poly[methylene(polyphenyl isocyanate)] |
MPP | 1-(2-Methoxyphenyl) piperazine |
MAP | 1-(9-Anthracenylmethyl) piperazine |
BI | Benzyl isocyanate |
PI | Phenyl isocyanate |
PAC | 9-Anthracenylmethyl 1-piperazinecarboxylate |
AMMS | 9-Anthracenylmethyl methyl sulfide |
NBDPZ | 4-Nitro-7-piperazino-2,1,3-benzoxadiazole |
ODS | Octadecyl modified silica |
PUF | Polyurethanes |
MMNTP | 4-Methoxy-6-(4-methoxy-1-naphthyl)-1,3,5-triazine-2-(1-piperazine) |
BHAC | N-(n-butyl)-6-hydroxy-anthracene carboxamide |
BVN | N-Buty-4-(4-vinyl phenol)-1,8-naphthalimide |
ICT | Intramolecular charge transfer |
FMO | Frontier molecular orbital |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |