Yaoqing
Feng
a,
Jia
Wei
a,
Lang
Qin
*a and
Yanlei
Yu
*ab
aDepartment of Materials Science, State Key Laboratory of Molecular Engineering of Polymers, Fudan University, 220 Handan Road, Shanghai, 200433, China. E-mail: ylyu@fudan.edu.cn; qinlang@fudan.edu.cn
bYiwu Research Institute of Fudan University, Chengbei Road, Yiwu City, Zhejiang 322000, P. R. China
First published on 29th December 2022
Photodeformable liquid crystal polymers (LCPs) exhibit shape changes of different modes like bending, twisting, and oscillation, which depend on the orientation of liquid crystals. However, it is challenging to create a three-dimensional (3D) actuator with distinct actuation modes due to the difficulty of local orientation in a complex bulk architecture. Here we propose a strategy based on athermal photo-welding to integrate different orientations into a single flexible actuator by the photofluidization of azobenzene-containing linear LCPs. Stretch-induced uniaxial films are cut in different directions and subsequently welded via local photofluidization, during which the LCP transitions from a high-modulus glassy state to a rubbery state upon photoisomerization of azobenzene at room temperature. As a consequence, a cucumber vine-like structure with the opposite handedness and a lifting gripper are constructed by such a cut-and-weld process, demonstrating diverse deformation modes of winding, unwinding, and curling. This strategy provides an athermal process for the fabrication of seamless 3D flexible actuators without structural defects, which have potential applications in micromechanical systems, soft robotics, and artificial muscles.
Recently, welding processes have been considered to be a viable solution to build flexible 3D actuators with diverse LC orientations through chemical bonding,25–27 including secondary polymerization,28,29 as well as network reconstruction based on dynamic bonds.30–34 Secondary polymerization for further crosslinking can be triggered by light or heat to realize defect-free welding of two LCP films with redundant reactive groups or crosslinkers. Ji and Wei et al. created seamless multi-component 3D LCP robots by means of thermal secondary polymerization of reactive acrylate groups in preformed acrylate group-rich LCP films, simultaneously realizing the welding of LCP films and uniaxial orientation of mesogens.29 However, the polymer network will be completely fixed once the reactive group is depleted, and excessive cross-linking reactions may damage the mechanical properties of LCPs.26 Recently, dynamic covalent bonds such as dynamic ester, dynamic boroxines, and diselenide bonds have been applied to prepare assembled LCP actuators, depending on the rearrangement of dynamic networks between two films. Yang et al. synthesized monodomain LCP films with exchangeable disulfide bonds through in situ photopolymerizations in antiparallel surface-rubbed cells, cut the obtained uniaxial-aligned LCP films into pieces and pasted them together via dynamic disulfide exchange to form versatile shaped soft actuators.31 However, the breaking and reforming procedure of dynamic covalent bonds usually requires a high temperature or the assistance of other reagents, which may disrupt the originally designed LC orientations, or lead to the poor performance of actuators with the residues of auxiliary reagents.33 Therefore, an alternative technique for athermal welding is urgently needed to assemble LCPs with different orientations into a 3D actuator.
Photofluidization is an athermal photo-welding method based on photoisomerization reactions, which are induced by photoresponsive groups such as azobenzene.35–37 Azobenzene-containing polymers (azopolymers) exhibit photoinduced reversible solid-to-liquid transitions due to the photoswitchable glass transition temperature (Tg), which have been utilized for the welding of polymers.38,39 Under UV irradiation, the Tg of the azopolymer decreases lower than room temperature, while the polymer transitions from a glassy state to a rubbery state or even a viscous state without heating. By welding the fluidized polymers via surface fusion and the entanglement of molecular chains, LCPs with diverse LC orientations are integrated to create 3D actuators.
Here, the azobenzene-containing linear LCPs are assembled into 3D complex actuators with different LC orientations by photofluidization (Fig. 1a), which has been comprehensively investigated in the perspective of chemical structures. Ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) is employed to synthesize a series of LCPs with different side chain mesogens. Photo-welded bilayer films are fabricated via a photofluidization process, in which molecular chains of two fluidized films entangle and the surface fuses together with pressure. Taking advantage of this cut-and-weld process, a cucumber vine-like structure with opposite handedness is produced using a photo-welded LCP ribbon with different orientations upon UV irradiation (Fig. 1b). In addition, a light-controlled lifting gripper is fabricated with LCP ribbons of different orientations, and it reveals individual motion to execute diverse functions. We anticipate that photo-welding can become a facile process to obtain complex bulk architectures of LCPs, thus providing far-reaching possibilities for soft microdevices with advanced functionalities.
The polymerization of P1 was performed using standard Schlenk techniques under a nitrogen atmosphere. The azobenzene monomer (1.354 g, 2 mmol) and cyclooctene monomer (0.132 g, 1.2 mmol) were added into a Schlenk flask. Then, the 3 μmol second-generation Grubbs catalyst with 3 mL anhydrous dichloromethane was added to the mixture. After stirring for 1 h at 50 °C, a yellow solid polymer was precipitated from methanol. (1.332 g, 91%). P2 and P3 were synthesized according to the published works,40,41 and the yields were 94% and 90%, respectively. All the results of 1H NMR are shown in the ESI† (Fig. S1–S3).
The photo-welded bilayer films were fabricated using the photofluidization, in which the films (thickness: 20 μm) were exposed to UV light (365 nm, 100 mW cm−2) for 2 min. Then, the fluidized films were overlapped with each other, pressed with a 200 g weight for 5 min, and finally cured by irradiation with visible light (530 nm, 60 mW cm−2) for about 2 min. The cross-sectional SEM images of photo-welded films were investigated using a field-emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM, Zeiss, Ultra 55). All cross-sectional samples were fractured after dipping into liquid nitrogen. The elastic moduli of drop-cast films and photo-welded films were measured with a tensile machine (Instron, Series 5943) at a loading rate of 20 mm min−1 at ambient temperature and each test was repeated at least 6 times to allow for statistical analysis. The samples were of the same size (20 mm × 3 mm × 20 μm), and the photo-welded area of all LCP films has the same size (3 mm × 3 mm).
Upon UV irradiation, the trans LCPs isomerized to the cis state with a high trans–cis photoconversion efficiency (>96%), which was investigated using the UV-Vis spectra (Fig. S5 and S6, ESI†). Therefore, cis LCPs were prepared according to the published work.38 The Tg of the LCPs at trans and cis states was measured by the DSC measurement. The DSC heating curves show a near-room-temperature Tg of the trans LCPs and a subzero Tg of the cis LCPs, indicating that the cis LCPs are in a rubbery state or a viscous flow state (Fig. 2b). The viscosity measured using the rotational rheometer increases rapidly when the frequency is lower than 1 Hz, indicating that the cis P1 is in the rubbery state rather than the viscous flow state (Fig. S7, ESI†). Similarly, both cis P2 and cis P3 are in the rubbery state. The Tg of cis P1 is the lowest, which may result from the low density of side chains. On the other hand, the non-responsive mesogens of cis P2 and cis P3 restrict the motility of chain segments to some extent. In addition, two small endothermic peaks emerge between the Tg (30 °C) and the clearing temperature (78 °C) in the DSC heating curve of trans P1, indicating the transition temperature of the smectic phase accompanied by the degree of decline of the order.
We performed nanoindentation measurements and quantitative nanoscale mechanical characterization by AFM on the drop-cast LCP films (thickness: 20 μm) to study the influence of photofluidization on the mechanical properties of the surface (Fig. 2c). The loading–pause–unloading displacement curves show that upon trans–cis isomerization induced by UV light, the hard surface of the LCP films gradually transfers to a soft state, leading to a significantly increased penetration depth and an obvious creep phenomenon (Fig. 2d). This variation is attributed to the fact that the surface is in the rubbery state possessing Tg below room temperature. In addition, the unloading curves reveal that compared to cis P2 and cis P3 that undergo an elastic–plastic deformation, cis P1 exhibits a typical plastic deformation, resulting from the lower density of side chains and a larger free volume. As summarized in Table 1, the hardness of all the LCP films decreases by one order of magnitude after UV irradiation. P1 exhibited the largest change of 96%, indicating the best photofluidization effect.
LCP films | Surface hardness (MPa) | Surface adhesion (nN) | |
---|---|---|---|
P1 | trans | 67.7 ± 2.6 | 14.8 ± 2.3 |
cis | 2.5 ± 0.3 | 294.6 ± 4.7 | |
P2 | trans | 57.7 ± 3.3 | 22.2 ± 3.8 |
cis | 4.1 ± 0.4 | 27.0 ± 1.9 | |
P3 | trans | 22.1 ± 1.4 | 36.8 ± 1.6 |
cis | 2.7 ± 0.5 | 181.7 ± 3.6 |
The retract force-separation curves of all the trans LCP films show a tiny action distance (<10 nm) between the tip and the surface with a negligible adhesion force (<50 nN) (Fig. 2e). After UV irradiation, the surface adhesion force of cis P1 and cis P3 is obviously increased, resulting from the increase of surface polarity based on the photoisomerization of the azobenzene groups (Table 1). In addition, due to the higher intermolecular force which stems from the lower density of side chains, cis P1 exhibits a higher adhesion force and a larger action distance than cis P3. Compared to cis P1 and cis P3, the lowest adhesion force of cis P2 may stem from the biphenyl mesogens in the side chains. The strong π–π stacking leads to the poor mobility of molecular segments and the symmetric chemical structure causes the low surface polarity, both of which result in the low surface adhesion. In summary, the aforementioned experimental results illustrate that P1 film has the lowest hardness and the largest adhesion force upon UV light irradiation, indicating the best photofluidization effect.
We introduced the rhodamine dye in the LCP films to observe the diffusion in the photo-welded films. The rhodamine-containing LCP films were fabricated by the drop-casting method and photo-welded with the original films under pressure (200 g). The obtained bilayer films were fractured after dipping into liquid nitrogen, and the cross-sectional color was observed using a microscope (Fig. S8, ESI†). The microscopic images show a clear color gradation region at the center of the bilayer P1 and P3 films, which reveals that the UV-irradiated surface of two films diffuses together due to pressure. The experiment proves the existence of the fusion region, which results from the cross-diffusion of the fluidized surface. Taking advantage of the extraordinary photofluidization, the surface of P1 films transfers to a fluidized state with high adhesion force upon UV irradiation, which is beneficial to surface physical fusion between two films. The adequate entanglement of chain segments in the fusion area enhances the solidity and stability of photo-welding. However, in contrast to P1 and P3, the bilayer film of P2 has no color gradation region with a clear boundary and several gaps (Fig. 3b), indicating a poor photo-welding result.
It is worth noting that the photo-welding process is athermal, which is testified by the temperature variation of the P1 film recorded with an infrared thermography. The photographs illustrate that the temperature of the film increases by only 6 °C after UV irradiation (365 nm, 100 mW cm−2) for 2 min, and then decreases to room temperature within 1 min after the UV light is turned off (Fig. S9, ESI†). The photo-welded strip exhibits strong robustness bearing a weight of 150 g, which is ascribed to the high molecular weight and the excellent photo-welding effect (Fig. 3d).
To study the stability of the photo-welded films, the mechanical properties of the original drop-cast films and photo-welded films were measured using a tensile method, respectively (Fig. 3e and f). The low breaking elongation of the photo-welded P2 film illustrates the poor photo-welding result with a lower elastic modulus than that of the initial film. The stress–strain curves of photo-welded P1 and P3 films show an increased breaking elongation with a larger yield strain, indicating the great effect of photo-welding. The elastic moduli of photo-welded P1 and P3 films are slightly increased compared to those of the initial films, probably as a result of the twice thickness of the welded area. It should be noted that none of the stretched films fractured at the welded area (Movie S1, ESI†), which proved the stability and excellent mechanical properties of the welded region.
Although P3 films were seamlessly welded, the mechanical properties of P3 were not strong enough to build a free-standing functional actuator. Therefore, P1 is chosen as the optimum material for building photodeformation 3D actuators. An LCP windmill was produced via a photo-welding process in combination with the tailoring method, in which the welding region was precisely controlled by the light (Fig. 3g). The linear structure of the LCPs and none of the auxiliary adhesives allow for directly recycling the materials by solvent dissolution or melting.
The photoinduced bending behaviors of the stretched films were recorded by a super-resolution digital microscope, and at least five samples were experimented to ensure the reliability of the results (Fig. S11, Fig. 4a and Movie S2, ESI†). All the films exhibit bending behaviors away from the light upon UV illumination (365 nm, 30 mW cm−2) and return to the initial state upon exposure to visible light (530 nm, 30 mW cm−2). The bending angle of the films with the stretching of 300% is significantly larger than that of the films at 200%, while the bending angles of the films at 300% and 400% are similar, indicating that the mesogens are oriented completely when the film is stretched to a ratio of 300%. Hence, the following experiments were conducted using the films with a stretching ratio of 300%.
It is worth noting that azobenzene-containing LCP films with a planar uniaxial orientation generally exhibit bending toward the irradiation direction of the light since an anisotropic contraction is generated along the orientation direction upon UV irradiation.20 Interestingly, our stretched P1 films bent away from the UV light. To investigate the photodeformation mechanism, we performed 2D-WAXD characterization with the X-ray beam applied to the front and the side of the film (Fig. 4b and c). The diffraction spots of the two patterns are almost the same, and the azimuthal integration indicates that the tilting angle (φ) of the mesogens in the smectic C phase is 65° (Fig. S12, ESI†). Therefore, it can be inferred that the LC layers are distributed as a stacked umbrella-like structure, and the mesogens are all oriented along the stretching direction (Fig. 4d). The GIXRD diffraction patterns show that the LC layer structure in the surface of the film is nearly identical after UV (365 nm, 30 mW cm−2, 60 s) and visible light (530 nm, 30 mW cm−2, 60 s) illumination (Fig. S13, ESI†). Considering the special layer structure of LC alignment, we assume that such a photoinduced bending behavior originates from the anisotropic free volume expansion in the orientation direction of the illuminated surface, where the highly ordered smectic C phase with a densely packed structure requires more free volume for the photoisomerization of azobenzene groups.45 To verify the free volume expansion of the stretched P1 film under UV illumination, we measured the density of a free-standing film in the UV-illuminated and visible light-illuminated state (Fig. S14, ESI†). First, the stretched P1 film was immersed in the salt solution, whose density (1.0733 g cm−3) was a little bit lower than that of the film, and the film was sinking in the solution. Then the stretched P1 film behaved bending and floated in the solution upon UV illumination, which is ascribed to a decrease in the density of the film, indicating the free volume expansion caused by the photoisomerization of the azobenzene groups (Movie S3, ESI†). When exposed to visible light, the bending film returned to the initial plate state and sank to the bottom of the cuvette, as the density increased to the original state. Moreover, this density variation along with the shape change was reversible.
The P1 films stretched at a ratio of 300% exhibited photodeformation behaviors with a rapid response and excellent reversibility under alternative irradiation with UV (365 nm, 30 mW cm−2, 10 s) and visible light (530 nm, 30 mW cm−2, 10 s), which is ascribed to the physical cross-linking provided by the crystallization of the poly-cyclooctene chain segment (Fig. 4e and Fig. S15, ESI†). Importantly, both the photodeformation and photofluidization depend on the photoisomerization of the azobenzene groups, which can be separately controlled by manipulating the UV light intensity. When UV irradiation with high intensity (>70 mW cm−2) is applied, the P1 films become soft due to the photofluidization, because more azobenzene groups undergo photoisomerization. The photodeformation behaviors of the films are achieved with low light intensity to avoid softening, since the elastic modulus of the P1 films is nearly constant when the light intensity is lower than 50 mW cm−2 (Fig. S16, ESI†).
A gripper actuator was integrated by the stretched films with diverse deformation modes through the precise photo-welding process. Two ribbons of θ = 0° were photo-welded in the center and built into a “hand” (purple part in the schematic). A ribbon of θ = 45° acted as an “arm” (yellow part in the schematic) and was photo-welded with the “hand” to fabricate a lifting gripper (Fig. 5c, d and Movie S4, ESI†). The “hand” of the gripper grabbed and released the objects when the ribbons exhibited curling and straight states with the irradiation of UV and visible light. The “arm” of the gripper acted as a rise and fall controller by changing the degree of spiral deformation upon the irradiation of UV light and visible light. It is worth noting that all the above deformations can be performed quickly and reversibly with good repeatability. It is predictable that the photo-welding process based on photofluidization could have an excellent prospect for applications in the field of assembly of different materials with various deformation modes.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic routes of the monomers and liquid crystal polymers, liquid crystal orientation characterization, and photodeformation behaviour investigations of the liquid crystal polymer films. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sm01476a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |