Alan A.
Wiles‡
a,
Jochen
Bruckbauer‡
b,
Nabeel
Mohammed‡
ac,
Michele
Cariello
a,
Joseph
Cameron
a,
Neil J.
Findlay
a,
Elaine
Taylor-Shaw
b,
David J.
Wallis
de,
Robert W.
Martin
*b,
Peter J.
Skabara
*a and
Graeme
Cooke
*a
aWestCHEM, School of Chemistry, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, G12 8QQ, UK. E-mail: peter.skabara@glasgow.ac.uk; graeme.cooke@glasgow.ac.uk
bDepartment of Physics, SUPA, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, G4 0NG, UK. E-mail: r.w.martin@strath.ac.uk
cDepartment of Chemistry, College of Science, Kirkuk University, Kirkuk, Iraq
dDepartment of Materials and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, CB3 0FS, UK
eCentre for High Frequency Engineering, University of Cardiff, Cardiff, CF24 3AA, UK
First published on 6th February 2020
The development of organic down-converting materials continues to attract attention in hybrid LED technology by obviating the need for non-sustainable rare-earth elements. In this work, a benzodiimidazole-based system (TPA-BDI) has been employed as a down-converting layer in a hybrid organic–inorganic LED device. A commercially available poly(urethane)-based resin is used as the encapsulating material, providing a dilute layer of TPA-BDI that is deposited on top of the GaN-based LED. Crucially, the solution-state emissive performance is generally maintained when encapsulated at low concentrations within this resin. A maximum luminous efficacy of 87 lm W−1 was demonstrated using a 1.0 mg ml−1 concentration of TPA-BDI in the resin. The suitability of using organic down-converters to produce green light from hybrid devices was demonstrated by the excellent repeatability of the device characteristics across a series of encapsulated LEDs.
These examples predominantly highlight the effectiveness of hybrid approaches to achieving desirable white light emission. In LEDs, device performance is compromised if there is a lack of green light output, which is the wavelength region of the visible spectrum for which the human eye is most sensitive, resulting in a lower than desired luminous efficacy and unsatisfactory output for the consumer. Therefore, efficient green light sources are highly desirable to optimise overall device performance and consumer experience. Arguably the most common method of producing green light-emitting OLEDs is through the use of phosphorescent heavy metal atom-containing complexes as dopants within a guest matrix. The metal induces a strong spin–orbit coupling effect and enhances the emission efficiency by allowing emission from the triplet state, but these complexes require expensive and rare metals such as iridium.14 Alternatively, inorganic green LEDs can be fabricated using two semiconductor material systems, namely III-phosphides and III-nitrides. However, compared with their blue and red counterparts, the device efficiency of inorganic LEDs in the green spectral region is greatly reduced. This problem is referred to as the ‘green gap’ and much effort has been focussed towards advancing III-nitride LEDs in order to realise efficient green inorganic LEDs.15 An alternative approach is built on the commonly-used method employed for generating white LEDs, where a highly-efficient blue GaN-based inorganic LED is combined with a yellow emitting phosphor.
Herein, we discuss our efforts towards realising a molecular approach to enable green light emission from hybrid organic/inorganic materials by employing an efficient GaN-based inorganic LED with a layer of green-emitting organic material encapsulated within a commercially available optically transparent poly(urethane) resin. Optically transparent poly(urethane) resins are ubiquitous to LED applications, due to their excellent optical and mechanical properties and have largely been used as encapsulants. They also benefit from well-established, large scale manufacturing techniques. Small molecules with a precise structure can offer advantages over polymeric semiconductor analogues, which can suffer from batch-to-batch variability and difficulties in achieving high purity.16 These advantages include complete reproducibility of synthesis and fine-tuning of properties for custom compatibility towards specific applications.17–19 Here we have synthesised the molecular species TPA-BDI (Scheme 1), which is a novel benzodiimidazole-cored organic system that can be prepared in just four steps from commercially available starting materials. Benzodiimidazoles and their derivatives have previously been reported as having tuneable optical properties by using push–pull donor–acceptor components and the potential to have medium to high photoluminescence quantum yields.20–23 The application of TPA-BDI in down-converting hybrid LED devices is investigated by its incorporation into an optically transparent poly(urethane) resin as host and encapsulant.
The absorbance and fluorescence of TPA-BDI were analysed in the solution state (Fig. 1a) and in the hardened resin (Fig. 1b). In dichloromethane solutions, TPA-BDI shows an absorption maximum at 422 nm (ε = 132810 l mol−1 cm−1) and an emission maximum at 479 nm and a shoulder at 506 nm (Fig. 1a).
Absorption spectra of the hardened films are essentially identical with a very small red-shift in the absorbance maximum to 426 nm (vs. 422 nm in solution), and only the addition of a band at 344 nm which can be attributed to the resin (Fig. S1a, ESI†). Higher concentrations showed a small red-shift in the onset of absorbance (480 nm to 500 nm), consistent with aggregation effects. However, the spectra were highly saturated in concentrations above 0.5 mg ml−1 due to instrument limitations (Fig. S1a, ESI†). Fluorescence spectroscopy of TPA-BDI was carried out at varying concentrations of the encapsulated hardened films (Fig. 1b). For clarity, only emission at 0.5 mg ml−1, 1 mg ml−1, 5 mg ml−1 and 20 mg ml−1 are shown. We can see that the emission spectrum of TPA-BDI is only slightly red-shifted at low concentrations when compared with the solution-state spectrum with a maximum at 484 nm (vs. 479 nm in solution), again consistent with a small aggregation effect in the hardened resin. The spectral shape of the emission spectra is essentially retained at low concentrations (up to 5 mg ml−1). However, with increasing concentration, the emission is broadened and red-shifted and the spectral shape changes in line with increasing levels of aggregation with a significant increase in contribution from the low-energy shoulder peak at 506 nm. Additionally, the photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY) of TPA-BDI in dichloromethane (1 × 10−4 M) was found to be 55%, and 49% and 44% in the hardened resin (1 mg ml−1 and 5 mg ml−1, respectively). Overall, the emission characteristics of TPA-BDI at low concentrations in the resin (0.5 mg ml−1 up to 5 mg ml−1), are similar to the solution-state measurements. An increase in concentration of TPA-BDI in the resin clearly leads to aggregation-induced quenching of emission.
Fig. 2a shows the absolute, response-corrected electroluminescence (EL) spectra of the LEDs with different concentrations of TPA-BDI operated under a constant forward current of 25 mA. As a reference the spectrum of the bare blue LED without the converter is also shown. Whilst the blue peak associated with transmitted, not absorbed, light from the blue LED is dominant for the lowest concentration of 0.5 mg ml−1, more of the light is absorbed and re-emitted in the green spectral range of 480–600 nm for the higher concentrations. The green emission maximum is around 510 nm. Even at 1 mg ml−1 almost all the light from the blue LED is absorbed by the organic molecule. The intensity of the green emission peak decreases with increasing concentration and also exhibits a slight change in spectral shape. Both can be attributed to quenching of the luminescence due to increased aggregation at higher concentrations.
The chromaticity coordinates in the CIE 1931 diagram for the LEDs featuring different concentrations of TPA-BDI are displayed in Fig. 2b. Increasing the concentration shifts the chromaticity coordinates steadily from the blue region (bottom left corner) towards the green region. The obvious deviation from a straight line observed when using the highest concentration (5.0 mg ml−1) is due to the change in spectral shape of the emission of the hybrid device. This addition of red in the emission spectrum shifts the chromaticity coordinate to the right (pure red is located in the right corner in the diagram).
To quantify the conversion process, the luminous efficacy and the radiant flux are determined from the absolute EL spectra. The luminous efficacy is the ratio of the luminous flux and the electrical input power of the LED measured in lm W−1. It describes the efficiency of converting electrical power into light taking the human eye response into account and is commonly used to describe white LEDs.13,24 The radiant flux is the total optical power measured in W, whereas the luminous flux is the perceived optical power in lm (lumens) taking the eye response into account. The luminous efficacy values for the LED using different concentrations of TPA-BDI can be found in Table 1. The increase in luminous efficacy between the two LEDs with the lowest concentrations (0.5 and 1.0 mg ml−1), relates to the increased contribution in the green spectral range despite the reduced blue emission. As the green emission peak decreases with increasing concentrations this concomitantly causes a drop in the luminous efficacy. Although the luminous efficacy is generally used to measure the performance of white LEDs, it is not the best measure for green LED performance. Therefore, the radiant flux is used for describing the efficiency of the colour conversion. Table 1 also shows the radiant flux of the blue LEDs before they were coated with the organic material as well as the radiant flux of the same LEDs measured after applying the colour converter. From these measurements, the loss in radiant flux is calculated as listed in Table 1. The radiant flux is decreasing with increasing concentration since the intensity of both emission peaks decreases with increasing concentration. This is also reflected by the radiant flux loss. The best result is achieved for the green LED with a 1.0 mg ml−1 concentration. At this concentration 51% of the optical power (radiant flux) from the blue LED is converted into green emission; this is equivalent to a radiant flux loss of 49%. With increasing concentration, the intensity drops further and above 5.0 mg ml−1 the spectral shape starts to change as the emission of the down-converter becomes red-shifted.
Concentration (mg ml−1) | Luminous efficacy (lm W−1) | Radiant flux (mW) – hybrid LED (after) | Radiant flux (mW) – blue LED (before) | Radiant flux loss (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
0.5 | 60 | 25 | 33 | 24 |
1.0 | 87 | 17 | 33 | 49 |
2.5 | 64 | 12 | 31 | 63 |
5.0 | 39 | 6 | 33 | 81 |
This loss in intensity of the hybrid LED devices can be explained by several photophysical factors. First, reabsorption of the emitted photons could have some effect due to the small overlap of the absorption and emission peak of TPA-BDI. As previously mentioned, aggregation-induced quenching effects are also responsible for some of the loss in intensity particularly when increasing the concentration. Secondly, photo-induced absorption (PIA) is likely the largest contributor to this loss in intensity, as explained in a previous publication.13 The effect of PIA was tested by means of pulsing the applied current (2% duty cycle, 500 μs period) to the blue LED encapsulated with a 1 mg ml−1 of TPA-BDI in the resin. Compared with the continuous current measurement of the same device, the intensity of the emission peak is higher by a factor of about 1.5 as seen in Fig. 3. The radiant flux loss for this pulsed device is 38% compared with 60% when continuously driven. Here, the pulse regime allows for any triplet states to relax within the timescale of the pulse (500 μs) thereby inhibiting the constant population of triplet states which will affect the ability of the organic molecule to emit whilst under constant illumination. In other words, by pulsing the blue LED, less of the blue light is wasted in non-radiative processes, leading to an increase in radiant flux.
Degradation of the transparent encapsulant can be excluded since a similar measurement series was performed using the resin without the organic colour converter (see Fig. S5, ESI†), and showed no degradation of the encapsulant. Therefore, this points towards the degradation of the organic material encapsulated in the resin. Thermal degradation of the organic material is unlikely as it is thermally stable up to 477 °C and its glass transition temperature (Tg) is 262 °C (measured by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), Fig. S3, ESI†); both temperatures are well above the operating temperature of the blue LED.
The same LEDs were measured again after approximately 21 months in order to observe any change over time when the LEDs were not operated. Fig. S6a (ESI†) shows the last EL spectrum of the hybrid LED (1 mg ml−1) that had been subjected to 3000 minutes of constant irradiation and the same device after 21 months. Fig. S6b (ESI†), on the other hand, shows the initial EL spectrum of another device (1 mg ml−1 concentration) that had been operated only once for no more than 5 min, and then compared with the EL spectrum measured after 21 months using a continuous or pulsed current. As can be seen, the emission spectra of both devices do not change over time. This means that the initial degradation of the organic material is limited and that the material is efficiently protected by the encapsulant from the environment to avoid further degradation by oxygen and moisture. Therefore, degradation of the organic material is likely due to a more complex photodegradation process which will require further studies.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9qm00771g |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2020 |