George
Metreveli
a,
Bianca
Frombold
a,
Frank
Seitz
b,
Alexandra
Grün
c,
Allan
Philippe
a,
Ricki R.
Rosenfeldt
b,
Mirco
Bundschuh
bd,
Ralf
Schulz
b,
Werner
Manz
c and
Gabriele E.
Schaumann
*a
aGroup of Environmental and Soil Chemistry, Institute for Environmental Sciences, University of Koblenz-Landau, Fortstrasse 7, D-76829 Landau, Germany. E-mail: schaumann@uni-landau.de
bGroup of Ecotoxicology and Environment, Institute for Environmental Sciences, University of Koblenz-Landau, Fortstrasse 7, D-76829 Landau, Germany
cDepartment of Biology, Institute of Integrated Natural Sciences, University of Koblenz-Landau, Universitätsstrasse 1, D-56070 Koblenz, Germany
dDepartment of Aquatic Sciences and Assessment, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Lennart Hjelms väg 9, SWE-75007 Uppsala, Sweden
First published on 11th January 2016
Understanding of the interplay of generally known colloidal transformations under conditions of test media (TM) used during cultivation of organisms and biological effect (=ecotoxicological) studies is still limited, although this knowledge is required for an adequate interpretation of test outcomes and for a comparison among different studies. In this context, we investigated the aggregation and dissolution dynamics of citrate-stabilized silver nanoparticles (Ag NPs) by varying the composition of three TM (ASTM, SAM-5S, and R2A, used during bioassays with Daphnia magna, Gammarus fossarum, and bacterial biofilms, respectively) in the presence and absence of two types of natural organic matter (NOM), namely, Suwanee River humic acid (SRHA) and seaweed extract (SW). Each original test medium induced reaction-limited aggregation of Ag NPs, and aggregation increased from R2A to SAM-5S and ASTM. In addition to the differences in aggregation dynamics, the concentration and speciation of Ag(I) differed between the three TM, whereby SAM-5S and ASTM are comparable with respect to the nature of the aggregation process but clearly differ from the R2A medium. Furthermore, Cl−, mainly present in SAM-5S, induced NP stabilization. The release of silver ions from Ag NPs was controlled by the presence of NOM and organic constituents of TM and by interactions with Cl− and Br−. The degree of aggregation, formation of interparticle cation–NOM bridges or stabilization was larger for Ca2+ than for Mg2+ due to the stronger ability of Ca2+ to interact with citrate or NOM compared to Mg2+. These observations and the dependence of aggregation rates on the particle concentration renders the interpretation of dose–response relationships challenging, but they may open perspectives for targeted ecotoxicological testing by modifications of TM composition.
Nano impactEcotoxicological studies on engineered nanoparticles (NPs) are conducted involving different test media (TM), whose composition is adapted towards the needs of the respective species. This composition significantly influences the colloidal state and properties of NPs. In this work, the aggregation and dissolution dynamics of Ag NPs were characterized in three different TM by varying their composition. The dissolution of Ag NPs was controlled by surface protection by natural organic matter (NOM) and organic constituents of TM and by interactions with Cl− and Br−. In general, reaction-limited aggregation was observed. Aggregation depended predominantly on the Ca2+/Mg2+ ratio, anion composition and NOM quality. This knowledge will support the interpretation of and comparison among ecotoxicological studies that may have been performed under differing conditions. |
It is known that the typically high ionic strength in TM promotes the aggregation of silver,2–5 gold,6 titanium dioxide,1,7–9 zinc oxide,7,10 and cerium dioxide11 NPs. Also, general impacts of individual TM constituents and additives (e.g., halides,12–16 multivalent cations,17–20 suspended minerals,21 natural organic matter (NOM)21,22) on NP transformations are well known from lab studies in well-defined systems. Some studies specifically focused on the role of individual TM constituents or additives in complex systems: Nur et al.9 observed that titanium dioxide NPs aggregated according to the classical Derjaguin–Landau–Verwey–Overbeek (DLVO) theory despite the complex chemical composition of the test media. The critical coagulation concentration (CCC) of TM for titanium dioxide NPs as determined by diluting the TM varied between 18% and 54%,9 which indicates that aggregation of these NPs in the original (100%) TM is diffusion limited. The dilution of TM in order to obtain stable Ag NP dispersions was also applied in other studies and suggested that dilution by a factor of 10 would reduce aggregation sufficiently for the tests.2–4 Tejamaya et al.4 reported increased shape and dissolution changes for citrate-coated Ag NPs after replacement of Cl− by SO42− and NO3−. Horst et al.8 observed the stabilizing effect of humic acid (HA) on titanium dioxide NPs in TM. Besides these findings, it is still largely unknown which of the generally known fundamental colloidal processes dominate NP transformation in which TM, to which extent the NP status varies among TM, and which aggregation mechanisms are relevant under which conditions. This knowledge is of high importance as the type of aggregation mechanism will influence, among others, how strongly the NP status is governed by NP concentration and how the type of coating and the tendency for dissolution are expected to affect the ecotoxicological potential of NPs.
From systems containing a lower variety of constituents than most TM, it is known that besides the ionic strength, the type of cations and anions is important for the aggregation of NPs. Divalent cations show higher efficiency to induce aggregation than monovalent cations.17–20 Furthermore, aggregation of citrate-coated Ag NPs is more pronounced in the presence of Ca2+ compared to Mg2+, which may be explained by the higher ability of Ca2+ to form complexes with citrate.14,18 Thus, not only differences in the total concentration of divalent cations but also differences in the molar ratio of Ca2+ and Mg2+ in TM will result in different aggregation states and, thus, different ecotoxicological responses. Furthermore, TM composition differs with respect to the presence and absence of halide ions. Chloride, for example, may either enhance or suppress the aggregation of Ag NPs. Ag NP stabilization by the formation of negatively charged AgCl(s) precipitates on the NP surface was observed in several studies,4,12,13 whereas Baalousha et al.14 reported enhanced aggregation due to interparticle bridging by solid phase AgCl(s).
Even more complex is the role of organic substances in the TM. Depending on the needs of the target organisms, TM contain various organic substances (proteins, enzymes, vitamins, glucose and others) at variable concentrations. Their role for the NP transformation in TM still requires investigation. Furthermore, NOM is increasingly used as an NP-stabilizing additive to traditional TM.1,8 However, NOM can induce either stabilization or destabilization of NPs, depending on the solution chemistry and the type of NOM used.22 Especially, the interplay between bridging-determined aggregation, which is observed predominantly at a high concentration of multivalent cations,14,18,23–25 and electrosteric stabilization23,26,27 will depend strongly on the quality of the NOM and on the concentration as well as types of multivalent cations. As reported by Stankus et al.,24 Mg2+ induced the bridging-determined aggregation to a lower extent compared to Ca2+. As TM normally contain a mixture of salts and sometimes various NOM additives, it will be essential to understand the combined effects of NOM and all cations as well as their individual contributions to the transformation of NPs. Special emphasis has to be put on differences between Mg2+ and Ca2+ and between NOM types and their ability to interact with these multivalent cations. Moreover, the suggested impeding impact of NOM on the Ag NP dissolution28–30 seems to be highly relevant for ecotoxicological testing.31 However, to date, no study is available in which the TM composition was varied systematically in order to elucidate the underlying NP transformation mechanisms and identify dominating effects.
Furthermore, the concentration of NPs influences their transformations in TM. For high NP concentrations (from 50 to 500 mg L−1) as used in some ecotoxicological studies,7,8,10,11 aggregation is significantly accelerated.32–34 Thus, dose–response relationships7,35,36 may be further distorted by NP concentration-dependent dynamics in aggregation during the tests. Moreover, the concentration of NPs available for the organisms can be changed by sedimentation of aggregated NPs. This can additionally complicate the interpretation of ecotoxicological test results.37
On the example of silver nanoparticles (Ag NPs), which are widely used in consumer products, the central aim of this study was to elucidate how and to which extent individual TM constituents trigger specific NP transformations and which mechanisms are responsible for these processes. In particular, we tested the following hypotheses. i) Aggregation of Ag NPs in TM without NOM and other organic compounds is described by the classical DLVO theory and it is predominantly determined by the concentration of Ca2+. ii) The presence of halide ions or organic compounds in TM modifies the NP surface, but NP aggregation is still dominated by the concentration of Ca2+. iii) Under the conditions of different TM, the NOM generally suppresses aggregation via electrosteric stabilization and hinders Ag NP dissolution. iv) NP size does not alter the aggregation mechanism. v) For NOM that interact strongly with Ca2+, there is a threshold value of Ca2+ concentration above which electrosteric stabilization is overlaid by bridging-determined aggregation.
In order to evaluate these hypotheses, the aggregation dynamics of citrate-stabilized Ag NPs was investigated in three TM: ASTM, SAM-5S, and R2A used during bioassays with Daphnia magna, Gammarus fossarum, and bacteria, respectively. In order to obtain process-based understanding, we characterized the influence of NOM, the cations Ca2+ and Mg2+, and the anions Cl−, Br−, SO42−, and NO3− as well as the concentration of NPs on the aggregation of Ag NPs by systematic variation of the TM chemical composition. In order to understand the influence of the particle size on the NP transformations under TM conditions, we used NPs in two different sizes (i.e., 30 nm and 100 nm). Furthermore, the release of silver from Ag NPs was investigated in the presence as well as in the absence of NOM.
The TM were, if needed, amended with NOM as follows: Suwannee River HA (SRHA) standard II from the International Humic Substance Society (for the preparation method for SRHA stock solution, see the ESI‡) was used as the model NOM. Additionally, seaweed extract (SW; Marinure®) from Glenside was used in experiments with ASTM due to its frequent use in ecotoxicological testing.37,43,44 The total organic carbon (TOC) concentration was adjusted to 9.4 mg L−1 SRHA and 8.0 mg L−1 SW, corresponding to the total mass concentration of 20 mg L−1 for both NOM. Whereas SRHA contains carboxylic and phenolic functional groups, SW contains polysaccharides with hydroxyl, carboxylic, and amino functional groups;45 thus the two NOM are expected to have a different affinity to multivalent cations. Following the categorization of NOM into NOM of aquatic origin and of rather terrestrial origin,46 it may be postulated from their composition that SW is likely to resemble aquatic NOM, while SRHA rather resembles NOM of terrestrial origin, the latter due to its higher affinity to Ca2+.47
In order to measure the concentration of metals in R2A medium, potentially originating not only from Na-pyruvate but also from other individual organic compounds, the solutions of each individual organic compound were prepared at the same concentration as that used in R2A medium. Metal concentration was measured in unfiltered and with 3 kDa membrane (Amicon Ultra-15 centrifugal filter device, Merck Millipore) filtered solutions using an inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer (ICP-OES, 720, Agilent Technologies).
In order to elucidate the influence of vitamins on the aggregation of Ag NPs in TM, early-stage aggregation experiments were performed for 30 nm Ag NPs in the absence and presence of CaSO4 (0.7 mmol L−1) in modified ASTM medium, which contained vitamins at different concentrations (B1: 0.075, 0.5, 5 mg L−1; B7: 0.00075, 0.005, 0.05 mg L−1; B12: 0.001, 0.01, 0.1 mg L−1). To exclude the influence of Mg2+ on the aggregation, the modified ASTM medium did not contain Mg2+ ions. To investigate the role of inorganic anions in the aggregation of Ag NPs, early-stage aggregation experiments were done for 30 nm Ag NPs in deionized water and modified ASTM medium in the absence and presence of CaSO4 (for manufacturer and purity, see Table S1‡), CaCl2 (for manufacturer and purity, see Table S2‡), Ca(NO3)2·4H2O (≥99%, p.a., Carl Roth), or CaBr2 (99.5%, Alfa Aesar) at the same Ca2+ concentration (0.7 mmol L−1). The modified ASTM medium did not contain Mg2+ ions and vitamins to exclude their influence on the aggregation. In order to test the influence of monovalent cations on the aggregation of Ag NPs in R2A medium, early-stage aggregation experiments were performed in deionized water at the same divalent cation concentration as detected in R2A medium (0.03 mmol L−1 Ca2+ as Ca(NO3)2, Table S12‡) and at different NaNO3 (≥99%, p.a., Carl Roth) concentrations (0–60 mmol L−1). In order to elucidate the role of the individual organic constituents of R2A on the aggregation of Ag NPs (30 nm), early-stage aggregation experiments were done in Mg2+-free R2A medium in the absence and presence of individual organic constituents and their mixtures at the same concentrations as present in the medium. In addition, the influence of NP concentration on the aggregation pattern was investigated exemplarily in the NOM-free ASTM medium for particle concentration ranges of 0.1–10 mg L−1 (30 nm NP) and 1–10 mg L−1 (100 nm NP) as well as in Mg2+-free R2A medium for the particle concentration range of 0.5–10 mg L−1 (30 nm NP).
(1) |
The attachment efficiency, α, was calculated by normalizing the aggregation rate constant of interest to the aggregation rate constant obtained for the diffusion-limited aggregation regime (kfast):17,18
(2) |
As reported in the literature, the dissolution and ecotoxicological impact of Ag NPs is strongly affected by the Cl− concentration.15,16 Furthermore, the different conditions in the TM will lead to TM-dependent Ag speciation and therefore to potentially different impacts on the Ag NP status. Model calculations for equilibrium speciation of Ag(I) showed that for the Ag<2nm concentrations determined after one day in the supernatant, the solution was undersaturated regarding solid phase silver chloride AgCl(s) and silver bromide AgBr(s) (Table S10‡). While in ASTM and R2A most of the Ag was present as Ag+, aqueous silver chloride AgCl(aq) dominated in SAM-5S due to the highest Cl− concentration. The Ag<2nm concentrations measured after one day in the supernatant of ASTM (105.6 ± 0.4 μg L−1) and SAM-5S (11.2 ± 0.5 μg L−1) were close to saturation concentrations calculated for ASTM (169 μg L−1) regarding AgCl(s) and for SAM-5S (21 μg L−1) regarding AgBr(s) (Table S11‡). This indicates that during dissolution of Ag NPs a part of released Ag+ is likely transferred to AgCl(s) or AgBr(s), leading to the lower dissolved Ag concentration in SAM-5S compared to ASTM due to the lower solubility constant for AgBr(s).55,56 In addition, the formation of surface precipitates of AgCl(s) and AgBr(s) as discussed below can hinder further dissolution of Ag NPs.
The low release of silver in the R2A medium, in turn, is likely explainable due to proteins or protein fragments present in the medium, which can form protein corona on the Ag NP surface57,58 and hamper the diffusion and adsorption of oxidants as observed for citrate-coated Ag NPs in the presence of bovine serum albumin (BSA)59 and luciferase.57 Furthermore, the removal of potentially formed Ag+–protein complexes by centrifugation, which cannot be fully excluded under the used centrifugation conditions, can result in underestimation of Ag+ release. Interestingly, after 7 d of exposure time, the concentration of Ag<2nm decreased in ASTM (24.9 ± 2.2 μg L−1) and SAM-5S (7.1 ± 2.4 μg L−1) but not in R2A. This effect may be explained by the interplay of several processes like dissolution of the initial silver oxide layer, oxidation of the Ag NP surface, precipitation of AgCl(s), and re-sorption of released Ag+ onto NP surfaces. After complete dissolution of the initial Ag2O layer, the dissolution rate of Ag NP can be decreased since further dissolution is likely controlled by the oxidation reaction of the Ag NP surface.16 The simultaneous formation of AgCl(s) precipitates can lead to decreasing concentration of Ag<2nm in the solution. Furthermore, the re-sorption of released Ag+ onto the NP surface cannot be excluded,28,60 which can be mediated by complexation sites provided by the free terminal carboxylate group of the citrate coating.61 In contrast to ASTM and SAM-5S, no decrease in the concentration of Ag<2nm was observed in R2A after 7 d, which can be attributed to the absence of halide ions or to the above-mentioned protecting effect of sorbed proteins and their fragments.
The presence of NOM decreased Ag<2nm concentration in ASTM and SAM-5S. The decrease in ASTM was stronger for SW than for SRHA. The observed effect of NOM agrees well with the previously reported decrease in Ag+ release with increasing concentrations of HA and fulvic acid (FA).28 This effect can be explained by the physical protection of the Ag NP surface by adsorbed NOM28,29 or by reduction of Ag+ by NOM62,63 and suggests a stronger protection by SW than SRHA. The stronger protection effect of SW may be explained by higher sorption of more hydrophilic64 SW on the hydrophilic Ag NP surface compared to SRHA. In contrast, SRHA increased the Ag<2nm concentration in the R2A TM, which either suggests a weaker protection by NOM in this medium or a meaningfully larger active Ag NP surface60 than in the other media. The latter is supported by the smallest Ag NP sizes and complete stabilization found in R2A relative to ASTM and SAM-5S (Fig. 2). Thus, the dissolution of Ag NP in TM seems to be controlled by the interplay of protecting mechanisms reducing the reactivity of the Ag NP surface and the stabilizing effects of NOM increasing the specific surface area of the Ag NPs. The higher release of silver from Ag NPs in all media by a factor of up to 2–100 compared to the original NP dispersions (Fig. 1) underlines the relevance of this process during ecotoxicological tests, especially in the light of the substantial toxicity induced by Ag+.29 The interplay between protecting and dissolution-supporting effects of organic constituents of the TM as well as NOM additives needs, however, more attention to uncover the underlying chemical processes and mechanisms.
In the absence of NOM, Ag NP aggregation increased in the order R2A < SAM-5S < ASTM during the first day, whereas after seven days, Ag NP in SAM-5S showed a slightly higher hydrodynamic diameter than in ASTM. Nonetheless, these differences should be interpreted with care, since DLS analyses are biased in the presence of large aggregates. In ASTM and SAM-5S, the hydrodynamic diameter of both Ag NPs increased within the first day to 686–1025 nm and 460–1089 nm, respectively. In R2A the 30 nm NPs aggregated only within the first minutes to 65 nm and then remained nearly constant, whereas the aggregation of 100 nm Ag NPs was much slower and aggregate size increased slightly up to 185 nm within one day of exposure time (Fig. 2e and f and S2e and f‡). This effect can be explained again by the lower initial particle number concentration and lower collision probability of 100 nm Ag NPs compared to 30 nm Ag NPs.
Aggregation of Ag NPs was consistent with the colloidal stability that can be expected from the zeta potential, which was most negative in the R2A medium, although its absolute value was substantially reduced in all TM compared to deionized water (Fig. 2g and h). The latter is a direct consequence of electrical double layer compression at high ionic strength (>5 mmol L−1).50,51 Considering the respective ionic backgrounds in the different TM (Table S4‡) and the stability tendencies (Fig. 2), it is clear that additional processes are involved in the stabilization of Ag NPs. The medium R2A, which generated the most stable suspensions, contains among others the surfactant Tween 80. Tween 80 is known to readily adsorb onto the NP surface and stabilize NPs60 – a process potentially of high relevance for the present study. Furthermore, the stabilizing effect of the proteins65 which are also present in the R2A medium cannot be excluded.
NOM generally increased the stability of Ag NPs in all TM and at all points of time except for SRHA in ASTM in combination with 100 nm Ag NPs after 7 days (Fig. 2 and S2‡). These observations support the general expectation of electrosteric NP stabilization by NOM.32–34 For exposure times exceeding one day SW served more efficiently as a stabilizing agent relative to SRHA (Fig. 2a and b), while for shorter exposure times, the stabilization by SRHA was slightly stronger or similar to that of SW. This could be explained by the different adsorption kinetics of SRHA and SW to Ag NPs or different aggregation mechanisms, which are further outlined below. However, neither SRHA nor SW completely prevented the Ag NPs in ASTM and SAM-5S from aggregation as the hydrodynamic diameter continuously increased during the seven days (Fig. 2c and d). In contrast to this, the addition of SRHA to R2A even completely prevented aggregation after one minute (Fig. 2e and f and S2e and f‡) likely due to the overlay of the stabilizing effects of SRHA and surfactant Tween 80.
Another interesting finding is that the zeta potential became slightly more negative after addition of NOM in ASTM and R2A, but not in SAM-5S (Fig. 2g and h). Although small, the differences range between 3 and 5 mV and are statistically significant. Thus, it cannot be excluded that these differences reflect changes in NP surface charge. Thus, NOM alone was not able to modify the zeta potential in the presence of inorganic constituents (SAM-5S), but it may have been able to increase its absolute value in the presence of additional organic compounds (R2A and ASTM). Although the final explanation requires more detailed investigations, the results suggest an interplay between NOM and further organic compounds present in ASTM and R2A or solid phase AgCl(s) precipitates, which were most likely present on the surface of Ag NPs in SAM-5S (see also discussion below).
If verified by further experiments, these findings demonstrate how the interplay between organic compounds and cations and its time dependence can affect dynamics in Ag NP stability. Therefore, using Ag NP pre-aged in TM likely results in different ecotoxicological effects relative to those used immediately after preparation, which was demonstrated for titanium dioxide NPs in ASTM medium.1
Attachment efficiency profiles obtained for the 30 nm Ag NPs in the absence of NOM (Fig. 4) showed two aggregation regimes (i.e., reaction and diffusion limited) and are in compliance with published literature.17,18 The CCC values ranged from 1.6 ± 0.1 mmol L−1 (Ca2+ in ASTM) to 2.3 ± 0.1 mmol L−1 (Mg2+ in SAM-5S) and were by a factor of up to 1.2 higher for Mg2+ than for Ca2+ and by a factor of 1.2–1.4 higher for SAM-5S than for ASTM (Table 1).
ASTM | SAM-5S | R2A | |
---|---|---|---|
a This concentration does not represent classical CCC, but marks the cation concentration at which α becomes larger than 1, indicating the concentration range where non-classical DLVO interaction mechanisms like aggregation by bridging become more important. b n.d.: not determined. | |||
Ca2+ (without NOM) | 1.6 ± 0.1 | 2.2 ± 0.1 | n.d.b |
Ca2+ (with SRHA) | 6.3 ± 1.4a | 4.2 ± 0.1a | n.d.b |
Ca2+ (with SW) | 3.5 ± 0.1 | n.d.b | n.d.b |
Mg2+ (without NOM) | 1.9 ± 0.1 | 2.3 ± 0.1 | 1.7 ± 0.2 |
Mg2+ (with SRHA) | 3.4 ± 0.1 | 2.9 ± 0.1 | 3.6 ± 0.1 |
Mg2+ (with SW) | 2.0 ± 0.1 | n.d.b | n.d.b |
Ca2+ + Mg2+ (without NOM) | 2.0 ± 0.1 | 2.4 ± 0.1 | n.d.b |
The slightly lower CCC and, consequently, the higher efficiency of Ca2+ than Mg2+ to induce aggregation agrees well with the literature14,18 and can be explained by stability constants of citrate complexes formed on the surface of the citrate-stabilized Ag NPs, which are higher with calcium (logK = 8.02 for CaHC6H5O7, logK = 3.5 for CaC6H5O7−) than with magnesium (logK = 7.66 for MgHC6H5O7, logK = 3.38 for MgC6H5O7−).66
On the other hand, the clearly higher CCC of Ca2+ and Mg2+ for SAM-5S than for ASTM despite comparable pH and divalent cation concentrations indicate that in SAM-5S additional stabilization mechanisms are effective. Different concentrations of monovalent cations in the media cannot explain the differences in Ag NP stability since reported CCCs of monovalent cations for citrate-stabilized Ag NPs (48–122 mmol L−1)14,18,67 are much higher than their concentration in the medium (2.43 mmol L−1 in ASTM and 1.06 mmol L−1 in SAM-5S, Table S4‡). Therefore, other TM constituents, namely, vitamins (present in ASTM) or halide ions (present in higher concentration in SAM-5S than in ASTM) are suspected to influence Ag NP stability.
Biotin (vitamin B7), present in ASTM, for example, was found to form polymeric complexes through binding of Ag+ to thioether and carbamide groups at concentrations of 2–25 mg L−1.55,56 Although biotin concentration in ASTM is much lower than these values, it cannot be excluded that such polymeric complexes are also formed on the Ag NP surface and support particle aggregation in ASTM. In order to test this hypothesis, we measured the initial aggregation rates of 30 nm Ag NPs in modified ASTM medium in the absence and presence of Ca2+ (0.7 mmol L−1) as well as in the absence and presence of vitamins (B1, B7 and B12) at different concentrations. The initial aggregation rate (approx. 2 nm min−1) determined in the absence of vitamins did not change significantly in their presence even at 67–100-fold higher vitamin concentrations than present in typical ASTM medium (Fig. S5‡). This indicates that the vitamins used in ASTM medium do not influence the aggregation of Ag NP.
The concentration of Cl− in SAM-5S medium is approximately 20-fold higher than in ASTM medium. Furthermore, SAM-5S medium contains Br− ions, which are not present in ASTM medium. In order to evaluate the role of inorganic anions in the aggregation of Ag NPs, we performed early-stage aggregation experiments for 30 nm Ag NPs in deionized water as well as in modified ASTM medium in the absence and presence of CaSO4, CaCl2, Ca(NO3)2, or CaBr2 at the same Ca2+ concentration (0.7 mmol L−1). In deionized water as well as in modified ASTM medium no aggregation occurred in the presence of Cl− or Br− (Fig. 5a). In contrast to this, aggregation was observed in the presence of SO42− or NO3− at the same Ca2+ concentration (Fig. 5a). Our results are, finally, in good agreement with those of El Badawy et al.,12 who reported a much higher hydrodynamic diameter (determined by DLS) of Ag NPs in the presence of 10 mmol L−1 NaNO3 than in the presence of the same amount of NaCl. In the solutions containing NaCl, no aggregation was observed even at low pH value (pH 3). El Badawy et al.12 explained this effect by the high negative charge of AgCl(s) surface precipitates. The formation of solid phase AgCl(s) or AgBr(s) in our dispersions was confirmed by model calculations for the ASTM medium when modifying the anion composition by substitution of the CaSO4 by CaCl2 or CaBr2 at equivalent Ca2+ concentration (0.7 mmol L−1). The results of these calculations showed that 62.2% and 97.6% of the released silver was present as solid phase AgCl(s) and AgBr(s), respectively (Table S10‡). However, solid AgCl(s) precipitates or the presence of AgCl(s) colloids cannot easily explain a higher stability of Ag NPs in the TM. On the other hand, zeta potentials of Ag NPs measured in ASTM medium modified with CaCl2 or CaBr2 were slightly more negative than in ASTM medium with Ca(NO3)2 (Fig. 5b). Although these differences range only between 3 and 6 mV, they are statistically significant and they could support the idea that negatively charged surface precipitates of AgCl(s) or AgBr(s) may have stabilized nanoparticles in SAM-5S medium. Furthermore, the stabilization of nanoparticles by adsorption of Cl− or Br− cannot be excluded. The idea that halide ions stabilize the Ag NPs in the TM is further supported by the observation that the CCC for citrate-coated Ag NPs determined by Li et al.13 was higher for NaCl (40 mmol L−1) than for NaNO3 (30 mmol L−1). Furthermore, Tejamaya et al.4 reported a reduction of absorbance and appearance of a shoulder at higher wavelengths in surface plasmon resonance spectra for citrate-coated Ag NPs after substitution of Cl− by SO42− or NO3− in 10-fold diluted OECD test medium, indicating, similar to our results, an increasing aggregation in the presence of SO42− and NO3−. Partly opposite effects were reported in another study: Baalousha et al.14 determined smaller CCCs for citrate-coated Ag NPs in NaCl than in Na2SO4 and NaNO3 electrolyte by UV-vis measurements and explained this effect by increasing aggregation due to the possible bridging mechanisms by solid phase AgCl(s). In the presence of divalent cations (i.e., Ca2+ and Mg2+) the influence of anions was less distinct, especially for the experiments using the UV-vis method for the detection of the CCC of Ca2+ and Mg2+. The CCC determined by DLS was slightly higher for CaCl2 than for CaSO4 and Ca(NO3)2 which is in compliance with the above discussed results. Most likely, whether or not the presence of Cl− or Br− stabilizes the Ag NPs depends on the concentrations of these anions and degree of dissolution of Ag NP. In order to clarify to which extent the aggregation state of Ag NPs depends on the concentrations of Cl−, Br−, and released Ag+, further detailed investigations are needed.
Despite the high long-term stability of Ag NPs in R2A (Fig. 2), which is most probably due to the presence of surfactants, it is important to mention that the CCC of Mg2+ (1.7 ± 0.2 mmol L-1) in R2A was even lower than in ASTM and SAM-5S in the absence of NOM (Table 1). Furthermore, even in the absence of Mg2+, attachment efficiency α (0.15) was clearly above zero (Fig. 6), whereas the aggregation of Ag NPs in ASTM and SAM-5S media required Ca2+ or Mg2+ concentrations above 0.5–0.9 mmol L−1 (Fig. 4). One reason for these unexpected findings may be that the organic constituents of the R2A medium contain significant amounts of cations, which had not yet been considered. The total concentration of divalent (Ca2+ and Mg2+) and monovalent (Na+ and K+) cations originating from the organic compounds of the R2A medium was 0.03 and 6.7 mmol L−1, respectively (Table S12‡). Considering that K+ (3.5 mmol L−1) originated from K2HPO4, the total monovalent cation concentration in Mg2+-free R2A medium was approximately 10 mmol L−1. Additional experiments showed that aggregation of Ag NPs in deionized water in the presence of 0.03 mmol L−1 Ca2+ started at a Na+ concentration of approximately 30 mmol L−1 (Fig. S6‡). Therefore, monovalent and divalent cations available in Mg2+-free R2A medium alone cannot explain the increase in hydrodynamic diameter of Ag NPs. Most likely, this effect is induced by organic compounds present in R2A (amino acids, proteins and protein fragments; Table S4‡) despite the high stabilization efficiency of Tween 80. Additional aggregation experiments showed that in the absence of MgSO4 the single organic constituents of R2A medium alone did not induce aggregation of Ag NPs (30 nm). Only the mixtures of individual organic compounds were able to initialize aggregation (Fig. S7‡). Most effective was the mixture of casein and yeast extract, which contain amino acids, proteins and protein fragments. Proteins adsorbing to Ag NP57,59,68 can form a multilayer protein corona on NP surfaces,57,58 which could also explain the fast initial increase in hydrodynamic diameter to 65 nm (Fig. 2) instead of aggregation. However, additional aggregation experiments in Mg2+-free R2A at different Ag NP (30 nm) concentrations showed that particle size remained constant within 10 min, but it increased with increasing NP concentration (Fig. S4‡), such that even the initial increase in hydrodynamic diameter must be at least partly due to aggregation, which is in contrast to the assumption of the sole relevance of the protein corona. Which mechanisms induce the initial aggregation and whether or not the protein corona is also effective (or becomes effective only slowly, preventing further aggregation after some minutes) should be investigated in further detail by assessing the development and architecture of OM coatings in media with complex composition.
The attachment efficiency profiles for Me2+ used as Ca2+–Mg2+ combinations at the Ca2+/Mg2+ ratio of the respective media (Fig. 4e and f) indicated lower CCC of Me2+ in ASTM (2.0 ± 0.1 mmol L−1) than in SAM-5S (2.4 ± 0.1 mmol L−1). Thus, the media would have to be concentrated with respect to Me2+ concentration by a factor of only 1.2 for ASTM but of 2.0 for SAM-5S in order to reach the diffusion-limited regime.
This is in line with the findings for single cations. The total concentrations of divalent cations (Ca2+ + Mg2+ in ASTM and SAM-5S and Mg2+ in R2A) in all original TM (grey vertical lines in Fig. 4e and f and 6) lie in the reaction-limited regime, which predicts the formation of reaction-limited aggregates (RLAs) in the original TM. It is important to note that the Me2+ concentration in ASTM, but not in SAM-5S, is already close to the CCC, such that an overlay between diffusion and reaction control cannot be excluded in ASTM. In contrast to our observation for Ag NP, the results of Nur et al.9 suggest diffusion-limited aggregation for titanium dioxide NPs in several original TM. RLAs are usually more compact and stable compared to the diffusion-limited aggregates (DLAs).69 The difference in aggregation regime between Ag NPs and titanium dioxide NPs thus suggests that organisms are confronted with different types of aggregates in the same test medium depending on the type of NP used.
Addition of NOM reduced α at the cation concentrations below the respective CCCs in all TM (Fig. 4), confirming the generally assumed stabilizing effect of NOM, which was stronger in the presence of Ca2+ than in the presence of Mg2+ (Table 1). This is in contrast to the strong destabilizing effect of Ca2+ on Ag NPs in the absence of NOM. Moreover, the stabilizing effect of SRHA in the presence of Ca2+ was dramatically stronger than that of SW, and the differences between Ca2+ and Mg2+ in the presence of NOM were lower for SW than for SRHA (Table 1 and Fig. 4). This can be a result of the stronger interaction between SRHA and Ca2+ than between SRHA and Mg2+, assuming that the multivalent cations act as a bridging agent between Ag NPs and NOM coating. This is in line with the observation in Ca2+-dominated systems, where the degree of SRHA-Me2+ interactions is higher compared to Mg2+-dominated systems.24,25
In contrast to this, SRHA, but not SW, resulted in α >1 at Ca2+ concentrations above 6.3 ± 1.4 mmol L−1 for ASTM and above 4.2 ± 0.1 mmol L−1 for SAM-5S. Furthermore, α further increased with increasing Ca2+ concentration up to 2.2 ± 0.5 and 3.7 ± 0.1 mmol L−1 in ASTM and SAM-5S, respectively. Also, high Mg2+ concentrations resulted in increased α (1.4), but to a much lower extent than for Ca2+. Such accelerated aggregation by SRHA in the presence of Ca2+ in high concentrations is in line with observations for Ag NPs14,18 and Au NPs24 in the presence of FA or HA and has been explained by bridging of NPs via Ca2+–NOM complexes. The formation of NP aggregates by cation–NOM bridges is not consistent with the classical DLVO theory. Stankus et al.24 reported that Mg2+ can enhance NP aggregation in the presence of SRHA (5 mg L−1 TOC), but to a lower extent than Ca2+. The difference between Ca2+ and Mg2+ was explained by the larger hydration radius of Mg2+ compared to that of Ca2+, leading to a lower tendency of Mg2+ to form inner sphere complexes with the NOM.24 The fact that no effect was observed for Mg2+ in the work of Chen and Elimelech25 is most likely a result of the significantly lower HA concentration (1 mg L−1 TOC) used in their work relative to the present study (9.4 mg L−1 TOC). This demonstrates that besides the concentration of divalent cations, the NOM concentration is a key parameter influencing bridging-determined aggregation.
The lack of aggregation enhancement by SW even in the presence of Ca2+ suggests that the SW constituents tend to undergo insignificant bridging with Ca2+ and Mg2+, which is most probably due to differences in molecular weight, multi-functionality and affinity of functional groups towards Ca2+ and Mg2+. While SW contains a large fraction of polysaccharides, phenolic and carboxylic functional groups are relevant in SRHA, suggesting that coordinative Me2+–NOM interactions are more relevant in SRHA than in SW. In the presence of NOM, aggregation enhancement was also not observed in R2A medium, which underlines the reported strong stabilizing efficiency of Tween 80.60 Furthermore, other organic constituents (proteins and protein fragments) of R2A may have modified the Ag NP surface and by this reduced the probability to form the Me2+–NOM bridges between NPs.
ASTM | SAM-5S | R2A | |
---|---|---|---|
a In mmol L−1/mmol L−1. b n.d.: not determined. | |||
Salt composition | |||
Ca2+/Mg2+a | 0.69/1 | 1/0.25 | 0/0.2 |
Cl−/Br−a | 0.11/0 | 2.05/0.01 | 0/0 |
Formation of Ag(I) species | |||
Ag+ concentration | ++++ | ++ | + |
Predominant Ag(I) species | Ag+ | AgCl(aq) | Ag+; Ag+–protein complexes? |
Impact of NOM | NOM reduces Ag+ | SRHA reduces Ag+ | SRHA increases Ag+ |
SW > SRHA | |||
Aggregation and colloidal stability | |||
Tendency to aggregate | ++++ | +++ | + |
CCC(Mg2+)/CCC(Ca2+)a | 1.9/1.6 | 2.3/2.2 | 1.7/n.d.b |
NP stabilization | No effect of vitamins | By halide surface precipitates? | By Tween 80, protein corona? |
Impact of NOM in original TM (at low Me2+ concentrations) | Electrosteric stabilization | Electrosteric stabilization | Electrosteric stabilization |
SW ≤ SRHA (short term) | |||
SW > SRHA (long term) | |||
Effect of Me2+ in the presence of NOM | Ca2+ enhances electrosteric stabilization compared to Mg2+ | ||
SRHA > SW | |||
Me2+ induces bridging-determined aggregation at high concentrations: | No bridging-determined aggregation | ||
Ca2+: >6.3 mmol L−1 | Ca2+: >4.2 mmol L−1 | ||
Mg2+: >3.4 mmol L−1 | Mg2+: >2.9 mmol L−1 | ||
General strength of cation effects | Ca2+ > Mg2+ based on Me2+–citrate and Me2+–NOM interactions | ||
Expected characteristics relevant for ecotoxicological potential of Ag NP | |||
Dissolved species | ++++ (Ag+) | +++ (Ag+; AgCl(aq)) | + (Ag+) |
NP surface | Ag–citrate | AgCl(s) | Ag–protein? |
Effectiveness of NOM coating | +++ | +++++ | + |
Aggregate size | ++++ | ++++ | + |
Aggregate type | Reaction-limited aggregates | Reaction-limited aggregates small clusters? | |
Overlay with diffusion limitation | |||
Dynamic aggregation properties within test duration | Aggregate size increases with time. Size and morphology strongly affected by NP concentration and solution chemistry | Aggregate size constant but depends on NP concentration | |
NOM-bridged aggregates | Low relevance but expected relevance in hard water | ||
Impacts of changes in TM composition | |||
Addition of Cl− | Stabilizes NP, AgCl(s) on NP surface | Enhances aggregation by AgCl(s) bridging? | AgCl(s) on NP surface? |
Reduction in Ca2+/Mg2+ ratio | Reduces aggregate size and stabilizing effect of SRHA coating | ||
Modifying NOM composition | SW: coating based on NOM–Ag interactions | Effects overbalanced by Tween 80 effect? | |
SRHA: coating based on Ca2+–NOM interactions |
In all TM, reaction-limited aggregates are expected, with the consequence that their morphology and stability are sensitive to the TM composition and NP concentration. These aggregates are very small in R2A medium, such that their properties will differ strongly from those of ASTM and SAM-5S. Aggregate types and dynamics are expected to be comparable between ASTM and SAM-5S media, but zeta potential, aggregate sizes and NP reaction on the addition of different types of NOM and on the changes in concentration and composition of multivalent cations differ between these two media. Furthermore, the Me2+ concentration in ASTM is close to its CCC, suggesting the starting relevance of diffusion limitation for aggregation. These differences are mostly due to different initial molar ratios of Ca2+/Mg2+ between the two media and the presence or absence of halide ions. In the absence of strong stabilizing agents like Tween 80, the most prominent differences among all TM are the concentration of Cl− and the dominance of Ca2+.
With respect to the inorganic constituents relevant for Ag NP dissolution, surface reaction and aggregation, the composition of the SAM-5S resembles that of the Rhine water discussed by Metreveli et al.23 and suggests that Ag NP aggregates are at least partly stabilized in the presence of Cl−, but with a distinct speciation of Ag(I) in this water. More generally speaking, our results suggest that Ag NPs may be only incompletely stabilized by NOM and halides in natural waters, and NOM quality in addition to ion composition will strongly affect the nature of the aggregates forming. Thus, as long as NOM in natural water is similar to SW, bridging-determined aggregates in that water will have low relevance compared to waters rich in NOM similar to SRHA.
The results of our study do not only show that by using different TM, the same Ag NPs will likely have different ecotoxicological potentials, but they also open perspectives for targeted research on the impact of individual Ag NP species on ecotoxicological potential. For example, increasing the Ca2+/Mg2+ concentration ratio in the absence of NOM will enhance aggregation. By modifying the nature of the NOM additive of the TM and the ratio between Ca2+ and Mg2+, the effectiveness of the electrosteric stabilization by NOM will be modified and bridging-determined aggregation may be induced. The use of SW and the dominance of Mg2+ will favor aggregates formed on the basis of extended DLVO interactions. In ecotoxicological tests, these composition parameters could be adjusted within ranges where no or low effects on the vitality of test organisms are expected in order to obtain Ag NPs with different coating stability, surface and aggregate characteristics, and concentration of dissolved Ag(I) species. It is furthermore essential to know how ecotoxicity results obtained in conventional TM could be transferred to environmental systems, the composition of which differs often significantly from that of the TM with the consequence of different aggregation properties.6 Taking advantage of the knowledge of NP transformations in TM with modified chemical composition will, therefore, allow the prediction of specific NP characteristics and aggregation states in natural environmental systems, which may help in a second step to extrapolate ecotoxicological findings to the field.
Footnotes |
† The authors declare no competing financial interest. |
‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Details of the Ag NP synthesis method; preparation method of SRHA stock solution; calculation of centrifugation duration; chemical composition of TM; pH values in TM after the addition of NOM and Ag NP; chemical composition of the stock solutions used for early stage aggregation experiments; input parameters used in the model calculations; speciation of silver in TM; metal concentrations in organic compounds used for preparation of R2A; particle size distribution (DLS) and TEM images of Ag NP; hydrodynamic diameter of Ag NP in TM for the first 60 min as a function of exposure time; hydrodynamic diameter of Ag NP in ASTM and R2A at different particle concentrations; initial aggregation rates of 30 nm Ag NP in modified ASTM medium in the absence and presence of vitamins (B1, B7 and B12); initial aggregation rates of 30 nm Ag NP in deionized water in the presence of 0.03 mmol L−1 Ca2+ and at different Na+ concentrations; initial aggregation rates of 30 nm Ag NP in deionized water and in Mg2+-free R2A medium in the absence and presence of individual organic constituents of R2A and their mixtures. See DOI: 10.1039/c5en00152h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |